How do you handle when other faiths come knocking at your door?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Miraluna
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Miraluna

Guest
Not sure if this is the right area for this post…We just had two Baha’i ladies knock at our door to share their faith. I could hear what was being said while I was brushing my teeth and fixing my hair and face. My husband was at the door and was being polite as he always is. However, he was doing all the listening and not speaking. I came out and asked my 11-year-old to watch his brother. I wanted to him to be at an ears distance but not right there with his full attention. The first question to them, was if they believed in God. I told my son that the answer to that was not the same God. Because our God (the God) is Trinitarian and to them Jesus was only a prophet. In some ways, I felt myself wanting to engage in polemics (I could feel my adrenaline rising): ask them questions, state our faith, refute some of the things they were saying. They came to teach and I could reciprocate the same: teach them about our faith and the misconceptions that people have about our faith. Another part of me kept saying be “charitable” but you do not need to listen to this. And another part of me was thinking, listen some and ask questions of their faith because awareness is a good thing and it does not change my faith at all…it actually, makes me acknowledge the truth, beauty and fullness of Catholicism even more. When they spoke of finding truth as each person’s mission, I told them that we had found truth and all its fullness in our Catholic church. That changed the flow of their conversation and started to bring it to an end. How would Christ have wanted me to handle this, better? :confused:
 
Not sure if this is the right area for this post…We just had two Baha’i ladies knock at our door to share their faith. I could hear what was being said while I was brushing my teeth and fixing my hair and face. My husband was at the door and was being polite as he always is. However, he was doing all the listening and not speaking. I came out and asked my 11-year-old to watch his brother. I wanted to him to be at an ears distance but not right there with his full attention. The first question to them, was if they believed in God. I told my son that the answer to that was not the same God. Because our God (the God) is Trinitarian and to them Jesus was only a prophet. In some ways, I felt myself wanting to engage in polemics (I could feel my adrenaline rising): ask them questions, state our faith, refute some of the things they were saying. They came to teach and I could reciprocate the same: teach them about our faith and the misconceptions that people have about our faith. Another part of me kept saying be “charitable” but you do not need to listen to this. And another part of me was thinking, listen some and ask questions of their faith because awareness is a good thing and it does not change my faith at all…it actually, makes me acknowledge the truth, beauty and fullness of Catholicism even more. When they spoke of finding truth as each person’s mission, I told them that we had found truth and all its fullness in our Catholic church. That changed the flow of their conversation and started to bring it to an end. How would Christ have wanted me to handle this, better? :confused:
It is usually the cults ( Jehovhas Witnesses, Mormons, Baha’i’s, Way International. etc. )
that come knocking at your door. A firm polite statement such as “I am Catholic and have no intention of converting” stops them and they leave. I have been witnessing to cultic members for over thirty years and, unless you know the cult and can engage them in conversation on their ground, this is about the only way to answer them.

By the way, they will rarely listen to or pay attention to what you have to say about your beliefs.

I do recommend you get the book “Kingdom of the Cults” by Dr. Walter Martin for deeply researched information on cults. It is usually available at any Christian book store

PAX DOMINI

Shalom Aleichem
 
I struggle with the exact same thing!!! I’m so glad I’m not the only one. I keep doing mental somersaults when JWs or Mormons come to my door between, debating whether engaging these folks in debate would be more an act of pride on my end or would it be truly sharing the gospel…:juggle: Most of the time I politely dodge the situations and tell them to come back later 😊(now in all fairness, they do have an uncanny knack to come at the most inconvenient times). I suppose there’s an underlying element of fear here, but I’d love to hear some responses and ideas about how to handle folks at the door.
 
The last time they came, they left considering Catholicism when my brother was finished with them 😃
 
It’s been years, and years since that’s happened to me. Every now and then I’ll find a Watchtower at my door. I don’t know if Jehovah’s Witnesses were just dropping them off, or if they came when I wasn’t home.
 
