How to help my Evangelical friend move towards Catholocism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter victrolatim
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

victrolatim

Guest
I was thinking about this last night during the Easter vigil when the RCIA candidates were being baptized and confirmed. I will try and keep the explanations brief but details are pertinent to the situation.

My friend is in her late 20s and, due to financial reasons, is still living under mom and dad’s roof. She was raised/is evangelical Protestant, attending one of those “non-denominational” megachurches nearby. She holds things very close to her chest and rarely openly talks about things that are bothering her. Recently, she has been noticing one thing after another that her church is teaching that she just doesn’t agree with. When I ask her about such things (teachings about roles of women, family, creation, saints, etc.) I ask her what she believes and what her church is saying. When she explains to me, she’s interested when I tell her what she believes is actually what the Catholic Church teaches and I try to show her the Catechism to back it up when I can. She holds the scriptures very close and I thought that if I show her the scriptural basis for Church teaching it would help. In addition, she is employed as a teacher at a Catholic school. She has told me that she really likes the priest and his sermons. I have occasionally attended the church and the pastor is very firm on explaining misconceptions and church doctrine in his sermons. Since his term began, he has taken the parish from a very confusing “70’s” type mentality to a very warm, solemn atmosphere with no more “wackiness”

Ok, the roadblocks. Despite all of this, my friend is still struggling with a lot of the mainstream Protestant positions. Things like Mary, the notion that “Catholics don’t read the Bible”, the true presence in the Eucharist, confession to a priest etc. . I have suggested that she talk to the priest but she is very apprehensive. Her father is very authoritarian and touts that he was born Catholic but then he “was saved”. If she does not attend the same service as her family on Sunday (choosing a later time due to fatigue), he quizzes her on the sermon to make sure she went. I have sensed for a while that her church has been making her uncomfortable but, as I mentioned, she will bury a lot of things until it is bothering her so much she has to tell someone.

So how do I sort of nudge her towards the Church given the circumstances? I have been making sure that I can gently and logically explain misconceptions when I can but I am careful not to come off as pushy or accusatory. Also, I feel the best evangelization so far is just being myself, attending Mass and living by example. The hardest thing at this point is the family situation.
 
I think that what you are doing is good. Just pray for her, and let God be her guide. Keep inviting her to Mass with you or to speak with her or your priest. The Holy Spirit will lead her when the time is right.

May God bless you and your friend forever! 🙂
 
Leading a good life and praying for her are your best options.
 
I have been making sure that I can gently and logically explain misconceptions when I can but I am careful not to come off as pushy or accusatory. Also, I feel the best evangelization so far is just being myself, attending Mass and living by example. The hardest thing at this point is the family situation.
Everything you are doing is right-on. Make sure you educate yourself very well so you can answer her questions. Pray for her, and invite her to mass every so often.
 
Agree with above posts. I will add sometimes in evangelical, authoritarian families, there is this very stark patriarchal form of family governance. She may face intense opposition until she is able to get out on her own, and even afterward. Conversion is not easy in these families, in fact it is white martyrdom. Keep this in mind as you pray for her. She will need to see the truth very clearly, for only the love of God and the clear ring of His truth can make going through this kind of family turmoil worthwhile.

I will pray with you.
 
I was thinking about this last night during the Easter vigil when the RCIA candidates were being baptized and confirmed. I will try and keep the explanations brief but details are pertinent to the situation.

My friend is in her late 20s and, due to financial reasons, is still living under mom and dad’s roof. She was raised/is evangelical Protestant, attending one of those “non-denominational” megachurches nearby. She holds things very close to her chest and rarely openly talks about things that are bothering her. Recently, she has been noticing one thing after another that her church is teaching that she just doesn’t agree with. When I ask her about such things (teachings about roles of women, family, creation, saints, etc.) I ask her what she believes and what her church is saying. When she explains to me, she’s interested when I tell her what she believes is actually what the Catholic Church teaches and I try to show her the Catechism to back it up when I can. She holds the scriptures very close and I thought that if I show her the scriptural basis for Church teaching it would help. In addition, she is employed as a teacher at a Catholic school. She has told me that she really likes the priest and his sermons. I have occasionally attended the church and the pastor is very firm on explaining misconceptions and church doctrine in his sermons. Since his term began, he has taken the parish from a very confusing “70’s” type mentality to a very warm, solemn atmosphere with no more “wackiness”

Ok, the roadblocks. Despite all of this, my friend is still struggling with a lot of the mainstream Protestant positions. Things like Mary, the notion that “Catholics don’t read the Bible”, the true presence in the Eucharist, confession to a priest etc. . I have suggested that she talk to the priest but she is very apprehensive. Her father is very authoritarian and touts that he was born Catholic but then he “was saved”. If she does not attend the same service as her family on Sunday (choosing a later time due to fatigue), he quizzes her on the sermon to make sure she went. I have sensed for a while that her church has been making her uncomfortable but, as I mentioned, she will bury a lot of things until it is bothering her so much she has to tell someone.

