Help in a Sola Scriptura Debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter thessalonian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In regards to your last paragraph, I don’t believe its as extreme as not being a true trustworthy church. The issues in debate are secondary on primary issue there is agreement and always has been.
The one all-defeating question to ask of the Protestants on the pillar of Sola Scriptura is: “what about the seven books?”

Martin Luther (may God rest his tortured soul), originator of this sola, laid claim to having done two things:
  1. Restoring the faith of the early, institutional Church (pre- 600 AD)
  2. Restoring the true scriptures (66 vs. 73)
… however, if he accomplished 1, he could not have accomplished 2, and vice versa.

The early Church defined the Canon of 73 books of scripture before St. Augustine died. This was done in 393 and 397 in separate councils approved by the Popes.

Luther, followed by Calvin, insisted that the true Church had one last good pope: St. Gregory the Dialogist (the Great). Using Luther’s logic, the popes and Church from 33-600 AD are pure, and those of the roughly 900 year period before Luther’s time were increasingly corrupt and obscurantist about the faith. He truly believed, however, that the early Church was the true Church of Christ, and believed himself to be taking part in its restoration. Why, then, did he reject those books of the Bible which had been accepted as God-breathed Scripture by the same early Church he so worshiped?

Either Luther contradicts the early Church, or he contradicts the scriptures. Both of his most important claims are indefensible if taken together, in context. One cannot say he is in the process of restoring the early Church, and simultaneously remove 7 books from the very scriptures which the same early Church had declared divinely-inspired - long before Luther’s supposed millennium-long fallow period.

To summarise the point: if our total, absolute, signed and sealed source of revelation is the Holy Scriptures alone, not one word should be removed from them. To do so is a sacrilege against the Almighty Holy Sacred Immortal. This is exactly what the Luther Bible and the King James Bible do, insanely contrary to their own stated principle. That’s the madness of all this: Luther stated X, then immediately stated Y by his actions.

To say that one is merely removing 7 books that were erroneously considered to be scripture for 1100+ years (by all the greatest fathers, saints, and bishops who Luther so loved) is to say that the early Church was not really the true Church, not truly trustworthy in anything. After that, where is the trustworthy peace of Christ? Where is the Lord? Where is God? Dead.
 
Not sure if that helps or hurts the case for Tradition…being they were written down then we have a bible that is infallable
They were all written down and every explanation and understanding that Jesus gave with them. Your sure… I think you could read all of Jesus words in much less than an hour. So he must have been a pretty quiet guy the rest of those three years or maybe he talked about the whether. Or do you think that there was a considerable amount more instruction that went along with those words he spoke. Hmmmmmm. No I don’t think the case for Oral Tradition has been hurt at all except in the mind of one who insists on Sola Scriptura.
 
They were all written down and every explanation and understanding that Jesus gave with them. Your sure… I think you could read all of Jesus words in much less than an hour. So he must have been a pretty quiet guy the rest of those three years or maybe he talked about the whether. Or do you think that there was a considerable amount more instruction that went along with those words he spoke. Hmmmmmm. No I don’t think the case for Oral Tradition has been hurt at all except in the mind of one who insists on Sola Scriptura.
Interesting, you claim essential information was left out of the bible. While scripture in the bible is errant and/or non essentail.
 
Interesting, you claim essential information was left out of the bible. While scripture in the bible is errant and/or non essentail.
Can you find either the Trinity or Fully Human and Fully Divine in the Bible (alone)? Or for that matter how do you even determine what is Sacred Scripture were it not for Sacred Tradition? From what I read he didn’t state Sacred Scripture was errant.
 
Can you find either the Trinity or Fully Human and Fully Divine in the Bible (alone)? Or for that matter how do you even determine what is Sacred Scripture were it not for Sacred Tradition? From what I read he didn’t state Sacred Scripture was errant.
Indeed but using your logic can you find explicit term Sola Scriptura?? Just using your logic.
 
Indeed but using your logic can you find explicit term Sola Scriptura?? Just using your logic.
No, my logic, can’t get there. There is an authority, the Church, outside of scripture that defines the canon. So without Sacred Tradition to define the canon, there is nothing defining what is Sacred Scripture and what isn’t.

Can you, using your logic, determine what is Sacred Scripture and what isn’t? Can you define the canon of Sacred Scipture via Sola Scriptura?
 
No, my logic, can’t get there. There is an authority, the Church, outside of scripture that defines the canon. So without Sacred Tradition to define the canon, there is nothing defining what is Sacred Scripture and what isn’t.

Can you, using your logic, determine what is Sacred Scripture and what isn’t? Can you define the canon of Sacred Scipture via Sola Scriptura?
Understood. The Church is authority and infallibility goes with that. A Protestant claims the bible is as just as you call the Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top