Husband's loyalty to wife? Or no big deal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jmj777
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s a communication issue. Based on the previous gift thread, you did display an unwillingness to communicate the gift issue properly to your husband. I think working on your communication with your spouse should be a priority.
 
jmj777,

I am sorry that some of the posts have felt like attacks. A lot of people have different ways of handling conflicts and can be adamantly opposed to ways different from their own. That is just a fact of different temperaments.

In regards to introvert/extrovert, I have increasingly found those terms unhelpful. They are often misunderstood and confused with terms such as shy/outgoing, which mean something entirely different. I think you might be very interested to learn about the four classical temperaments: choleric, melancholic, phlegmatic, and sanguine. I think they offer better insight into behavior patterns in oneself and others and dovetail with Catholic teaching quite nicely.

With regards to your current thread:
I have gone back through several of your threads over the last year. What I have noticed is that in many(most?) of your primary relationships, you have described repeated boundary violations of others against you, that you are unwilling or unable to acknowledge and address. And yet you are feeling resentful or offended or angry because people are violating your boundaries, the boundaries that you aren’t willing to enforce.

Even the most well-intended person who loves you is going to have a tough time being close with you if you don’t begin to understand yourself and become aware of your own boundaries and begin to enforce them. They will literally be always alternating between offending, neglecting, or suffocating you, merely by default.

With respect to your husband’s flirtatious behavior that you describe in this thread, that is a perfect example of a boundary violation. He may as yet be unaware that his behavior is flirtatious, even if everyone else present sees it clearly. In fact, it is best to approach it’s if he is totally unaware of what he has been communicating, and sit him down to explain that his behavior is obviously flirtatious, and that you know he doesn’t mean it that way, but some behaviors are just objectively going to communicate certain things, whether we intend to or not. Sort of like a woman with “resting b**** face”. She doesn’t mean to scowl at people and she has to learn to overcome her social disability by actively reminding herself to put on a pleasant expression. I hope my analogy makes sense and is not offensive. I personally work to use pleasant expressions myself in order to avoid my neutral expression communicating disapproval (except with naughty children of course!).

So I think the behavior you describe definitely needs to be addressed, but not from the perspective of loyalty. Rather from the perspective of social propriety and boundaries of spouses. Just as an aside, I know you said you have an autistic son, by any chance are either you or your husband on the spectrum? That could contribute to certain social challenges that could be alleviated by applying some of the strategies you do to help your son to yourselves. But that might not be applicable…

Also, I think itwouldreally help you to read “Boundaries”, a book written with a Christian worldview in mind that helps people to learn about setting and enforcing proper boundaries in relationships. There is also one for marriage and one for parenting, too, but I would start with the original “Boundaries”. People like us who had incredibly dysfunctional and toxic family life never learned how to understand ourselves or to have appropriate boundaries as a child. It was useful to abusive or manipulative parents to have a defenseless, boundariless child. But we grow up and we must overcome bad habits instilled by toxic parents.

People who have never experienced that sort of manipulation or abuse will not easily understand the challenges such people face. Sometimes, they can be annoyed or exasperated, as seen by some responses in this thread. We have to remember it is because they care and when they see a person perpetuating a cycle of abuse or falling into victim/helpless thinking (habits instilled by toxic parents) they come out forcefully. But it very often only forces a person further into the cycle. So many people do not understand, and thank God they never had to deal with it.

I have been actively working on learning about boundaries and overcoming instilled bad habits for about 6 years now. I am now at the point where I can identify in the moment which manipulation tactic is being wielded and choose not to engage or if I do engage, call a spade a spade. So a person can make great progress and be free of these bad habits of thought, which mostly were for self-preservation while we were still experiencing ongoing abuse or manipulation. There is so much freedom and joy waiting for those who decide to change this about themselves and with God’s help and with lots of hard work, root out the insanity of our upbringing.

I hope my post is received in the earnest concern that I mean it. These are heavy topics, but so much of this is within your ability to directly address. God bless you and good luck!

Feel free to PM me if you want!
:clapping:👍 Brilliant post!
 
I can agree with you that if one spouse is purposely doing something that he/she knows irritates the other. I don’t know that we know that in this situation, though. Maybe there’s more because I haven’t gone back and looked at every thread the OP has started; but in this particular thread, it just sounds like she’s irritated that her husband was nice to someone that she has had a falling out with in a public situation. If that is truly the case, I think the wife is out of line. When you’re in a public setting at a social function, there are ways you act, and intentionally snubbing someone or being rude to them because your wife doesn’t like them is inappropriate. In that case I’d say that it does matter if the wife’s request is reasonable or not. That’s all I’m saying.
Sorry, I disagree again:).
I am a soft extrovert and in tune with social cues, and know that there is a wide disparity between gushing over someones cooking and snubbing. A simple warm hello is one of the other choices her husband had in greeting this person.

This husband’s behavior is bordering on flirtatious- since the op said he does it a lot to women. I think it is rude and inappropriate if this is the case…she needs to tell him to stop, and if she already did, she needs to do it again.

For the guys that replied too-how would you feel if your wife gushed over some other guys accomplishments right in front of you–and you didn’t like this guy? And also was very friendly to other men in your presence even after you told her it bothered you?