Not sure if this is the right area for this post…We just had two Baha’i ladies knock at our door to share their faith. I could hear what was being said while I was brushing my teeth and fixing my hair and face. My husband was at the door and was being polite as he always is. However, he was doing all the listening and not speaking. I came out and asked my 11-year-old to watch his brother. I wanted to him to be at an ears distance but not right there with his full attention. The first question to them, was if they believed in God. I told my son that the answer to that was not the same God. Because our God (the God) is Trinitarian and to them Jesus was only a prophet. In some ways, I felt myself wanting to engage in polemics (I could feel my adrenaline rising): ask them questions, state our faith, refute some of the things they were saying. They came to teach and I could reciprocate the same: teach them about our faith and the misconceptions that people have about our faith. Another part of me kept saying be “charitable” but you do not need to listen to this. And another part of me was thinking, listen some and ask questions of their faith because awareness is a good thing and it does not change my faith at all…it actually, makes me acknowledge the truth, beauty and fullness of Catholicism even more. When they spoke of finding truth as each person’s mission, I told them that we had found truth and all its fullness in our Catholic church. That changed the flow of their conversation and started to bring it to an end. How would Christ have wanted me to handle this, better? :confused:
Sounds to me like you handled them just fine.

I think its helpful to steer away from faith theology and towards morals theology because that’s where the Catholic Church shines like that city on a hill.
 
It is kind of difficult because in some respect it is a battle of worldviews (kinds of logic) not of faiths or doctrines. Bahai, if i understand it correctly, comes from an eastern dialectic worldview that can take in any belief system. Dialectical system rest on the logic Both - And. So in their worldview you can ask one Bahai member is god personal and he will say yes, ask another and he will say No and they are both right.

The other major world view is the law of non contradiction (either or logic).
Perhaps the next time they come you point out the faults of the dialectic. Ask them that you dont believe Jesus can be God (as held by christians) and not god as believed by muslims. Say it has to be either or. And when he/she rejects that type of logic and says no it is the dialectic then just point out that he has just supported the law of non contradiction.
 
It’s been years, and years since that’s happened to me. Every now and then I’ll find a Watchtower at my door. I don’t know if Jehovah’s Witnesses were just dropping them off, or if they came when I wasn’t home.
I think they just leave the tracts and scamper off.

My Dad invites them in for a beer - this didn’t work too well when two Mormon girls came around, but it was funny to watch.

I have a Jewish buddy with a wicked sense of humor who, in high school, would come to the door dressed in black robes with White Zombie playing in the background. Whatever questions the proselytizers would ask, he’d respond inappropriately:

Way of the Master: “Hi, do you believe you’re a good person?”
Friend: “What blood type are you, by chance?”

Jehovah’s Witness: “Could I give you a copy of our Watchtower magazine?”
Friend: “What time of day do you usually shower?”

Usually I just tell them I know my faith and don’t feel like being proselytized to.
 
It is kind of difficult because in some respect it is a battle of worldviews (kinds of logic) not of faiths or doctrines. Bahai, if i understand it correctly, comes from an eastern dialectic worldview that can take in any belief system. Dialectical system rest on the logic Both - And. So in their worldview you can ask one Bahai member is god personal and he will say yes, ask another and he will say No and they are both right.

The other major world view is the law of non contradiction (either or logic).
Perhaps the next time they come you point out the faults of the dialectic. Ask them that you dont believe Jesus can be God (as held by christians) and not god as believed by muslims. Say it has to be either or. And when he/she rejects that type of logic and says no it is the dialectic then just point out that he has just supported the law of non contradiction.
As a point of interest (putting my two cents worth in), Baha’i is an off-shoot of Zoroastrianism (Zarathustra) as Zen Buddhaism is an off-shoot of Buddhaism.

PAX DOMINI

Shalom Aleichem
 
The same way I deal with anyone trying to sell me something in which I am not interested. IF I answer the door (I do not believe every knocking door or every ringing telephone requires an answer), the conversation is limited to “Sorry, not interested.” Close door.
 
My first approach is to hope my partner’s status of Mary or my mezzuzzah scares them off.

Next line of defense–hide and don’t answer the door.

Last line of defense–sorry not interested, quick shut of door.

I’ve never needed more.

I do have a friend with a poster that says Missionaries will be sacrificed and then eaten. Not sure if that is effective.
 
That never happened to me and hopefully, never will.

In case it ever does though, I’ve actually laid out this plan in my head to give varying reactions depending on my impression of them.

