How many wills does Jesus have?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Big_Dummy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your last reply [user]steve b[/user], I was indeed edified!

If I someday decide to return to communion with Rome I really don’t feel my Miaphysite/Monophysite will be an issue at all because, I am convinced that Rome actually does technically/officially hold the Miaphysite view. Of course I could be wrong about this, but I don’t think so.

Just a few minor responses…
What then is the incarnation or its purpose?
Deification/Salvation
All of that in quotes [the four adverbs], pertains to the Divinity. The divinity as a result of the incarnation doesn’t change one iota. That does NOT mean the 2 natures aren’t distinct. All the changes happened only to the human nature being assumed into the divinity.

Human nature DID change as a result of the incarnation and hypostatic union.
I don’t believe that is correct even from the Roman Catholic point of view. Chalcedon Confession is: Christ has two natures, human and divine, united in one person without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. The four adverbs “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation” do not pertain only to the divine nature but to both.
Would you explain this difference in two natures vs from two natures] further?
St. Cyril the Great taught us not to talk about two natures after the incarnation. It is from him that the term “Miaphysite” came. An often used quote from him said, “One Nature of God the Incarnate Logos” (Mia Physis Tou Theou Logou Sesarkwmene).
The problem was, it was argued by opponants that Christ’s Divine nature so absorbed His human nature, that His human nature, ceased to exist – thus giving birth to the heresy of Monophysitism which spread throughout the East. As you know, this heresy was condemned.
This is almost a complete farce. Heretics that believed Christ’s divine nature absorbed His human nature were hard to be found. The Coptic Church has never believed this, and has in fact condemned it too as a heresy. It was a falsehood put forth that this is what “Monophysite’s” believe. The use of the term “Miaphysite” is mainly used to make sure people no not think that is what we believe. I would actually prefer to call myself a Monophysite (Pope Shenouda III uses the term “Monophysite” instead of “Miaphysite”), but if I did so I would run the risk of people assuming that I am one of those, almost non-existent, heretics.

Thanks for the dialog!

In Christ, [user]JohnVIII[/USER]
 
If I someday decide to return to communion with Rome I really don’t feel my Miaphysite/Monophysite will be an issue at all because,* I am convinced that Rome actually does technically/officially hold the Miaphysite view. Of course I could be wrong about this,* but I don’t think so.
John,

Monophysitism is a heresy.
newadvent.org/cathen/10489b.htm
J:
I don’t believe that is correct even from the Roman Catholic point of view. Chalcedon Confession is: Christ has two natures, human and divine, united in one person without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. The four adverbs “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation” do not pertain only to the divine nature but to both.
Re: human nature

for space, see the links below. particularly (the effects of the incarnation on Christ’s soul and human will)

Where human nature changed that He assumed, He couldn’t sin.
J:
St. Cyril the Great taught us not to talk about two natures after the incarnation. It is from him that the term “Miaphysite” came. An often used quote from him said, “One Nature of God the Incarnate Logos” (Mia Physis Tou Theou Logou Sesarkwmene).
Included in the link provided up the page
J:
This is almost a complete farce. Heretics that believed Christ’s divine nature absorbed His human nature were hard to be found. The Coptic Church has never believed this, and has in fact condemned it too as a heresy. It was a falsehood put forth that this is what “Monophysite’s” believe. The use of the term “Miaphysite” is mainly used to make sure people no not think that is what we believe. I would actually prefer to call myself a Monophysite (Pope Shenouda III uses the term “Monophysite” instead of “Miaphysite”), but if I did so I would run the risk of people assuming that I am one of those, almost non-existent, heretics.

Thanks for the dialog!

In Christ, [user]JohnVIII[/user]
I enjoyed the dialogue as well. Be sure to check out the following

Human nature of Jesus, including heresies newadvent.org/cathen/07706b.htm#I2
The Catholic view, newadvent.org/cathen/07706b.htm#II4

Effects of the incarnation, on
newadvent.org/cathen/07706b.htm#III
 
Dear [user]steve b[/user];

I read the links you provided…
Monophysitism is a heresy.
newadvent.org/cathen/10489b.htm

Be sure to check out the following
Human nature of Jesus, including heresies newadvent.org/cathen/07706b.htm#I2
The Catholic view, newadvent.org/cathen/07706b.htm#II4
… and now I would ask you to read them too, and do so with this question in mind, ask your self, “Is there anything written here that says you must believe that two separate natures in Christ?”. You will see that, as long as you confess that Jesus is true God and true man you are not in heresy you are orthodox! Nowhere does it say that if you do not also say the hypostatic union is still two natures now after the incarnation you are not orthodox. Personally I think they were deliberately very careful to make sure they didn’t say that because the Catholic Church does accept the Miaphysite view as valid!

The only thing I would not agree with is the mis-defining of the term Monophysite. Once again virtually everyone today that has been labled “Monophysite” do NOT hold the idea that Jesus is only divine and not human! In reality Monophysite’s are the same as Miaphysite’s, we believe that Jesus is 100% God and 100% man, true God and true man! the ONLY thing that is different from the Diophysite (Roman Catholic) view is that the two natures are one composite nature after the incarnation, and this view the Catholic Church has said is acceptable so long as you confess the four adverbs: “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation”.

