Fr Hardon’s “signs” of disordered attachment

  • Thread starter Thread starter TominAdelaide
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TominAdelaide

Guest
From Fr Hardon’s “Catholic Catechism”:

Self-Love and Detachment. Assuming that the object I possess is not inherently sinful, I can still be unduly attached to it, as may be recognized by certain signs. Some of these are external, and others can only be experienced internally.

The standard hierarchy of values—supernatural, spiritual, intellectual, and material—may be applied here. So that if, for example, I am more concerned with an intellectual project than with my spiritual obligations to the evident detriment of the latter, I ought to suspect undue affection for the former.
  • If I find myself habitually taking complacence in some possession, to the point where I tend to contemn or pity others for lacking what I have, this is a sign of inordinate self-love.
  • If I often lose peace of mind from definable or undefinable causes, on account of what I have or do, I am too attached to the object, person, or practice, since ordinate affection, being orderly, produces tranquillity of mind, which is the essence of peace.
  • If I am always afraid of losing or being hindered in the use of some gift or possession, or if I feel dissatisfied with what I have, whether its amount, quality, or perfection, I am too enamored of the object because the right kind of affection precludes such anxiety.
  • If I regularly talk about my achievement along certain lines or advertise what I have for no better reason than the pleasure I get from being recognized, this is a sign of disorder in the appetitive faculties.
  • If I am inclined to envy others for some kind of talent, production, or property that I feel outshines or obscures my own, this is a danger signal pointing to the need for greater self-control.
  • If I tend to be jealous of what I have, slow to share it with others, or fearful that others may acquire the same, I am overly in love with the creature, no matter how lawfully acquired or how holy the thing may be in itself.
The masters of Christian asceticism state without exception that the test of true detachment is the willingness either to keep or to put away a creature to which a person has become strongly attracted. Why, we ask, should this be so?

Whenever a creature produces an undue attraction, the fault must not be sought in the object as such, but rather in me, precisely because the same creature may be safely possessed by someone else without detriment or even with positive benefit to his spiritual life. Perhaps I have not received the grace necessary both to keep physically and spiritually to profit from the disturbing creature. Or I may be lacking, culpably or otherwise, in those qualities of mind and temperament needed to overcome the natural seductiveness of what disturbs my peace of mind. Or most certainly, the state of life to which God has called me makes demands on my generosity and self-sacrifice that cannot be properly fulfilled except at the cost of being freed of certain inordinate affections.
 
Can somebody translate that to English?
If I find myself habitually taking complacence in some possession, to the point where I tend to contemn or pity others for lacking what I have, this is a sign of inordinate self-love.
“I feel so sorry for those around me who aren’t as smart as me; they’ll never see the beauty and wonder in the world as one with a gifted brain like my own can.”

“I don’t waste my time with dumb people; it simply isn’t worth it.”
If I often lose peace of mind from definable or undefinable causes, on account of what I have or do, I am too attached to the object, person, or practice, since ordinate affection, being orderly, produces tranquillity of mind, which is the essence of peace.
“I can’t understand this!!! This can’t be, I’ve been staring at this problem since yesterday and I’ve not gotten anywhere! I’m smart, I can’t not understand this! I can’t be stupid! Being smart is who I am!”
If I am always afraid of losing or being hindered in the use of some gift or possession, or if I feel dissatisfied with what I have, whether its amount, quality, or perfection, I am too enamored of the object because the right kind of affection precludes such anxiety.
“I’ll drink poison before I let my mind rot due to Alzheimers or advanced age. I can’t bear to be without it.”
If I regularly talk about my achievement along certain lines or advertise what I have for no better reason than the pleasure I get from being recognized, this is a sign of disorder in the appetitive faculties.
“Did I ever tell you about that time I solved a problem that my professor’s own favorite Ph.D student couldn’t when I was an undergrad? Yes? Do humor me as I tell it again: I’m quite proud of it.”
If I am inclined to envy others for some kind of talent, production, or property that I feel outshines or obscures my own, this is a danger signal pointing to the need for greater self-control.
“That smug little brat, proving me wrong! He must think he was so clever pulling me aside privately to tell me I was wrong, and all the more with that infuriating ‘polite’ manner of his! It’d be a shame if a guy like that took a long fall off a cliff; that big brain of his might cause a crater from the impact.”
If I tend to be jealous of what I have, slow to share it with others, or fearful that others may acquire the same, I am overly in love with the creature, no matter how lawfully acquired or how holy the thing may be in itself.
“What, you want me to explain this? I didn’t learn this so I could spread it to everyone who asks like a disease. Why should you reap the profit off what took my time and gifts to understand? Go figure out yourself. It’s not that hard anyway.”
 
Last edited:
Can somebody translate that to English?
I have listed a few quotes that hopefully simplify the idea of detachment Fr Hardon is referring to:

“If anyone can rob you of your peace of mind you depend too much on that person for your happiness.” (Grow Program, The Program of Growth to Maturity, page 32)

“Man is disturbed not by things, but by the views he takes of them.” — Epictetus

“The man who knows himself to be a son of God is always happy and never loses his peace of mind.” (Fr Francis Fernandez, “In Conversation with God”)

“A soul that loves God is not disturbed by any misfortune that may happen to her.” (St Alphonsus Liguori, “Sunday Sermons”)

”Whatsoever shall befall the just man, it shall not make him sad." (Proverbs 12:21)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top