If they strike me as:
  1. Nice - I give them a very apologetic face and say “Sorry, I’m a very busy guy” or in other cases, pretend to look rather tired or even sleepy. Heck you can pretend to be sleeping altogether. 😃
  2. Persistent - I try to give them them the impression of an extreme busy body and look as if I was in the middle of something. Theoretically, the flustered look on your face would make them extremely uneasy enough to think of you as someone who lives too turbulently for any thought of religion to settle in your mind. Be polite though and remind them that the neighbors may not be as busy. :cool:
  3. Downright confrontational - These are the types that just won’t leave you alone and there’s also a high chance that they know you’re a Catholic and are desperate to “save” you from whatever “myth” they think you are worth saving from. They pull no punches and have no care about how much they offend you. My solution for such people is simple: shut the door. In their face. (And in my case, I’d wish it’d hit them in the nose because honestly, such people are so annoying).
Of course, I’ve never really tried this with anyone (and if I’m lucky, I’ll never have to). Still, it feels like the most realistic thing I’d do. You’re all free to shoot criticisms though. :o
 
I tell them I have my won faith, and I am not interested, and I ask them to remove me from what ever lists they might have…btw I have a no soliciting sing on my door…why these people don’t think it applies to them I will never understand

I do try to be kind, it takes courage to follow Christ, and to invite others to join you, no matter what your denomination
 
Not sure if this is the right area for this post…We just had two Baha’i ladies knock at our door to share their faith. I could hear what was being said while I was brushing my teeth and fixing my hair and face. My husband was at the door and was being polite as he always is. However, he was doing all the listening and not speaking. I came out and asked my 11-year-old to watch his brother. I wanted to him to be at an ears distance but not right there with his full attention. The first question to them, was if they believed in God. I told my son that the answer to that was not the same God. Because our God (the God) is Trinitarian and to them Jesus was only a prophet. In some ways, I felt myself wanting to engage in polemics (I could feel my adrenaline rising): ask them questions, state our faith, refute some of the things they were saying. They came to teach and I could reciprocate the same: teach them about our faith and the misconceptions that people have about our faith. Another part of me kept saying be “charitable” but you do not need to listen to this. And another part of me was thinking, listen some and ask questions of their faith because awareness is a good thing and it does not change my faith at all…it actually, makes me acknowledge the truth, beauty and fullness of Catholicism even more. When they spoke of finding truth as each person’s mission, I told them that we had found truth and all its fullness in our Catholic church. That changed the flow of their conversation and started to bring it to an end. How would Christ have wanted me to handle this, better? :confused:
What I would do is just be very respectful and polite. A “No thank you. I’m a Catholic and I am not intrested in converting” should suffice. We have freedom of religion in this country, so they can come to my house and drop off a pamphlet, but on the other hand I have a right to hold firm to my Catholic beliefs.

That’s just my 2 cents

-Jeanne
 
I discovered years ago that it usually is a waste of breath and time to try and argue or convince these people of anything, so I merely say, politely, “I’m not interested” and close the door. They usually come in pairs to shore each other up and keep an eye on each other, and I think it’s very rare that anything you say will make a difference.

Now there is a very nice Baptist Pastor that will go around the neighborhood with some tracts (very inoffensive ones) occasionally, but all he says is “Do you have a church?”, and when I say yes, he just says “Good”, and we exchange pleasantries and he hands me a tract, which I take, “in case someone is looking for a church.” (His words). He is so nice, that if I were a Protestant, I’d consider checking out his church.
 
Now there is a very nice Baptist Pastor that will go around the neighborhood with some tracts (very inoffensive ones) occasionally, but all he says is “Do you have a church?”, and when I say yes, he just says “Good”, and we exchange pleasantries and he hands me a tract, which I take, “in case someone is looking for a church.” (His words). He is so nice, that if I were a Protestant, I’d consider checking out his church.
There are churches that are looking specifically for the un-Churched, the de-Churched etc. to try to get to lost souls. For these folks, denominations of Christianity aren’t relevant and they figure they’re not going to convert enough non-Christians dedicated to another faith to make it worth their while. So they search specifically for those not attending worship services.
 
I discovered years ago that it usually is a waste of breath and time to try and argue or convince these people of anything, so I merely say, politely, “I’m not interested” and close the door. They usually come in pairs to shore each other up and keep an eye on each other, and I think it’s very rare that anything you say will make a difference.

