Having a Orthodox say a Divine Liturgy

  • Thread starter Thread starter PopePiusXIISupp
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PopePiusXIISupp

Guest
I was wondering if it would be ok to have an Orthodox priest say a Divine Liturgy for the repose of the soul of my cousin. I am having a Roman Catholic priest say a Mass for the repose of her soul so I was wondering if it would be ok or not?
 
I was wondering if it would be ok to have an Orthodox priest say a Divine Liturgy for the repose of the soul of my cousin. I am having a Roman Catholic priest say a Mass for the repose of her soul so I was wondering if it would be ok or not?
I don’t see a problem with it.
 
I think the real question is whether the Orthodox priest would do it.
 
I didn’t realize that the Orthodox took “intentions” for the Divine Liturgy.
 
Is an Eastern Orthodox Priest actually allowed to perform a Catholic Mass?
 
If they don’t take issue with it, go for it. However I’m not sure if they would even do it.

I say this due to the fact that Orthodoxy doesn’t have the belief in purgatory, like Catholicism does. At least as far as I understand it, masses said for people are most of the time done to help the person along in their time in purgatory.

But go for it. If they don’t you could just have a non-latin rite priest say a mass for them aswell.
 
If they don’t take issue with it, go for it. However I’m not sure if they would even do it.

I say this due to the fact that Orthodoxy doesn’t have the belief in purgatory, like Catholicism does. At least as far as I understand it, masses said for people are most of the time done to help the person along in their time in purgatory.

But go for it. If they don’t you could just have a non-latin rite priest say a mass for them aswell.
I think reading these Orthodox prayers for the dead will help clarify the Orthodox belief:
O Almighty God and our Father, fount of time and eternity, who by Thy power hast set a term of our life on earth, and through Thine only-begotten Son dost grant unto us, through resurrection, immortal life and a kingdom which cannot be moved, do Thou remember Thy servant N. who hath fallen asleep in the hope of resurrection unto life eternal, we beseech Thee, hear and have mercy.

O Father, holy and good, for as by the offence of one man, our forefather, sin entered into the world, and death by sin, so may we be inheritors of eternal life by the righteousness of Thine all-perfect Son, and do Thou give rest to the soul of Thy servant N. and preserve it unto the blessed life that is with Thee, we beseech Thee, hear and have mercy.

O Lord God, Father Almighty, in the name of Thy beloved Son, our hope, Who gave Himself for a ransom to death wherein we were held fast and continue so to this day, sold under sin: Do Thou loose the grievous shackles of our death, make us sons of resurrection, and receive into Thy rest, (where all Thy saints have found repose) the soul of Thy servant N. we beseech Thee, hear and have mercy.

O Lord Jesus Christ, Eternal God, Who dost uphold all things by the power of Thy word, Who didst make Thyself of no reputation, and took upon Thee the form of a servant, wast crucified and descended into hell; Who opened the way of resurrection for all flesh slain by sin and in the bondage of corruption, give rest to the soul of Thy servant N. who hath set his hope in Thee, our Maker, the Author of our being, and our God, we beseech Thee, hear and have mercy.

O Lord Jesus Christ, Who in the days of Thy sojourn with us in the flesh, and Thy saving passion didst cry unto Thy Father: Holy Father, I will that they also, whom Thou hast given me, be with me where I am; that they may behold my glory, which Thou hast given me: for Thou lovedst me before the foundation of the world: Mercifully now receive Thy servant N. who is come before Thee, and accept him as a partaker of Thine imperishable glory, we beseech Thee, hear and have mercy.

For Thou are the resurrection and the life and the repose of Thy departed servant N. O Christ our God; and unto Thee we ascribe glory, together with Thine eternal Father, and Thy most holy, good and life-giving Spirit; now, and forever: world without end. Amen.

May Christ our true God who is risen from the dead, by the prayers of His most holy Mother; of the holy and all-glorious apostles; of our righteous and holy father, and of all the saints; establish in the mansions of the righteous the soul of his servant N. grant him rest in Abraham’s bosom, and number him with the righteous, and upon us have mercy. For He is good and loving-kind.
 
If they don’t take issue with it, go for it. However I’m not sure if they would even do it.

I say this due to the fact that Orthodoxy doesn’t have the belief in purgatory, like Catholicism does. At least as far as I understand it, masses said for people are most of the time done to help the person along in their time in purgatory.