So how do I sort of nudge her towards the Church given the circumstances? I have been making sure that I can gently and logically explain misconceptions when I can but I am careful not to come off as pushy or accusatory. Also, I feel the best evangelization so far is just being myself, attending Mass and living by example. The hardest thing at this point is the family situation.
WOW!:o

The devil IS in the details.

1st We, me and you are not in the conversion “business” directly; that is GOD"S Role:)

Certainly God can and DOES use us to advantage at tiles.

2nd. Catholicism is 2,000 years old. There is a glut of Sacred Tradition and believes that MUST be addressed ONE issue at a time; because having been misinformed is FAR worse than simply not being informed at all… One has to UNDO, before doing:)

3td there is no substitute for PRAYER for your friend. God needs to grant sufficient grace for her to sever the bonds of the controlling influences she is living in.

So pray also for her parents

4th take one issue at a time; and center on that issue until it is not only explained, but understood.

MOST Catholic Issues DO have a biblical basis, so start with them; one isse, one topic at a time and do not permit yourself to be sidetracked…

TRY to get from her a list or an articulated expression of the MAJOR to Minor issues she is unclear about; then work from this list prayerfully, carefully, factually and always with extreme charity…

There is a book you REALLY ought to rad by the founder of CAF; Karl Keating [And because of its age its very inexpensive too:D]

CATHOLICISM AND FUNDAMENTALISM: The Attack of Romanism by Bile Christians"

LOOK for a private message from me please.

Easter Blessings,

Patrick [PJM] here on CAF
 
Here is a list of Catholic writers and apologists where were very instrumental in our conversion:

Dr. Scott Hahn
Tim Staples
Steve Ray
Devin Rose
Bruce Sullivan
Jennifer Fulwiler
David Currie
Karl Keating

Look into their resources and consider purchasing their books and/or audios for your friend.
 
I would do some research so I would have a number of facts / examples and simply pose this one question that one can say has been “bothering” you. Why do all these miracles only happen in the Catholic Church, including Eastern Orthodox? Is someone trying to tell me something?

I specifically like all the Eucharistic miracles beginning with Lanciano in the early 700’s. One can just look at all the Eucharistic miracles and go from there. Let that person come to his own conclusion.
👍
 
I once worked with several non-denominational “Bible Christians” who were curious about the tame Catholic they suddenly had in their midst. I had studied a lot of theology and apologetics but suddenly I had to learn to explain why Catholics believe certain things…from the Bible.

I am still studying, reading the Bible and praying because I need to "be ready to give an explanation for the hope that is in [me]".

One of my favourite things is to watch The Journey Home stories, because the people who have come into the Church have struggled with all the issues your friend has, and tell how they overcame their original objections.
 
Bishop Robert Barron’s *Catholicism * series is excellent and presents the Catholic faith so beautifully …I would say it is an easy watch 🙂
 
… my friend is still struggling with a lot of the mainstream Protestant positions. Things like Mary, the notion that “Catholics don’t read the Bible”, the true presence in the Eucharist, confession to a priest etc. I have suggested that she talk to the priest but she is very apprehensive. …
Don’t rush her. It sounds like she is on a lot of solid ground already. Give thanks to God for that. I think her dad needs prayer that he doesn’t get too “controlling” in their relationship. Meantime, get her to prioritise - out of the four issues you list here - which are the most urgent one or two for her. That way, she needn’t feel so daunted. If she thinks it will be a relaxed journey to finding out various things, she needn’t feel too hemmed in. Meantime, you could ask her if there are still some things that she appreciates about her usual church.

In terms of Bible reading there are some in every church that don’t (including some “Bible Christians”). Catholic churches have been under orders to hold Bible studies for many years now so there is every reason they should. In addition, Catholics don’t need to await permission to invite others to join them for Bible study at home.

Our Father said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top