Has Artificial Contraception Reduced Abortions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JamalChristophr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your argument requires that somehow, magically, there was enough of a failure in the bc that a healthy, viable ovum was released.

This is already a problem for you as there’s some research out there that seems to indicate that “breakthrough ovulation” ovums are smaller, less viable
But this also assumes that every ovum that breaks through is 1. viable and 2. fertilized and 3. rejected by the uterus.

You have absolutely no data to show that this is the case. None.
You have, essentially, an argument from silence. All those are all junk, as a rule.
Respectfully, the position that I am making is not my position. It is the medical community’s position. They are the ones who are saying that this is how the pill works, not me. I have attached to various posts four different links to show this is how the pill works: Priests for Life (with a statement from OB/GYN physician Thomas Hilgers), Verywell (which article was reviewed by an MD), WebMD, and Columbia University. If you wish you can discuss it with them and tell them they are incorrect; that their research is “magic”; that it is “junk”.

Blessings
 
Reuben

I’m sorry if this has confused you. The thread started with a question as to whether or not the use of contraception increased or decreased the number of abortions. I do not recall that the Church’s teaching on contraception, per se, was discussed at all. In any case, Vonsalza is correct, the Church prohibits the use of any contraception.

The current discussion that Vonsalza and I are having is in what is the way does the pill work. I have taken the position that one of the ways that the pill works (in addition to preventing ovulation and impeding sperm migration) is to impede the implantation of a zygote (a human person) into the mother’s womb. I have provided links to support that position.

Blessings
 
http://www.usccb.org/issues-and-act...o-contraception-does-not-reduce-abortions.cfm

"4. Studies show that greater access to contraception does not reduce unintended pregnancies and abortions.

Increasing access to contraception gives teens a false sense of security, leading to earlier onset of sexual activity and more sexual partners, which counteracts any reduction in unintended pregnancies.

Researchers in Spain examined patterns of contraceptive use and abortions in Spain over a ten-year period from 1997-2007. Their findings, published in the journal Contraception in January 2011, were that a 63 percent increase in the use of contraceptives was accompanied by a 108 percent increase in the rate of elective abortions.10

In July 2009 results were published from an expensive three-year program at 54 sites, funded by England’s Department of Health, seeking to “reduce teenage pregnancy” through, among other things, sex education and advice on access to family planning beginning at ages 13-15. “No evidence was found that the intervention was effective in delaying heterosexual experience or reducing pregnancies.” Young women who took part in the program were more likely than those in the control group to report that they had been pregnant (16% vs. 6%) and had early heterosexual experience (58% vs. 33%).11

David Paton, author of four major studies in this area, has found “no evidence” that "the provision of family planning reduces either underage conception or abortion rates."12 He sums up the U.K. experience: “It is clear that providing more family planning clinics, far from having the effect of reducing conception rates, has actually led to an increase…. The availability of the morning-after pill seems to be encouraging risky behavior. It appears that if people have access to family planning advice they think they automatically have a lower risk of pregnancy.” 13

K. Edgardh found that despite free contraceptive counseling, low cost condoms and oral contraceptives, and over-the-counter emergency contraception (EC), Swedish teen abortion rates rose from 17 per thousand to 22.5 per thousand between 1995 and 2001.14

Peter Arcidiacono found that among teens, “increasing access to contraception may actually increase long run pregnancy rates even though short run pregnancy rates fall. On the other hand, policies that decrease access to contraception, and hence sexual activity, may lower pregnancy rates in the long run.”
 
Respectfully, the position that I am making is not my position. It is the medical community’s position.
The medical community’s position on abortion-via-failed-implantation is that there’s no real evidence it occurs.

-Full Stop-

The primary mechanism by which bc prevents pregnancy is by preventing ovulation.

-Again, Full Stop-

In fact, when taken properly, breakthrough ovulations are genuine statistical oddities; oddities with varying levels of viability as it pertains to the ovum.
They are the ones who are saying that this is how the pill works, not me.
No one is debating how the pill works. When you restrict the hormones that cause ovulation, you also restrict the very same hormones that prepare the uterus and cervical mucus for pregnancy.
If you wish you can discuss it with them and tell them they are incorrect; that their research is “magic”; that it is “junk”.

Blessings
I read them. On the topic of the probability of “abortion via failed implantation”, they produce literally no research. None. Just conjecture on how it miiiiiight be possible using models.

For serious, credible research - NOT GOOD ENOUGH. Period.

On the other hand, for folks looking for confirmation of their biases, it’s more than sufficient. Really, in those cases, anything is.
 
Last edited:
Thanks.

I agree. In the earlier days, basically the pills are abortificients by preventing implantation of the embryo to the uterine wall.

However, they (manufacturers) also came out with the type that prevents ovulation and conception by changing the hormonal content.

All are preventing pregnancies, albeit without the semantic.
 
What I heard was that the earlier pills tended to suppress ovulation more completely. However, the side effects were so bad that the formulation was changed to lessen the side effects. This change led to more ovulations. What I’ve read is that the ovulation rate can be as high as 35 percent.

Of course the side effects of the pill are still horrendous- I wouldn’t wish them on my worst enemy.

Unfortunately, I am away from my resources so I can’t verify the change in formulations - I’m working from my feeble memory. When I get back I’ll try to look it up.

Blessings
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top