Have I sinned?

[Bonnie]

I will make sure to never ask you anything ever again.

Good. Get important information - which includes health information - from knowledgeable sources in real life, not from the Internet.

 

[lynn1314]

Good. Get important information - which includes health information - from knowledgeable sources in real life, not from the Internet.

Note taken.

 

[Irishmom2]

have. And I’m sorry I’ve wasted your time. I’ve learned a lot over the years, just not sure if I sinned while doing this. I’m trying to be a good faithful Catholic again. But you’re making it really difficult. All I want was a yes or no answer, I don’t need to be told about what I did was wrong. I’m fully aware and have been counseled on it in confession, I don’t newsboy hear it from you too.

Okay. I’m done listening to you. I did plan on asking the priest, I forgot in the confessional. I understand that what I did was wrong. I’m sorry. It just sorta happened. It wasn’t planned. I will make sure to never ask you anything ever again.

You know, you asked a question and people took the time to answer you in depth because you really didn’t seem to understand something. Things are not as black and white, or yes and no as you think.

But then, when you didn’t like what we answered, you got annoyed. You heard the truth, and you don’t like it. That is the chance you take asking something that is private on a public forum.

 

[lynn1314]

You know, you asked a question and people took the time to answer you in depth because you really didn’t seem to understand something. Things are not as black and white, or yes and no as you think.

But then, when you didn’t like what we answered, you got annoyed. You heard the truth, and you don’t like it. That is the chance you take asking something that is private on a public forum.

By you didn’t answer, instead all you guys did was tell me about how what I did was wrong and judge me on it. I wasn’t annoyed with it, I was tired of people retelling me what I already know.

 

[Hoosier_Daddy]

I took vitamin c to bring on a period. I was a no th late, but I knew I wasn’t pregnant because I had taken 4 pregnancy tests that came up negative, even though I hadn’t done anything to get pregnant. I’m just not sure that if there was some chance I was pregnant and I took the vitamin c to bring on the period, that I could have in theory aborted a baby. I had been in a relationship before then, but we hadn’t actually done it, we were impure in some ways, but none that could have caused a pregnancy. I have been to confession a couple of times since then, I just wasn’t sure if I had sinned, and kept forgetting to ask the priest in the confessional.

On the Internet, you many people have to say yes or no before you believe one side or the other. Is there a specific percentage of responses that will affect if you have sinned or not.
In the matter above you can seek out advice from your priest and follow it and advice about vitamin c from a medical professional and follow it.

 

[Bonnie]

By you didn’t answer, instead all you guys did was tell me about how what I did was wrong and judge me on it. I wasn’t annoyed with it, I was tired of people retelling me what I already know.

Then you must not have read all the replies, or interpreted them in your own way. I don’t recall “judging” you, but I did assume from what you wrote that you didn’t know much about human sexuality. Because of your seeming not to know exactly what could make you pregnant - or the point of a pregnancy test - I also assumed you were young, perhaps jr. high age.

I did wonder if you are a troll, but decided to err on the side of caution & reply as if you were sincerely asking.