How is this Papal Bull not Infallible?

[bobzills]

St Augustine is not infallible. .

However, he is a Father of the Church as are the African Fathers. Further, Pope St. Zosimus, Pope John XXII and Pope Gregory X are infallible. They have indicated definitively that babies who die with original sin only on their soul will immediately descend into hell and you can read this for yourself. You have not addressed their statements, so your argument is not convincing.

 

[richwmiller]

However, he is a Father of the Church as are the African Fathers. Further, Pope St. Zosimus, Pope John XXII and Pope Gregory X are infallible. They have indicated definitively that babies who die with original sin only on their soul will immediately descend into hell and you can read this for yourself. You have not addressed their statements, so your argument is not convincing.

The three popes you mention can be infallible depending on how they wrote and what they wrote and to whom they wrote or they could not.
Have you checked out the commission’s report?
I believe it talks about all the people you mention.
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20070419_un-baptised-infants_en.html

 

[DJim]

Bobzills remains genuinely wrong in his assessment of the Magisterial view of the fate of unbaptized babies.

There is another thread active on this topic. I’d suggest going to that one for some interesting dialogue ahead…

DJim

 

[Michael_Francis]

Thread closed.