Faith and Rationality

  • Thread starter Thread starter wasmit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi wasmit,

I admire your refusal to accept anything nebulous thrown at you from a database. Let us try to summarize simply what some people have been trying to say.

Christian faith is first of all an intellectual act. It is not an act of confidence. It says, "I am convinced of this truth because God revealed it.

The **will **is involved because it goes against our nature to accept something merely on the word of another, in this case, God. So we have to say to ourselves, “This is not just anybody. It is God, the source of all truth. All right, I’ll accept it.” This is an act of the will, moving the intellect, but not replacing it.

But this submission of the will is by no means automatic. In order for it to happen, we need to be helped along. This help comes from God. It is called grace. “Grace” is from a latin word, which translates a Greek word that means “gift”. It is a free gift from God. (Why the gift is given to some and not to others is something we don’t know, and it is futile to try and understand it. God is infinite being and there are some things our mind cannot cope with… at least in this world. )

When we are baptized, even as children, we ask for “the gift of faith”. This is the ability to accept intellectually the truths that God has revealed. This helps us grow in our faith as we come in contact with the word of God and the truths of our faith. Confirmation helps us put these truths into practice in our dealings with others and with the world in general. All the sacraments, with their specific gifts help us live out our Christian faith.

I hope my post has helped you understand the subject better. Farewell.

Verbum
 
Hi wasmit,

What I have gathered from this post is that the definition of faith is “belief that something is true because God said it is true”

Is this an accurate definition?

Yes. What do you think ?

Verbum
that’s fine by me, it is easy to understand!

This also raises a further question - How do we know what God said? In order to use faith to reach a true conclusion about a particular issue X, we must be certain that god said that X is true. If we are wrong about what God said, then the application of faith to a particular issue will lead to a false conclusion.
 
Hi wasmit,

I admire your refusal to accept anything nebulous thrown at you from a database. Let us try to summarize simply what some people have been trying to say.

Christian faith is first of all an intellectual act. It is not an act of confidence. It says, "I am convinced of this truth because God revealed it.

The **will **is involved because it goes against our nature to accept something merely on the word of another, in this case, God. So we have to say to ourselves, “This is not just anybody. It is God, the source of all truth. All right, I’ll accept it.” This is an act of the will, moving the intellect, but not replacing it.
This is a clear explanation, thankyou. Is the following paraphrase fair:

I choose (will) to be convinced (intellect) that X is true, because God said it is true, and he is a 100% reliable person to believe".

Is that a fair paraphrase?
But this submission of the will is by no means automatic. In order for it to happen, we need to be helped along. This help comes from God. It is called grace. “Grace” is from a latin word, which translates a Greek word that means “gift”. It is a free gift from God. (Why the gift is given to some and not to others is something we don’t know, and it is futile to try and understand it. God is infinite being and there are some things our mind cannot cope with… at least in this world. )
Ok, from this paragraph i understand that grace is a gift. That doesn’t tell me much. Can you explain further?
When we are baptized, even as children, we ask for “the gift of faith”. This is the ability to accept intellectually the truths that God has revealed.
How does baptism change anything in relation to the intellectual acceptance of claims, when anyone of any religion or no religion can intellectually accept claims?
This helps us grow in our faith as we come in contact with the word of God and the truths of our faith. Confirmation helps us put these truths into practice in our dealings with others and with the world in general. All the sacraments, with their specific gifts help us live out our Christian faith.

I hope my post has helped you understand the subject better. Farewell.

Verbum
When you say “grow in faith”, are you using a different definition of the word faith? i ask this because “Grow in [belief that something is true because God said it is true]” doesn’t make sense.

If you are using a different definition of the word faith, what is this second definition?

your post is very helpful.
 
This is a clear explanation, thankyou. Is the following paraphrase fair:

I choose (will) to be convinced (intellect) that X is true, because God said it is true, and he is a 100% reliable person to believe".

Yes.

Ok, from this paragraph i understand that grace is a gift. That doesn’t tell me much. Can you explain further?

A gift is something that you have not earned. Thre is nothing we can do that would entitle us to receive anything from God.

How does baptism change anything in relation to the intellectual acceptance of claims, when anyone of any religion or no religion can intellectually accept claims?