But go for it. If they don’t you could just have a non-latin rite priest say a mass for them aswell.
They do pray for the dead, despite a lack of a doctrine of purgatory.
 
I say this due to the fact that Orthodoxy doesn’t have the belief in purgatory, like Catholicism does.
There is a somewhat analogous “tollhouse” theology propounded by some EO, in which there is a progression proceeding from tollhouse to tollhouse, but it is not universally accepted (and indeed widely condemned by parts of EO).

AMDG

hawk
 
They do pray for the dead, despite a lack of a doctrine of purgatory.
But why? If they don’t believe in purgatory then there’s only heaven and hell.

If they’re in heaven, then there’s no need to pray for them, as they are already with god.
If they’re in hell, then the prayers offered for them wouldn’t do any good and would just be in vain.
 
But why? If they don’t believe in purgatory then there’s only heaven and hell.

If they’re in heaven, then there’s no need to pray for them, as they are already with god.
If they’re in hell, then the prayers offered for them wouldn’t do any good and would just be in vain.
Re-read post #10
 
But why? If they don’t believe in purgatory then there’s only heaven and hell.

If they’re in heaven, then there’s no need to pray for them, as they are already with god.
If they’re in hell, then the prayers offered for them wouldn’t do any good and would just be in vain.
And what if they’re in purgatory? Understand that purgatory is on the right side of heaven.

Having said that, in the East it is taught that the process of Divinization that begins with Baptism continues after death. Those anxious about reconciling Western developments with Eastern teachings like to make this some sort of equivalent understanding of purgatory, even if unnecessary to an Eastern Christian.
 
But why? If they don’t believe in purgatory then there’s only heaven and hell.
No one is in hell until after the final judgement at Christ’s second coming. Nothing is set in stone until then so out of love we seek God’s mercy upon their souls.
There is no law against love.
 
No one is in hell until after the final judgement at Christ’s second coming. Nothing is set in stone until then so out of love we seek God’s mercy upon their souls.
There is no law against love.
Well put.

Also, there is a tendency to conflate our notions of time and sequence with God’s–which is just plain wrong.

AMDG
 
The dead, Orthodox or not, may be commemorated during one of the litany during the Divine Liturgy. Also, “Memory Eternal” may be intoned at the dismissal for the repose of the soul of the departed. We typically do not offer a Liturgy in its entirety for the dead as in Catholic practice.

Typically the stand-alone service for the dead would be a Panikhida, but I have never witnessed one for someone who is not Orthodox.

In Christ,

Reader John
 
No one is in hell until after the final judgement at Christ’s second coming. Nothing is set in stone until then so out of love we seek God’s mercy upon their souls.
There is no law against love.
I thought immediately after death, a soul is judged by Christ. And that, if an unrepented mortal sin is on their soul, they are damned and subsequently descend into Hell.
 
I thought immediately after death, a soul is judged by Christ. And that, if an unrepented mortal sin is on their soul, they are damned and subsequently descend into Hell.
If I recall correctly, the Orthodox believe in a sort of intermediate state after death where no one is technically in heaven or hell. The blessed are in one “area” enjoying a foretaste of the glory of heaven, while the damned are in another “area” experiencing a foreshadowing of the torments of hell, with neither group’s experiencing the fullness of either until the final judgement. The Orthodox believe (again IIRC, and the Orthodox posters here should feel free to correct me) that those on the “bad side” can still be helped by prayers until the last day, when their fate is finally sealed.

While this may sound radically different from the Catholic approach, the two can sort of be reconciled when you consider how vague the Catholic teachings on the nature of heaven, hell and purgatory are. We also believe in an “intermediate state” if you think about it. Though we Catholics believe that souls immediately enter heaven or hell (ignoring purgatory for a second), the souls do not experience the fullness of their reward or punishment until the resurrection of the body, when they will feel everything with both body and soul, and therefore could sort of be said to be in an intermediate state (just not in the exact same way). That some souls are saved from the bad side by prayers makes it a functional equivalent of purgatory, even though the Orthodox would never ever call it that. Again, given the vague teachings on the exact nature of purgatory, it is not outside the realm of reason to imagine that souls there undergo their purification within view of the damned, and some theologians have speculated as much. It is also worth pointing out that the Orthodox Synod of Jerusalem proclaims a belief in post-mortem purification that matches exactly what a traditional Catholic would think of when hearing the word purgatory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top