Help me get this straight

  • Thread starter Thread starter coco2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

coco2

Guest
Ok, can someone help me understand these things?:

Is Eastern Catholic different from Orthodox?

Is it Orthodox or Orthodox Catholic?

Am I right in thinking that all Eastern churches are in communion with Rome but Orthodox is not?

What are some names of “Eastern” churches? How do I know if they are in communion with Rome? I know the Byzantine church is one, but that is all.

Are Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox the same church? Are they in communion with each other?

Do Eastern catholics and Orthodox have Divine Liturgies and how is that different from Roman Mass? Can I receive communion at Eastern or Orthodox churches if I am Roman Catholic?
 
Is Eastern Catholic different from Orthodox?
Yes, Eastern Catholics are in communion with the Bishop of Rome, but Eastern Orthodox are not.
Is it Orthodox or Orthodox Catholic?
Orthodox with a small ‘o’ refers to Catholics who believe everything the Catholic Church teaches. Some people on this forum call themselves “Orthodox Catholic”, but I’m not precisely sure what they mean, or whether they can be grouped together.
Am I right in thinking that all Eastern churches are in communion with Rome but Orthodox is not?
No, Orthodox Churches are properly called Churches. All Eastern Catholic Churches are necessarily, and definitionally in communion with Rome.
What are some names of “Eastern” churches? How do I know if they are in communion with Rome? I know the Byzantine church is one, but that is all.
There are 22 Eastern Catholic Churches. The Byzantine Church is not the proper name of a Church, rather there is a Byzantine Rite, which is used in around 14 Eastern Catholic Churches.
Are Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox the same church? Are they in communion with each other?
They are not the same. I think they are in communion with each other.
Do Eastern catholics and Orthodox have Divine Liturgies and how is that different from Roman Mass? Can I receive communion at Eastern or Orthodox churches if I am Roman Catholic?
The Divine Liturgy is what they call their Mass. They use a different liturgy, but their priest confects the same Eucharist that the Roman Catholic priest does. You may receive Holy Communion at any Eastern Catholic Church. Receiving at an Orthodox Church is also allowed by the Catholic Church, but you should identify yourself as a Catholic first and abide by the priest’s decision.
 
Ok, can someone help me understand these things?:

Is Eastern Catholic different from Orthodox?
Yes. Two different Churches (pay attention to that capitalization)
Is it Orthodox or Orthodox Catholic?
The Orthodox Church can be referred to as the Orthodox Catholic Church. We are One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic. You could say we are catholic, with a little c, but we also have no qualms about identifying as Catholic if we think it wouldn’t cause confusion (which most of the time it does, and on this forum can get us in trouble).

If you call us just Orthodox you’ll always be fine and always be speaking correctly and respectfully.
Am I right in thinking that all Eastern churches are in communion with Rome but Orthodox is not?
There are many Eastern Churches not in Communion with Rome, the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Oriental Orthodox Church are two such Churches (who aren’t in Communion with each other either - yet)
Are Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox the same church? Are they in communion with each other?
Yes, they are in communion with each other. They are two churches within the Orthodox Church. Notice the capitalization again - an easy way to differentiate. The Orthodox Church is subdivided into many churches based off their locality. In Greece the Orthodox Church is called the Greek Orthodox Church, in Russia the Russian Orthodox Church. America is being evangelized still (sort of why we have so many different churches here) but will eventually have an American Orthodox Church.
Can I receive communion at Eastern or Orthodox churches if I am Roman Catholic?
In general - no. Most Orthodox priests in North America and other Western countries will not allow inter-communion (and they’re not supposed to). In the “old countries” they shouldn’t, but sometimes will (even though they’re not supposed to). You’re welcome to attend (wear comfortable shoes - we stand for almost the entire service) but you shouldn’t approach the chalice for Communion or for a blessing. I haven’t heard of an Orthodox church giving a blessing to non-communicants. Even if it does happen, easier, less confusing, to just remain.
 
Ok, can someone help me understand these things?:

Is Eastern Catholic different from Orthodox?

Is it Orthodox or Orthodox Catholic?

Am I right in thinking that all Eastern churches are in communion with Rome but Orthodox is not?

What are some names of “Eastern” churches? How do I know if they are in communion with Rome? I know the Byzantine church is one, but that is all.

Are Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox the same church? Are they in communion with each other?

Do Eastern catholics and Orthodox have Divine Liturgies and how is that different from Roman Mass? Can I receive communion at Eastern or Orthodox churches if I am Roman Catholic?
The vocabulary that the Vatican has choosen for Christian non-Catholic churches is:
those with valid sacraments are called Christian particular churches (or sister churches),

those without valid sacraments are Christian ecclesial communities.

Of the non-Catholic churches those with valid sacraments are the Polish National Church, the Old Catholic churches, the Eastern Orthodox, the Oriental Orthodox, and the Assyrian (or Ancient) Church of the East.

They are not all in communion with one another. These are autocephalous:

Eastern Orthodox
1 Constantinople
2 Poland
3 Albania
4 Czech,Slovokia
5 Greece
6 Bulgaria
7 Georgia
8 Serbia
9 Cyprus
10 Russia
11 Romania
12 Jerusalem
13 Alexandria
14 Antioch

Oriental Orthodox
1 Armenian
2 Coptic
3 Ethiopian Tweahedo
4 Eritrean Tweahedo
5 Syriac
6 Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church

Ancient (Assyrian) Church of the East

And some others are striving to be recognized as authcephalous by all, such as several of the Ukrainian Orthodox churches.
 