Baptism helps our **will **accept what is presented to our intellect as God’s revelation.

When you say “grow in faith”, are you using a different definition of the word faith? i ask this because “Grow in [belief that something is true because God said it is true]” doesn’t make sense.

Growing in faith means accepting with ever increasing understanding and convicition the truths proposed to us as well as the ability to put them into practice in our lives.

How do we know what God said? In order to use faith to reach a true conclusion about a particular issue X, we must be certain that god said that X is true. If we are wrong about what God said, then the application of faith to a particular issue will lead to a false conclusion.

Our faith rises or falls on the resurrection of Christ. He accepted the Hebrew scriptures and the apostles he appointed gave us the Christian scriptures. He also said and did many things “that are not written down in this book” (John 20,30) giving the apostles the mission to continue his work. But as proof of the genuiness of his mission he offered to die and come back to life. That is why we believe in the word of God as expressed in the scriptures and in the teachings of Christ’s church.
If Christ did not resurrect, your faith is vain (…) If we have put our hope in Christ for this life only, then we are the unhapppiest of men."
1 Cor 15,16ff)

From generation to generation (about 65 grandfathers), the testimony of Christ’s resurrection has been transmitted to those who are called to the faith.

That is what we live by.

Verbum
 
I can’t watch videos.
thats a shame. it was a good one.

basically what hes saying is that man has a desire for fulfillment that cant be satiated by the passing things of this world. unlike an animal that will get what it wants and just lay down in contentment, mans desires are never fulfilled because we were “wired” with the understanding that there has to be more than just this fleeting life - that basically we were made for god and we will not find true peace/fulfillment/contentment outside of god. he says that it is this desire that is proof of gods existence, like hunger is proof that there is food. the proof is in the hunger/desire for god.

i think this is worth contemplating, however, a few things come to mind:

it is possible that man has convinced himself (and convinced others through religion) that these desires are for god and not simply momentary feelings of dissatisfaction or despair or the result of living a selfish or greedy life.

true some people find fulfillment in religion/faith - i once did - but this still is not proof. if i convince myself that i will find ultimate fulfillment every time i eat a twinkie i will find fulfillment that way. its about programming yourself.

i also believe that people who are selfless are fulfilled (something christ taught) and even in the absence of belief in god i find fulfillment in loving others and serving them.

so i’m not sure i buy his argument, but i’m willing to give it more thought.
 
…When someone says that they have faith that muhammad split the moon in two, they are saying that they absolutely believe this claim.
I don’t understand how that conflicts with anything I’ve said.
ok, I think I sort of get what this means. Can you explain “The free and undeserved gift that God gives us to respond to our vocation to become his adopted children” further? It seems vague and wishy-washy to me.
It’s perfectly clear to me, I can’t figure out how to say it any better than that. But that’s a bit tangential - perhaps it’s best left for a separate conversation.
How does this definition make sense in the statement “I have faith that I will win the competion”, or “I have faith that mohammad split the moon in two” when there is no adhering or binding occuring, and there is no other person?
It may or may not make sense depending on the circumstances. It might help to remember that people frequently engage in the sloppy use of language.

An act of faith can also be an act of credulity. An example might be going into a slum and giving money to someone I’ve never met before because he says he’ll come back and give me a stolen radio.
It’s the same principle for both examples - one cannot be 100% certain about these two things.,None of these examples (money lending, marriage, colleague’s work) involve faith, because there is not 100% certainty. So, how do these examples support your claim that it’s impossible to live as a human being without exercising faith ?
Most of the time I hear folks say that faith requires no certainty at all - this is the first time I’ve ever heard anyone say that it requires 100% certainty. Both are false. It really has little to do with how certain you are or whether or not you’re correct in your belief. It’s about your response.
 
I think we might be talking about different degrees of belief.

If a person said “I have faith[secular definition] that the share price of X company will increase within one week”, I take that to mean that they are 100% absolutely certain that the price will rise. This is irrational because prices fluctuate, so he may be wrong. It he said “It is probable that the price of X company will rise within one week because of reasons Y and Z”, that is not inherently irrational. However the second quote (probable) does not involve faith[secular definition].

