Fire pits: Immoral or okay?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Loud-living-dogma
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Catholics are permitted to light fires outside their homes, in small fire pits, if the following conditions are met:
  1. No individual with asthma resides within a 5 KM radius of your home;
  2. There is at least one individual with red hair (symbolizing fire and thus a good sign) living within a 5 KM radius of your home;
  3. On the day on which you light your fire, the Pope has consumed at least three cups of coffee and one glass of wine; and,
  4. Its a Tuesday within three days (before or after) a solemnity or feast of the Lord.
If any of the above conditions are not satisfied, lighting a fire outside one’s home is a very grave sin. So grave, in fact, that the resulting automatic excommunication can only be lifted by the Apostolic Signatura in Rome

 
Last edited:
What can we do? There are thousands of unregistered fire pits on the street. Worse yet, people can make their own!!!
 
Last edited:
Again, depends on what you are burning and why.

If you are burning 100% natural wood (dead tree branches, etc) - no issue

If you are burning chemicals, treated wood, trash, etc; then yes, that’s most likely not a good thing.

Also, are you burning the wood for reasons most people would find natural & acceptable? Or are you doing it for vain reasons?
 
Last edited:
Have you had a bad experience with open pit fires or something? You just seem to have something personal against them


There is nothing immoral about having a bonfire. Just follow your local code and do it responsibly. And if you know the neighbor has asthma then yeah you should probably ask them. But one open fire in a backyard every now and then is hardly going to ruin the air quality past a 10ft radius.
 
I will say, I was once in a city where the entire population almost exclusively used wood stoves and open fires for their heating and cooking. And not just burning wood either- in fact probably not much wood burning at all. The smog was pretty bad, and in the winter, at night, you could actually see the smog gathering and thickening and pooling over the buildings. Like malevolent mist in a sci-fi movie. If you slept anywhere without good ventilation you would wake up with a nice headache from smoke inhalation. You could taste it and smell it 24/7. My nose was always stuffed

 
Last edited:
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
You’ve obviously never seen a neighborhood destroyed and families torn apart due to a poorly understood Fire Pit.
 
Last edited:
Maybe not, but I have seen some badly burnt s’mores in my day. You’d think after so many you become hardened to the site of them, but I find myself in the throes of fresh anguish each time. Who could treat name brand marshmallows in such a way, really

 
My neighbours and I make bonfires and burn garden refuse,it’s more difficult for me because I have to have the wind direction just right so they don’t get the smoke.But then again,you can make a fire burn hot and quickly so it doesn’t smoulder
little smoke
If people have the right technique and the right sort of firewood there is very little smoke.
 
Honestly, I was just fascinated when the topic came up on another thread, how seemingly reasonable people seemed rather inconsiderate about their fire pit use. And if people called them on it, the attitude seemed to be “Just deal with it. Stay inside and close your windows.” They sounded like heavy smokers circa 1972. So I just wondered how people do feel about loving their neighbors, if they have breathing issues, if that conflicts with what people want to do (have fires whenever they want).
 
The trouble with the standard, “if your neighbours have breathing issues” is that it is set too high. “Not wanting to acquire breathing issues” should be a sufficient reason for a neighbour to respect the air you wish to breathe.

Think of it like the canary in the mine. The canary warns the miners if there is a build up of carbon monoxide. It is more sensitive to air quality problems than either mice or people. Just because the miners heeded the warning and left the mine alive doesn’t mean that they didn’t suffer from the buildup of gases.

Likewise, people with asthma are more sensitive to smoke, but that doesn’t mean the smoke isn’t affecting people without asthma negatively.

As with all safety issues, there is always a contingent of people who feel ignoring an air quality problem is easier than changing their habits.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top