J
JohnVIII
Guest
Thank you for your last reply [user]steve b[/user], I was indeed edified!
If I someday decide to return to communion with Rome I really don’t feel my Miaphysite/Monophysite will be an issue at all because, I am convinced that Rome actually does technically/officially hold the Miaphysite view. Of course I could be wrong about this, but I don’t think so.
Just a few minor responses…
Thanks for the dialog!
In Christ, [user]JohnVIII[/USER]
If I someday decide to return to communion with Rome I really don’t feel my Miaphysite/Monophysite will be an issue at all because, I am convinced that Rome actually does technically/officially hold the Miaphysite view. Of course I could be wrong about this, but I don’t think so.
Just a few minor responses…
Deification/SalvationWhat then is the incarnation or its purpose?
I don’t believe that is correct even from the Roman Catholic point of view. Chalcedon Confession is: Christ has two natures, human and divine, united in one person without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. The four adverbs “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation” do not pertain only to the divine nature but to both.All of that in quotes [the four adverbs], pertains to the Divinity. The divinity as a result of the incarnation doesn’t change one iota. That does NOT mean the 2 natures aren’t distinct. All the changes happened only to the human nature being assumed into the divinity.
Human nature DID change as a result of the incarnation and hypostatic union.
St. Cyril the Great taught us not to talk about two natures after the incarnation. It is from him that the term “Miaphysite” came. An often used quote from him said, “One Nature of God the Incarnate Logos” (Mia Physis Tou Theou Logou Sesarkwmene).Would you explain this difference in two natures vs from two natures] further?
This is almost a complete farce. Heretics that believed Christ’s divine nature absorbed His human nature were hard to be found. The Coptic Church has never believed this, and has in fact condemned it too as a heresy. It was a falsehood put forth that this is what “Monophysite’s” believe. The use of the term “Miaphysite” is mainly used to make sure people no not think that is what we believe. I would actually prefer to call myself a Monophysite (Pope Shenouda III uses the term “Monophysite” instead of “Miaphysite”), but if I did so I would run the risk of people assuming that I am one of those, almost non-existent, heretics.The problem was, it was argued by opponants that Christ’s Divine nature so absorbed His human nature, that His human nature, ceased to exist – thus giving birth to the heresy of Monophysitism which spread throughout the East. As you know, this heresy was condemned.
Thanks for the dialog!
In Christ, [user]JohnVIII[/USER]