Using your stock market example, You said “you have faith that your stocks will go up”. Inserting the definition, you said “you have Mental acceptance of and confidence in a claim as truth without proof supporting the claim that your stocks will go up”

Similarly for the other examples, string theory and love for/from a partner, 100% certainty is irrational, but less than 100% certainty is not.

This is why I say it is irrational, because it is 100% certainty without proof.
First, please try to be consistent with you argument. You are adding things to your definition of faith that were not there to begin with. At no point did your definition include “100% certainty of faith” or as you put it in the first paragraph of the response: “100% absolute certainty.” You are attempting to narrow the definition of faith in such a manner that if anything is rational then it is not faith: that is dishonest given your definition. Stick to your original terms: faith is acceptance and confidence in something without having proof.

You have already judged certain examples of accepting and having confidence in something without having proof as rational. My examples were completely logical based on that definition. Inserting the original definition into the stock market example only demonstrates that it makes sense: “you have accepted and have confidence, despite lack of proof, that your stocks will go up.” You have no proof of the future: no one does. You can have confidence in it, based on events in the past, but in no way do you actually have proof that your stock will increase or that your marriage will be successful. You simply have no proof that your love for that woman/man will last for a lifetime, but in saying “I do” you have demonstrated and vocalized your acceptance and confidence in an unprovable claim.

You seem to think that Christians always have 100% certainty in what they believe, but the fact is, that is not true, and any Christian that tells you otherwise is lying to themselves and to you. Just as with buying a stock, we have looked at reasons X and Y and concluded that it is logical not only to believe in God but to love Him. But in no way does it constitute definitive proof. Atheists have done the same: they have looked at reasons X and Y and concluded that it is not logical to believe in God. But in no way can they prove God does not exist.

Second, the debate on “credulity” versus “faith” is misplaced. The difference between faith and credulity/gullibility is in the eye of the beholder. One has a positive connotation, the other a negative. If you can successfully delineate the two, you should move onto some other ones: one man’s rebellion versus another man’s revolution, one man’s terrorism versus another man’s freedom fighting, etc. In trying to establish criteria for the words, you are explicitly judging the results (ask a republican if believing in Obama’s “yes we can” is faith or credulity and then ask a democrat). One man’s faith is another man’s folly. You’re not going to get anywhere on this point.
What does this mean? Surely if God was calling for something, he would just make it happen.
God cannot compel humans to be good or to accept Him anymore than I can compel a child to love me. God created humankind with free will, knowing that in doing so, He was allowing us to choose something other than Him. If God was to “just make it happen” He would be violating our free will, which would kind of defeat the point of the gift of free will to begin with.
I got lost here. You seem to be adding 3-4 different things into the definition, that don’t really mean anything to me.
Sorry…I’m just trying to explain a statement that is wrapped in many, many layers of theology. Some of those key assumptions would be: all good that we have is a gift from God; free will allows us to choose between doing God’s will (i.e., that which is good) and our will (if it opposes God’s will, that which is bad); when we do good, it is because God has given us the tools and we have chosen to use them; no truth in this world can deny God - all truth points to God; humans have been created to seek God - it is part of what makes us human; etc…
 
hi, sorry for my slow reply. Hopefully I will respond specifically to each person in more detail soon. Just a quick question that seems to be causing our misunderstanding of each other: Does using faith on a particular issue imply 100% certainty?

Using the catholic definition, When someone says:
I have faith that erecting the Berlin Wall was the right thing to do at the time.
I have faith that I will win the competition tomorrow.
I have faith that muhammad split the moon in two.
I have faith that the parents that I live with are my biological parents.
I have faith that the apostle john wrote the gospel of john.
I have faith that jesus was crucified to death.

Are they meaning that they are 100% certain that it is true?
Are they meaning that they are are extremely certain, i.e. 99.9% certain that it is true?
Are they meaning that they are fairly sure. e.g. 95% certain that it is true
Are they meaning that it is more likely to be true than false, i.e. 65% certain that it is true?

from your friend,
 
Hi wasmit,

We believe the truths defined by the Church with 100% certainty. As for the rest, our certainty can vary between 0% and 99%.

Verbum
 
So, what is the definition of faith when considering an issue upon which the Catholic Church has not taken a position?
 
Hi wasmit,

I think you may be confusing faith with confidence.

Verbum
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top