Humanae Vitae and Contraception

  • Thread starter Thread starter GracieRuth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One is NOT a person, until one DOES exist! God Bless, Memaw
This does not answer the question. In scenario C, should a person have come into existence?

In reality, scenarios B and C are almost identical. Couple B may have known they did not want a child, and definitively decided after the outcome of the act. Couple C knew they did not want a child from the** beginning,** and blocked the outcome of the act. In B and C, both couples changed the outcome of the act. B, after the act. C, ahead of the act. But, we can definitively say that in all three scenarios, the outcomes should have been identical. Life should have existed.
 
I don’t know whether the premise “God intends…” is meaningful. Does God make plans that we thwart? Without a meaningful premise, I can’t answer.

And I think you need a case D. The couple planned to have sex that night, and God intended a child to be born, but the husband instead accepted an invitation to a poker game. 😃 Did husband thwart God’s plan and deny life?
Okay, don’t say intended. But in scenario C, can we objectively say a person should exist, that doesn’t?

Not sure if you can call it thwarting God’s plan, but we can sure change what God intended for us. It was not God’s plan for Adam and Eve to eat the apple. Also what Jesus teaches about divorce, sure seems to indicate that we can go against God’s plan: 'what God has joined.’

There is no thwarting of life when the act does not take place. If that were the case, than my eating this salami sandwich is thwarting life. 😉
 
Okay, don’t say intended. But in scenario C, can we objectively say a person should exist, that doesn’t?

Not sure if you can call it thwarting God’s plan, but we can sure change what God intended for us. It was not God’s plan for Adam and Eve to eat the apple. Also what Jesus teaches about divorce, sure seems to indicate that we can go against God’s plan: 'what God has joined.’

There is no thwarting of life when the act does not take place. If that were the case, than my eating this salami sandwich is thwarting life. 😉
But the act should have - if the parties agreed it would… Sorry, I find the whole notion of saying something unpredictable should have happened, but the condom made it not happen, to be overreach. And when the something is conception, to call the action that supposedly averted that to be akin to murder, just bizarre. I think my poker game story is not all that much more bizarre.
 
But the act should have - if the parties agreed it would… Sorry, I find the whole notion of saying something unpredictable should have happened, but the condom made it not happen, to be overreach.
You are not answering the question though. In fact your answer makes no sense at all. The scenario originally set up was that fertilization would occur in scenario C. In fact, why use a condom at all, if you do not think scenario C is the possible outcome of the act?
And when the something is conception, to call the action that supposedly averted that to be akin to murder, just bizarre. I think my poker game story is not all that much more bizarre.
You think it is bizarre, as most would, because most people do not want to think of the consequences of their actions. Some do, and are horrified when they realize just what their actions entailed.

There is a clear reason why not to call scenario C murder though. And that is because in scenario C, the couple had no way of knowing ahead of time that life would have resulted from their act, had they not prevented it from coming into existence with the use of contraception. There is no guarantee ahead of time that fertilization would have happened. In scenario B, we know that fertilization did happen.

In scenario B, we can see the consequences of the act (life, then an abortion). In scenario C, though we see the consequences (no pregnancy), the consequences are really in doubt, because we have no way of knowing if fertilization would have occurred, due to the use of contraception.

Now remember, in scenario C, we have set up ahead of time that fertilization would have occurred. The couple in scenario B, are culpable because they knew life occurred as the result of their act, and chose to abort. The couple in scenario C are not culpable in the same way as the couple in scenario B, because they knew life could result from their act, and chose to block the possibility ahead of time. I agree it’s not murder. But it is something. Life should have occurred, in scenario C. That is not in dispute. It is not murder, but what exactly is it? Life should have occurred.

Is it so different than this analogy?

1.) A man takes a rifle, aims into a crowd, and shoots person x, killing him.
2.) A man takes a rifle, shoots a gun straight up into the air, not meaning to hit anyone, but the bullet falls and hits person x, killing him.
3.) A man takes a rifle, aims to kill person x, but misses him, and no one is hurt.

We can objectively say that in all three scenarios, the man with the rifle is guilty. Is the man in scenario 3, more guilty than scenario 2? After all he attempted murder. But in scenario 2, though he did not attempt to hit anyone, murder did occur, blood is on his hands, and he is just as guilty as scenario 1, because he should have known that recklessly firing a gun into the air above a crowd, could have dire consequences. All three scenarios are guilty of murder in some way, though in scenario 3 no one died.

Back to the couple and the marital act:

1.) In scenario B, we can objectively say as Catholics that the couple made a horrible decision to abort, after the act was performed.
2.) Given that life should have occurred in scenario C, how can we objectively say that couple did not make a horrible decision almost to a level as the couple in scenario B?

I contend, the only difference in culpability, is the couple in scenario C, has no knowledge ahead of time that this particular time, the act would have resulted in life, if not for contraception blocking fertilization. But in both scenarios, we can objectively say, where two years down the road we should see a baby, in neither case do we.

And do not compare this to NFP. In scenarios A, B and C, the act that brings forth life is engaged in, and we are strictly talking about the consequences of that particular act at a certain point in time. With NFP, the act that brings forth life is not engaged in, so has no bearing on this discussion.
 
Duane. I rejected your analogy some posts ago. Detracting from the possibility of a new life being created is very different to eliminating a life co-created with God. Many who use contraception would never pursue ending a pregnancy via abortion. The CCC places contraception under the 6th not 5th commandment.
 
Duane. I rejected your analogy some posts ago. Detracting from the possibility of a new life being created is very different to eliminating a life co-created with God. Many who use contraception would never pursue ending a pregnancy via abortion. The CCC places contraception under the 6th not 5th commandment.
Rau, I understand. And I understand why the Church places it under the 5th. And yet, we can definitively say, to use your words, where life should have been co-created with God, it wasn’t, because of our actions. And in some way, though you reject it, it surely is a prevenient elimination of life.

I think we can agree that nothing either of us say will change the others opinion on the matter, and the conversation has run it’s course.

Thank you for the dialogue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top