My husband and I have a conversion story that was actually published in both our parish bulletin and, eventually, the diocese bulletin.
My husband was raised Protestant but always had a feeling something was missing. He went to Mass once when he was nine and was taken aback by the reverence of communion. He wondered why the priest held up the host and actually quoted scripture by saying “this
is the body of Christ” instead of saying it was “in memory” at his Church. He asked his mother this question and couldn’t get an answer.
Time went on and he became more and more unhappy with his church. He was raised Pentecostal and is incredibly shy and very introverted. He wanted to convert to Catholicism but was disheartened by the vast number of Cafeteria Catholics he met (including a priest!).
But he kept reading about the Church and its history and began to study himself out of Pentecostalism and into other Churches he thought were more genuine. He tried Presbyterianism and Calvinism…and was unimpressed with both.
He came close to attending RCIA three separate times. Each time he’d talk himself out of it.
Then I came into the picture. I was a fallen away cradle Catholic. I was raised in a “Catholic” family. We were water, rice and dirt Catholics. I was baptized and sent to a very poor Sunday school at my neighborhood parish.
My parents did absolutely nothing to raise us in the faith except help us learn a couple of mandatory prayers and only brought us to regular Mass a couple of months before we were to receive our First Communion.
I stopped Sunday school soon after, with no objection from anyone, and was never confirmed.
I grew into an agnostic who thought she “knew” everything about Christianity and how “wrong” it was and how “crazy” people were to believe in it.
I met my husband. We started dating. He was in the military and was sent on an 8 month training deployment soon after. We got to know each other through endless hours on the phone.
This led to a lot of discussion about Christianity. What he said made perfect sense.
When he came home around Christmas we watched The Nativity Story together and went to midnight Mass.
Watching that movie did something for me. It moved me so much and opened my heart to Jesus.
But I still didn’t go to Church. I just started reading the bible and praying.
Going to a Protestant church wasn’t really an option for me. I went to one service at my husband’s mother’s Church and was scared and really confused.
I didn’t like the band and I didn’t like the casualness of the preaching. I didn’t like the openness of it…or the alter call.
My husband and I moved in together…we were making it all up as we went along. No one saw anything wrong with us co-habitating. I had no idea it was so wrong.
Predictably…and after being together for 3 years…I found out I was pregnant.
This was when everything changed.
He proposed to me soon after and we started looking into getting married. I wanted to be married in the Church.
I finally started reading into Catholicism and exactly what it taught and why.
I was horrified. Absolutely horrified. I was horrified at myself. I couldn’t believe how wrong I was and how wrong we had been.
I was also angry that I had never been taught about morality. My parents, the Church I went to during my childhood.
Even my soon-to-be husband knew about this all but still caved to everything.
Meanwhile…my husband was seriously looking into conversion. He started going to a local parish because he liked the messages on the Parish sign. They were conservative and not watered down.
He went in to talk to the Priest and the Parish director. They weren’t like other Catholics he had met.
They actually believed everything the Church taught and were very Orthodox.
He started going to Mass and adoration.
A couple of months later…I did too. Then we both started RCIA.
It was the longest, hardest year of my life. I was in school full time, working part time, going to RCIA, planning for a baby and planning for a wedding…and we got approved for a house loan and started house hunting too.
In this order…we finished RCIA, had our daughter a week later, he was fully received into the Church about a week after that, closed on our house a month later, baptized our daughter a week after we closed on the house…and a week after that we were sacramentally married. Two days after our wedding I was confimed and a week after that we moved into our house.
The Holy Spirit was with us the whole time…I didn’t know it at the time…but, looking back, it’s seriously obvious.
God is amazing…isn’t He?
