My brother’s parish started GOF this past year. Admittedly this is second-hand but these are my thoughts.
I looked up the web site when my SIL first told me about it. I wasn’t sure I was in the right place. It doesn’t mention the Catholic Church anywhere. The only clue are the names of the sacraments.
I am sure there are different ways to implement the program but this is what my brother’s parish did. They held an event once a month and mailed home a packet of materials. If you missed an event, the materials were not self explanatory so you just had to go it alone or wait for next month.
The program was billed to be done by family groups. But the activities are divided by age. With my brother’s two children, they had to choose between staying as a family but having one child in the ‘wrong’ age group or splitting off - one parent for each child. If you had only one parent or more than 2 kids you wouldn’t have that second option.
I teach CCE - second grade this past year. We know that maybe half of the kids are in families where they get little faith formation at home. They may not even attend Mass regularly. We hope that a few kernals of what we teach sink in and maybe percolate up later in life. GOF will not attract these families (in my opinion). It will mostly get those families that are already actively teaching the faith at home and are eager for more resources and tools. What about those other kids?
I should note that in my brother’s parish, they have “successfully” seperated sacrament prep from regular CCE for years. They have a mandatory meeting in the Fall and give the parents a workbook to do with their child to prepare for First Confession in Dec. Then, after Christmas there is a second meeting to do the same thing for First Communion. All the teaching and determining if the child is prepared is left up to the parents. It’s on the honor system so if the parents go to the meeting and also show up for rehersal, they are good to go.
But I digress.