Now there is a very nice Baptist Pastor that will go around the neighborhood with some tracts (very inoffensive ones) occasionally, but all he says is “Do you have a church?”, and when I say yes, he just says “Good”, and we exchange pleasantries and he hands me a tract, which I take, “in case someone is looking for a church.” (His words). He is so nice, that if I were a Protestant, I’d consider checking out his church.
The Baptist minister is doing this the correct way, not pressuring but being open if someone wants to listen. That’s what going door to door should be.

-Jeanne
 
=Miraluna;5125596]Not sure if this is the right area for this post…We just had two Baha’i ladies knock at our door to share their faith. I could hear what was being said while I was brushing my teeth and fixing my hair and face. My husband was at the door and was being polite as he always is. However, he was doing all the listening and not speaking. I came out and asked my 11-year-old to watch his brother. I wanted to him to be at an ears distance but not right there with his full attention. The first question to them, was if they believed in God. I told my son that the answer to that was not the same God. Because our God (the God) is Trinitarian and to them Jesus was only a prophet. In some ways, I felt myself wanting to engage in polemics (I could feel my adrenaline rising): ask them questions, state our faith, refute some of the things they were saying. They came to teach and I could reciprocate the same: teach them about our faith and the misconceptions that people have about our faith. Another part of me kept saying be “charitable” but you do not need to listen to this. And another part of me was thinking, listen some and ask questions of their faith because awareness is a good thing and it does not change my faith at all…it actually, makes me acknowledge the truth, beauty and fullness of Catholicism even more. When they spoke of finding truth as each person’s mission, I told them that we had found truth and all its fullness in our Catholic church. That changed the flow of their conversation and started to bring it to an end. How would Christ have wanted me to handle this, better? :confused:
The One common and always do response is to use EXTREME kindness and charity.

The next [in my opinion] necessary thing is to SMILE and say we are practicing Catholics. Allow them to respond.

Now where one goes from there is highly circumstantial.

Are you sufficiently informed about what the RCC Teaches to share our faith AND to defend it factually and always with charity? IF you are, and have the time, invite them in, offer them refreshments and debate with them. It would be wonderful to have a Bible handy. Do you have a good understanding of our Bible? If not, you’re likely not ready for the war of ideas your about to enter;)

**Before you began it is highly recommended that you establish acceptable “ground rules.” **For example, we Catholics use the Entire Catholic Bible **{2 Tim. 3:16} **“All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, 17 that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.”

**Sacred Tradition {2 Thess. 2: 13 & Jn. 21:25} **“But we are bound to give thanks to God always for you, brethren beloved by the Lord, because God chose you from the beginning to be saved, through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth. 14 To this he called you through our gospel, so that you may obtain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ. 15 So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter.

Jn.21:25 “But there are also many other things which Jesus did; were every one of them to be written, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written.”

**And COMMON SENSE: { Lk. 1: 26 } **“In the sixth month the angel Gabriel was sent from God to a city of Galilee named Nazareth, 27 to a virgin betrothed to a man whose name was Joseph, of the house of David; and the virgin’s name was Mary. 28 And he came to her and said, “Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with you!” 29 But she was greatly troubled at the saying, and considered in her mind what sort of greeting this might be. 30 And the angel said to her, “Do not be afraid, Mary, for you have found favor with God. 31 And behold, you will conceive in your womb and bear a son, and you shall call his name Jesus. 32 He will be great, and will be called the Son of the Most High; and the Lord God will give to him the throne of his father David, 33 and he will reign over the house of Jacob for ever; and of his kingdom there will be no end.” 34 And Mary said to the angel, “How shall this be, since I have no husband?” 35 And the angel said to her, "The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore the child to be born * will be called holy, the Son of God.

Jesus is the Son of God
Mary is the Mother of Jesus
COMMON SENSE = Mary is therefore the Mother of the Son of God!


Unless ground rules can be established, one is better off to defer the debate.

Be aware that nearly always they travel in-group’s of 2 or 3 so the “odds (they think) are in there favor?

If you don’t have time, if you don’t feel qualified to debate, if you don’t have a bible handy, or if you cannot settle on ground rules. Simply tell them you’re a Catholic, “no thank you” and “God Bless you!”

Love and prayer’s Pat
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top