How to console a grieving widow who is abusive to her adult child

  • Thread starter Thread starter joannkt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

joannkt

Guest
This past weekend I attended the funeral & burial of my friend’s father. While not estranged, I have known for years that my friend and her family have had a difficult relationship. I had heard many stories over the years of ways in which my adopted friend was relegated to 2nd-class status after the unexpected birth of her parents’ BIOLOGICAL son seven months later. I didn’t DISBELIEVE the stories, but the events of this weekend made me realize that things had been much worse that I had imagined.

When I went to the hospital several weeks ago to lend support I became very friendly with her mother, a devout Catholic who is very active in her church. At the funeral, I couldn’t help but notice that while she treated me wonderfully, she never missed an opportunity to belittle, snub, or generally tear down my friend in front of family, friends and members of the church. This culminated in her mother attempting to start the burial before my friend and I, among other guests, arrived having seen us only minutes before and knowing we were on the way. My friend’s 20-year-old son had been on his knees graveside REPEATEDLY begging his grandmother, his uncle, and the deacon performing the service, not to begin before his mother arrived. Thankfully, the deacon waited the FOUR minutes for us to arrive at the cemetery before beginning and the service ended before the scheduled start time - as guests were still arriving. Those at the burial all witnessed this and were embarrassed. Many of them told me privately that they believe the whole point of trying to start early was to try to make my friend miss her father’s burial because she “doesn’t count”.

When she was a teenager, my friend asked her parents why they didn’t give her back when they found out that they were expecting and they said, “What would it LOOK like?” This seems to be a reason behind many of the painful events in my friend’s life. Her parents had a very strong desire to APPEAR to be good, virtuous Catholics to friends and fellow parishioners but since they “behave in public” there was never any help for my friend from the outside.

I want to offer her love and support while she grieves the loss of her beloved husband of 60+ years, BUT, I have such mixed feelings. It’s not my place to address the family’s private problems, but I also don’t want to be just another person who witnesses these things happening and says and does nothing. I would dearly love to let her know that I care for her DESPITE past events as I imagine that she harbors a great deal of personal pain that needs healing. I wouldn’t want to put her on the spot, but I also don’t want to give the impression that her behaviour is acceptable.

I’m not sure what to do.
 
Look, the mother/wife is not your friend. Your friend is the one being abused by the mother/wife. This woman is mentally ill. Or evil. Do not cultivate a friendship with her. Remain by your real friend’s side, she needs you because she has been abused. Don’t abuse her trust by befriending her mother and trying to remain friends with her.

Nothing you say is going to impact this woman if she behaves this way towards her own daughter. She is not going to get subtle hints or recriminations. I don’t know why you would want to cultivate a friendship with her at all. Or am I misunderstanding your post?
 
Last edited:
Having been abused similarly by both my parents for 40 years now, I can definitely say to stop worrying about this woman… Pay all your attention to your friend, instead. She needs it soooo much more than the widow does. My heart is aching for her.
 
You make a great point that I have been agonizing over. Of COURSE my friend comes first and she always will, but do we just look the other way when we see someone treating others horribly? Do we just write off a person who is mentally ill or suffering in some way that makes them behave badly? Is that what Jesus would do? (I know, childish, but I keep it in mind when I’m trying to think ethical questions through. :))

I keep trying to figure out what “doing unto others” means to me in this situation. I imagine how she must be feeling. She just lost her husband and now everyone has seen her behaving badly in public for the first time and is feeling humiliated (and dare I say ashamed?). If I was her I would fear people turning their backs on me and that just doesn’t seem like the charitable thing to do.

I’ve been reading about Works of mercy and trying to find some guidance there, but I can’t find anything that seems to apply.

I guess just pray for her.
 
I have to agree with 1ke – why do you want a relationship with someone who has hurt your friend do badly? It seems to me that would be a betrayal of your friend, and that’s certainly the last thing she needs.
 
I imagine how she must be feeling. She just lost her husband and now everyone has seen her behaving badly in public for the first time and is feeling humiliated (and dare I say ashamed?). If I was her I would fear people turning their backs on me and that just doesn’t seem like the charitable thing to do.
I’ve known people like your friend’s mother. I really wouldn’t bet that she’s feeling any shame or humiliation. Remember, she and her late husband spent decades justifying their behavior to themselves. They had to be very, very good at it, for her to act that way in public.

For you to proceed with this idea would be the very opposite of a work of mercy when it comes to your friend. I really hope you won’t do this to her.
 
Your loyalty is to your friend. Comfort her and support her during this time when she is grieving a death and dealing with being mistreated by her mother. Leave the mother alone. You’re not friends with the mother, and unless your friend has specifically asked you to get involved in her family business, you saying anything to her mother may well just pour fuel on an already smoldering fire.

If you want to do something for abusive, mental mom, you can pray for her, preferably without telling your friend you’re doing it.
 
I imagine how she must be feeling. She just lost her husband and now everyone has seen her behaving badly in public for the first time and is feeling humiliated (and dare I say ashamed?).
You are imagining it, correct. You are imagining what she would feel is what you would feel. But that is a mistake, you’re assuming she feels shame or humiliation. In my experience people like this tend to blame the other. She will find a way to blame her daughter for her behavior.
 
Last edited:
If I was her I would fear people turning their backs on me and that just doesn’t seem like the charitable thing to do.
You aren’t turning your back on her. You weren’t her friend a week ago, you need not be her friend now. You are her daughter’s friend and it should always be through that lens and context that you are in contact with her. Do not seek out a friendship outside of that context.
 
Last edited:
You most certainly can and should call her out on how she treats your friend. If we don’t stand up to bullies they keep bullying people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top