Holding hands before courtship?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JeraldW
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JeraldW

Guest
Is is appropriate to hold hands with someone of the opposite sex before courtship? I as a man really enjoy holding hands with my sweetheart. The first time we held hands it was just magnetic after that to both of us. We do not share any more affection than that, other than chaste hugs. We however will not be able to seriously court for quite sometime, due to distance and state in our lives. Some protestant dating blogs are against it, but i was wondering if that is too puritanical for our Catholic mindset?
 
Is is appropriate to hold hands with someone of the opposite sex before courtship? I as a man really enjoy holding hands with my sweetheart. The first time we held hands it was just magnetic after that to both of us. We do not share any more affection than that, other than chaste hugs. We however will not be able to seriously court for quite sometime, due to distance and state in our lives. Some protestant dating blogs are against it, but i was wondering if that is too puritanical for our Catholic mindset?
Why would you ask this question?
 
So our hearts don’t get too attached before we are even close to really seriously dicerning marriage.
Well, from what it sounds like, you are both very conservative and serious in what you are looking for out of relationships. The end result being marriage, as it most certainly should be. So I would say, if your are not ‘seriously discerning marriage’ why are you two in a relationship at all? With that said, I think that it is perfectly acceptable for a courting couple to sweetly hold hands 🙂
 
:hug3:

Sounds sweet to me. Please do hold hands.

There is a difference between sexual arousal and showing affection for another person. The only problem would be if holding hands leads you to an occasion of near sin.
 
Well, from what it sounds like, you are both very conservative and serious in what you are looking for out of relationships. The end result being marriage, as it most certainly should be. So I would say, if your are not ‘seriously discerning marriage’ why are you two in a relationship at all? With that said, I think that it is perfectly acceptable for a courting couple to sweetly hold hands 🙂
This X10
 
Except I’m not so sure spouses or boyfriends/girlfriends are too keen on that practice with other opposite sex friends. 😃
I guess it depends on the culture and the context. A reasonable person wouldn’t complain about very close friends in very serious emotional situations, in which case it’s close to, for example, comforting your sibling (some friends get to that point, and ahead of many collateral relatives). On the other hand, opposite-sex friends don’t normally walk the streets hand-in-hand 100% of the time. 😛

This said, for a concerned person the morality of holding hands like many other gestures of friendship, depends on the intent and whether it creates a near occasion of sin (for that specific person, since we can all agree that for the typical person it does not, by far). No physical gesture is necessary to commit a sin of lust, as imagination is enough. Perhaps in some specific situations holding hands would involve a sin. But that would be a highly abnormal situation, or at least very rare, e.g. that one day when just feeling a woman’s touch makes your system go crazy (i.e. wild levels of tension build up) for whatever stupid hormonal reason, in which case yeah, you don’t hold hands. You lock yourself up with your Xbox.
 
i can actually understand what the op is talking about, and in regards to holding hands in mass during the Our Father ( which i no longer do ) i dont find any intimate connection only a spiritual one or at least i did when the congregation was doing this…

I rarely hold hands with my family while walking about, not because i dont want to, i just barely have that need to do so for that comfort or connection…

holding hands as simple and innocent as it sounds for most people, for others such as myself and the OP it becomes deeper than simplisity.

Personally i find a real intimate connection holding hands with the opposite sex, it requires no talking, no over thinking between myself and the female i am interested in , and we walk together in confidence and peace, and harmony i guess…

I couldn’t even bring myself to shaking hands with females in my college class recently just doing a simple introducing myself, as a means of being sociable and breaking through my own personal barriers, i super impose a connection that isnt there and i didnt want to break this imposed barrier of letting someone connect with me on a simple hand shake, i only shake hands during the sign of peace in mass, as that a mere sign of peace and for me even that leaves a physical imprint on my hand that i can feel after each handshake, and it feels weird and i have to work through it quickly to focus back on mass, and i find myself wiping my hand on my pants to get that feeling off, n also to quickly wipe off any germs, but mostly this weird imprint feeling i get.

I admit none of this makes sense to those who dont understand, i guess one could analyis myself and the op and say we have some neurological disorder or need therapy, but i would venture to guess that the op might feel the same connection i do when holding hands with someone of the opposite sex they are attracted to, or breaking this invisible barrier and shaking someones hand, which to me symbolizes a friendship, at times a contract between two people.

Hence why i try to stop thinking so much and i try to stop psychoanalysing myself at every given moment of the day.
 
Well, if you aren’t going to hold hands with someone you are interested in, what’s left?

Looking into each other’s eyes longingly? :shrug. Maybe extended sighing? 🤷🙂
 
Well, if you aren’t going to hold hands with someone you are interested in, what’s left?

Looking into each other’s eyes longingly? :shrug. Maybe extended sighing? 🤷🙂
Air hugs, bro-hugs, and handshakes maybe.
 
I guess it depends on the culture and the context. A reasonable person wouldn’t complain about very close friends in very serious emotional situations, in which case it’s close to, for example, comforting your sibling (some friends get to that point, and ahead of many collateral relatives). On the other hand, opposite-sex friends don’t normally walk the streets hand-in-hand 100% of the time. 😛

This said, for a concerned person the morality of holding hands like many other gestures of friendship, depends on the intent and whether it creates a near occasion of sin (for that specific person, since we can all agree that for the typical person it does not, by far). No physical gesture is necessary to commit a sin of lust, as imagination is enough. Perhaps in some specific situations holding hands would involve a sin. But that would be a highly abnormal situation, or at least very rare, e.g. that one day when just feeling a woman’s touch makes your system go crazy (i.e. wild levels of tension build up) for whatever stupid hormonal reason, in which case yeah, you don’t hold hands. You lock yourself up with your Xbox.
Well in the U.S., if your spouse caught you and a friend of the opposite sex out for a stroll, I think this would be a big no-no:



But this would be okay, though, as it’s considered formal, and less intimate:

http://media3.corbisimages.com/CorbisImage/hover/10/8/3839/10083839/HU057571.jpg
 
Well, if you aren’t going to hold hands with someone you are interested in, what’s left?

Looking into each other’s eyes longingly? :shrug. Maybe extended sighing? 🤷🙂
"John…“Marsha”… 😛

Also…air hugs? Bwuh?..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top