The Wikipedia article on Eastern Catholic Churches is actually very good, as are the articles on Divine Liturgy, Vespers , etc. The Divine Liturgy at my parish is identical to that at the local Russian Orthodox parish, except we commemorate the Pope of Rome, the Melkite Patriarch and our Bishops and they commemorate their Metropolitan and their Bishop.

The Divine Liturgy has the same two broad components as the Roman Rite Mass-- the Liturgy of the Catechumens/the Word and Liturgy of the Faithful/lthe Eucharist.

If you’re interested in seeing for yourself what that Divine Liturgy is like you can see if there is an Eastern/Greek/Byzantine Catholic Church near you by checking here at Find-A-Parish 🙂
 
The Wikipedia article on Eastern Catholic Churches is actually very good, as are the articles on Divine Liturgy, Vespers , etc. The Divine Liturgy at my parish is identical to that at the local Russian Orthodox parish, except we commemorate the Pope of Rome, the Melkite Patriarch and our Bishops and they commemorate their Metropolitan and their Bishop.

The Divine Liturgy has the same two broad components as the Roman Rite Mass-- the Liturgy of the Catechumens/the Word and Liturgy of the Faithful/lthe Eucharist.

If you’re interested in seeing for yourself what that Divine Liturgy is like you can see if there is an Eastern/Greek/Byzantine Catholic Church near you by checking here at Find-A-Parish 🙂
This is very helpful, thanks for the responses. There is a Greek Orthodox church in my town and I would like to go to a Divine Liturgy. I won’t attempt to receive the Eucharist because I don’t want to cause any problems, but I have lately been thinking how much our Lord must desire for all to worship together and receive His Body and Blood in union. Can you imagine how much our Lord could do through all of us in this world if we were united again?

Thanks for the responses.
 
Thought I’d answer your questions, too, not because other posters - Catholic and Orthodox - haven’t done a great job, but because our answers will complement each other. I have a few extra details for you. 🙂
Ok, can someone help me understand these things?

Is Eastern Catholic different from Orthodox?
Yes. Many (though far from all) eastern Catholics have the same rite as the Orthodox - the Byzantine Rite (a “rite” is the “liturgical, theological, spiritual and disciplinary patrimony, culture and circumstances of history of a distinct people, by which its own manner of living the faith is manifested in each autonomous [sui iuris] Church” according to the Code of Canons for the Eastern Churches).

But the Orthodox Church is not in communion with the eastern Catholic churches, which are a part of the Catholic Church.
Is it Orthodox or Orthodox Catholic?
Orthodox Christians often refer to themselves as “Orthodox Catholics,” because the official title for their church is “the Orthodox Catholic Church.” They call themselves this because they consider their church to be the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church founded by Christ.

Obviously the Catholic Church claims this, too, so generally Catholics refer to themselves as “Catholic” and refer to the Orthodox simply as “Orthodox.”

Further complicating matters is that many Catholics who want to communicate their fidelity to the Church’s teachings refer to themselves as “orthodox Catholics.” In this context the term is meant to contrast with “heterodox Catholic,” and it is not to be confused with the Orthodox self-label “Orthodox Catholic.”
Am I right in thinking that all Eastern churches are in communion with Rome but Orthodox is not?
You’re partially right: the Orthodox are not in communion with Rome. The eastern Catholic churches are, but there are many different kinds of eastern Christians:

(1) the churches of the Orthodox communion - not in communion with Rome since roughly the eleventh/twelfth centuries
(2) the churches of the Oriental Orthodox communion - not in communion with Rome or with the eastern Orthodox since A.D. 451
(3) the Assyrian Church of the East and the Ancient Church of the East, out of communion with everyone since A.D. 431; the latter split from the former in the 1960s over calendar issues (I think)
(4) the eastern churches that are a part of the Catholic communion - are in communion with Rome; they re-entered the Catholic Church from the above churches at different points in Church history. Exceptions who were never out of communion with Rome include the Maronite Syriac Church of Antioch, the Italo-Albanian (Byzantine) Catholic Church, and maybe the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church? I’m not sure about that last one; they have a very complicated history.
What are some names of “Eastern” churches? How do I know if they are in communion with Rome? I know the Byzantine church is one, but that is all.
“Byzantine” is a rite, not a church. No less than fourteen autonomous Catholic churches share the Byzantine Rite.

Wikipedia lists each of the twenty-two autonomous eastern Catholic churches by name here.

If you mean “how do I identify an eastern Christian parish as Catholic/in communion with Rome?”, well, usually they’ll have “Catholic” in their name. This is not foolproof, though.
Are Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox the same church? Are they in communion with each other?
They are different autonomous churches, but they are in communion with each other just as the Latin Church is in communion with the eastern Catholic churches. They are a part of the larger body known as the Orthodox Church (the Byzantine one I mentioned above as no longer in communion with Rome since the eleventh/twelfth centuries).
Do Eastern Catholics and Orthodox have Divine Liturgies and how is that different from Roman Mass?
Yes, they do! 🙂 There are lots of differences because the Byzantine Rite is a separate tradition from the Roman Rite, but both are 100% valid, beautiful Eucharistic Liturgies.
Can I receive communion at Eastern or Orthodox churches if I am Roman Catholic?
At an eastern Catholic church, yes.

At an Orthodox church, no. The Orthodox do not generally permit non-Orthodox to receive Holy Communion at their Liturgy.

Hope this helps!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top