The links sort of tried to label a man named “Eutyches” as a heretic that denied the human nature of Jesus, but this was not even a fact of history, as Eutyches was falsely accused of this. Eutyches confessed that Mary was human and that Jesus truly go His humanity from Mary. So this really is a heresy without a heretic! I sometimes wonder if anyone has ever believed in this heresy?! Possible I guess, but I don’t know of any.

Eutychianism was a made up heresy that those who rejected the Council of Chalcedon and the Tome of Pope Leo were falsely accused of believing. But really those who rejected Chalcedon did so for false reasons as well. Mainly they rejected it because they thought that this declaration of Pope Leo, that Christ is in two natures, meant that Pope Leo was saying that Christ is two persons, which is the heresy of Nestorius. So they were mistaken as well, in fact there is a good argument that shows that what Pope Leo meant by “in two natures”, was the same thing as “from two natures”.

Not only do I believe that I am correct to say that the Catholic Church does not condemn the Miaphysite view, but it is also true that Miaphysite believers do not condemn the Diophysite either, now that there is a correct understanding of it. Here’s a quote from Patriarch St. Nersess the Gracefilled (12th century Armenian Patriarch) to show this point across:

" If one says ‘one nature’ in the sense of the indissoluble and indivisible union and not in the sense of confusion, and if one says ‘two natures’ as being without confusion, alteration or signifying division, then both positions are within the orbit of orthodoxy. "

God Bless!
 
One problem was that words were defined differently by different people. For example, hypostasis and physis are the words for person and nature respectively. But in Greek they were both terms that refered to nature. The miaphysites tended to use them synonymously, whereas the Romans and Greeks used them to designate different concepts.
 
In the beginning, before the fall, human nature was perfect. THAT’s the human nature Jesus assumed. Just as Adam and Eve should have resisted sin, and remained perfect, they didn’t. As a result, they couldn’t pass on to all the generations, what they lost. That doesn’t mean Jesus (the new Adam) by assuming a perfect human nature, void of imperfections, and keeping it pristine for all eternity, can’t relate completely to us.
The problem is that ‘homo-ousios with man’ requires that he actually recieve his human nature from the same stalk as every other human. It must be the human nature recieved from Adam. If it is not, then Jesus is not homoousios with humanity. It doesn’t matter how much his humanity is like ours, if he is not from the stalk of Adam it doesn’t matter.

It is similar to the concept of the procession of the Son from the Father. The humanity of Christ proceeds from that of Adam. If you were to say that Jesus didn’t proceed from the Father, then he also wouldn’t be homo-ousios with the Father. They would be two seperate gods, with two seperate natures, no matter how similar. The same goes for the humanity of Christ. If it doesn’t proceed from Adam, then the most you can say is that they are ‘like in essence’ (homoi-ousios:an Arian phrase).

When you say that Jesus’ humanity was the humanity before the fall you are implying that it was recieved from some other source than Adam and Eve who were fallen.
 
The problem is that ‘homo-ousios with man’ requires that he actually recieve his human nature from the same stalk as every other human. It must be the human nature recieved from Adam. If it is not, then Jesus is not homoousios with humanity. It doesn’t matter how much his humanity is like ours, if he is not from the stalk of Adam it doesn’t matter.

It is similar to the concept of the procession of the Son from the Father. The humanity of Christ proceeds from that of Adam. If you were to say that Jesus didn’t proceed from the Father, then he also wouldn’t be homo-ousios with the Father. They would be two seperate gods, with two seperate natures, no matter how similar. The same goes for the humanity of Christ. If it doesn’t proceed from Adam, then the most you can say is that they are ‘like in essence’ (homoi-ousios:an Arian phrase).

When you say that Jesus’ humanity was the humanity before the fall you are implying that it was recieved from some other source than Adam and Eve who were fallen.
Maybe I didn’t state it as well as I could have.

His tree goes back to Adam. [Lk 3:38], that doesn’t mean Jesus assumed the sin of Adam, into His nature at the incarnation and hypostatic union of human and Divine natures… Jesus is the NEW Adam, without sin, and eternalized that.

