Thanks for the comments. I pretty much agree with everything you say, and if you think of it as a rebuttal to my earlier post, then I didn’t explain myself clearly enough.
All right. And I’m glad to avoid a pitched disagreement.
You say that husband has final say in decisions, yet you say that he can’t give a legitimate order. The two ideas are in conflict. There is a disagreement, the husband makes a final decision, he tells the wife to abide by his decision. That is an order.
Not necessarily. Although I don’t like the analogy, this would be closer to a golden vote than to giving an order. The head of the family picks the course of action, the rest defer. This isn’t like, “I want you to put on that polka dot dress today, dinner shall be steak, well fried, and you aren’t going anywhere out of the house today,” or some equal nonsense.
To revisit the previous examples: a parent can send his child to its room or tell the child to do some cleaning up (right there and now). An officer can make a soldier do a heckload of things right there and now according to the officer’s picking, albeit at the risk of some trouble for the officer if this resembles bullying. A boss can interfere with your working schedule and pile some urgent work on you, interrupting whatever you were doing. Or remove you from a project and tell you to leave the room when you try talking about it. All of these things are orders. I don’t believe the husband, even as the head of the family, has such rights regarding his wife. I would think her dignity puts a bar to all of this. To go on farther: to be bound by an order unless the thing ordered would be a sin is a standard pretty much for monastic obedience. In other relationships, like the ones we discussed, an order can be illegal and/or not an order because it violates your rights and/or exceeds the competence of the person trying to give that order. In my view, a husband trying to inflict his choice, to feel like a jolly little lord and master, or just being a pain in the side, falls well out of any idea of legitimate authority (in fact, more annoying than George III was as of the Declaration of Independence, not like George III was lawful authority in Britain, since that would be Bonnie Prince Charlie

).
The husband’s role is one of responsiblity and service, not one of bullying and ego.
True and that is why he is not supposed even to try such silly things as micromanaging his wife.
The Catholic ideal is for the husband and wife to model themselves on the new Adam and the new Eve- Our Lord and Our Lady. Mary is the perfect Queen, she obeys the every command of the Lord. The Lord is the perfect King, denying no request of His Lady.
Right but we aren’t perfect and while a saintly woman might try to change her idiotic-egotic husband by obeying his silly commands, I don’t believe a woman is actually bound by any form of obedience where she, simply put, would have to obey commands.