IN ThE WILL

Sinlessness
The effect of the Incarnation on the human will of Christ was to leave it free in all things save only sin. It was absolutely impossible that any stain of sin should soil the soul of Christ. Neither sinful act of the will nor sinful habit of the soul were in keeping with the Hypostatic Union. The fact that Christ never sinned is an article of faith (see Council, Ephes., can. x, in Denzinger, 122, wherein the sinlessness of Christ is implicit in the definition that he did not offer Himself for Himself, but for us). This fact of Christ’s* sinlessness is evident from the Scripture. “There is no sin in Him” (1 John 3:5). Him, who knew no sin, he hath made sin for us" i.e. a victim for sin (2 Corinthians 5:21) "*

Liberty :

The will of Christ remained free after the Incarnation. This is an article of faith. The Scripture is most clear on this point. “When he had tasted, he would not drink” (Matthew 27:34). “I will; be thou made clean” (Matthew 8:3). The liberty of Christ was such that He merited. “He humbled himself, becoming obedient unto death, even to the death of the cross. For which cause God also hath exalted him” (Philippians 2:8). “Who having joy set before him, endured the cross” (Hebrews 12:2). That Christ was free in the matter of death, is the teaching of all Catholics; else He did not merit nor satisfy for us by His death. *Just how to reconcile this liberty of Christ with the impossibility of His committing sin has ever been a crux for theologians. Some seventeen explanations are given (see Summa Theologica III:47:3, ad 3; Molina, “Concordia”, d. liii, membr. 4). *
 
Dear [user]steve b[/user];

I read the links you provided…

… and now I would ask you to read them too, and do so with this question in mind, ask your self, “Is there anything written here that says you must believe that two separate natures in Christ?”.
written proofs Jesus has a sepetate human nature.
to be continued
 
(continued)
You will see that, as long as you confess that Jesus is true God and true man you are not in heresy you are orthodox! Nowhere does it say that if you do not also say the hypostatic union is still two natures now after the incarnation you are not orthodox. Personally I think they were deliberately very careful to make sure they didn’t say that because the Catholic Church does accept the Miaphysite view as valid!
Both natures, Divine and human, remain distinct but hypostatically united. The miaphysite position is a heresy.
J:
The only thing I would not agree with is the mis-defining of the term Monophysite. Once again virtually everyone today that has been labled “Monophysite” do NOT hold the idea that Jesus is only divine and not human!
Definitions are clear.
Monophysites and Monophysitism newadvent.org/cathen/10489b.htm
J:
In reality Monophysite’s are the same as Miaphysite’s, we believe that Jesus is 100% God and 100% man, true God and true man! the ONLY thing that is different from the Diophysite (Roman Catholic) view is that the two natures are one composite nature after the incarnation, and this view the Catholic Church has said is acceptable so long as you confess the four adverbs: “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation”.
Do you have a reverence for that?
J:
The links sort of tried to label a man named “Eutyches” as a heretic that denied the human nature of Jesus, but this was not even a fact of history, as Eutyches was falsely accused of this. Eutyches confessed that Mary was human and that Jesus truly got His humanity from Mary. So this really is a heresy without a heretic! I sometimes wonder if anyone has ever believed in this heresy?! Possible I guess, but I don’t know of any.
he apparantly agreed to only 1 nature after the incarnation. . Therefore, it was deemed bottomline, If you do not say two natures after the union, you’re in effect saying there is mixture and confusion of natures which is heretical.
newadvent.org/cathen/05631a.htm
J:
Eutychianism was a made up heresy that those who rejected the Council of Chalcedon and the Tome of Pope Leo were falsely accused of believing. But really those who rejected Chalcedon did so for false reasons as well. Mainly they rejected it because they thought that this declaration of Pope Leo, that Christ is in two natures, meant that Pope Leo was saying that Christ is two persons, which is the heresy of Nestorius. So they were mistaken as well, in fact there is a good argument that shows that what Pope Leo meant by “in two natures”, was the same thing as “from two natures”.
Eutychianism is adequately identified newadvent.org/cathen/05633a.htm
J:
Not only do I believe that I am correct to say that the Catholic Church does not condemn the Miaphysite view, but it is also true that Miaphysite believers do not condemn the Diophysite either, now that there is a correct understanding of it. Here’s a quote from Patriarch St. Nersess the Gracefilled (12th century Armenian Patriarch) to show this point across:

" If one says ‘one nature’ in the sense of the indissoluble and indivisible union and not in the sense of confusion, and if one says ‘two natures’ as being without confusion, alteration or signifying division, then both positions are within the orbit of orthodoxy. "

God Bless!
You’re still trying to find ways to say one nature .
 
“God did not regard Divine Nature as something not to be shared. He emptied Himself, pour Himself out, became one of us … that we might become sharers in His Divine Nature.”
St Athanasius said it more powerfully, “God became man … so that man might become God.”

Hello BD –
I’ve read only your first and opening posting. Time prevents me reading all way through. And I don’t think it’s necessary.

Jesus Christ is True God (the Second Divine Person) AND a real human being, with a real and complete human nature.

There are two intellects in Christ > the Divine Intellect AND a human intellect.
There are two free wills in Christ > the Divine Free Will AND a human free will.
There are two natures in Christ > the Divine Nature AND a human nature.
Jesus Christ has a complete assemblage of emotions, the same as yours.
And all these are united in the One Divine Person (hypostatic union).

They are united smoothly and beautifully and perfectly just like your soul and intellect and free will and memory and several other factors are united in the one person you are.

More is presented about these things in CCC (Catechism of the Catholic Church) 461-478.
Have I presented things understandingly?
Blessing and God’s Love! John (JohnJFarren)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top