I think it would be a bigger deal to some.
 
"…there is a wide disparity between gushing over someones cooking and snubbing. A simple warm hello is one of the other choices her husband had in greeting this person.
Well said! I totally agree that a simple warm hello would have been absolutely no problem. The “gushing over” her cooking was too much.

I really don’t understand other posters’ rejections as if having that healthy balance is completely out of line for me to want my husband to maintain. I never expected him to ignore her, but simply to be nice and drive on.

You’re right in asking how others would feel if their spouses gushed over someone they disliked and their spouses were aware of it.

Peace.

+JMJ+
 
That does not mean the husband is not at fault in this situation, only that the original poster may not be painting a complete picture and that communication and perception are clearly huge problems in this marriage so simple answers are not probably going to fix things, digging deeper and much prayer are probably necessary.
You are right in that I am very sensitive, but this thread is really about the situation. Asking if it would be something that would irritate others. Yes, there are communication issues in our marriage that need to be worked out, but this situation occurred during a time of peace in our marriage.

The quote you referenced was during a very difficult and tumultuous time that we were experiencing. I suppose my posting only the problems prohibit readers to see only the problems and never the good moments.

Clearly my fault, as I am a very private person, but getting (name removed by moderator)ut from others on an anonymous forum helps to see things from different perspectives when I am unable to turn to another in my little microcosm of life.

My marriage struggles do not go without deep and constant prayer. Posting questions on a Catholic forum is how I can obtain others’ (name removed by moderator)ut without any bias. Simple as that.

Peace.

+JMJ+
 
Well said! I totally agree that a simple warm hello would have been absolutely no problem. The “gushing over” her cooking was too much.

I really don’t understand other posters’ rejections as if having that healthy balance is completely out of line for me to want my husband to maintain. I never expected him to ignore her, but simply to be nice and drive on.

You’re right in asking how others would feel if their spouses gushed over someone they disliked and their spouses were aware of it.

Peace.

+JMJ+
But does your husband understand this? Have you clearly told him how the argument affected you and how you would like him to act towards her? It could be that he was just trying to be nice, or that he didn’t realise how badly the argument hurt you. If he knew your friend was upset about it, he may he been overly nice to counter balance it.

I think all types of communication problems are ongoing, in any kind of relationship. You seem to see it as a loyalty vs ignoring feelings issue, and I don’t think your husband was attempting to be disloyal to you by talking to her.

You not liking the way he spoke to her is one thing. If it’s recurring, that’s an issue you need to speak to him about and work on together.

Lou
 
What if…

Husband knows wife is in a fight with another woman.
Husband wants to fix this source of pain for wife. Husband goes out of way to be especially nice to the other woman perhaps in an attempt to demonstrate that there is a chance for dialogue in the situation and that there is no hatred being harbored. Making it appear that the problem can be solved by acting overly friendly. Encouraging a softening of the other woman for the chance to fix it.

Not exactly the smartest thing but it could be a motive. I might do something like that.

Or he is a jerk. I’m not sure what the op wants to hear.

I tend to act overly polite and warm when there is an awkward situation.
 
What if…

Husband knows wife is in a fight with another woman.
Husband wants to fix this source of pain for wife. Husband goes out of way to be especially nice to the other woman perhaps in an attempt to demonstrate that there is a chance for dialogue in the situation and that there is no hatred being harbored. Making it appear that the problem can be solved by acting overly friendly. Encouraging a softening of the other woman for the chance to fix it.

Not exactly the smartest thing but it could be a motive. I might do something like that.

Or he is a jerk. I’m not sure what the op wants to hear.

I tend to act overly polite and warm when there is an awkward situation.
That’s what I was thinking. The OP’s husband may have thought he was doing the OP a favour by being overly nice, and then leaving the OP and her friend to build bridges.

Lou
 
But does your husband understand this? Have you clearly told him how the argument affected you and how you would like him to act towards her? Lou
We talk about his friendliness towards women, there’s an apology, forgiveness, and it’s over… until it happens once again.

Peace.

+JMJ+
 
What if…

Husband knows wife is in a fight with another woman.
Husband wants to fix this source of pain for wife. Husband goes out of way to be especially nice to the other woman perhaps in an attempt to demonstrate that there is a chance for dialogue in the situation and that there is no hatred being harbored. Making it appear that the problem can be solved by acting overly friendly. Encouraging a softening of the other woman for the chance to fix it.

Not exactly the smartest thing but it could be a motive. I might do something like that.

Or he is a jerk. I’m not sure what the op wants to hear.

I tend to act overly polite and warm when there is an awkward situation.
This could very well be plausible, however, being very friendly and playful is something he does to other women, in general. The fact it involved a former friend is what drove it over the top.

And acting overly polite and warm is quite different than gushing and complimenting.

Peace.

+JMJ+
 
You are right in that I am very sensitive, but this thread is really about the situation. Asking if it would be something that would irritate others. Yes, there are communication issues in our marriage that need to be worked out, but this situation occurred during a time of peace in our marriage.

The quote you referenced was during a very difficult and tumultuous time that we were experiencing. I suppose my posting only the problems prohibit readers to see only the problems and never the good moments.

Clearly my fault, as I am a very private person, but getting (name removed by moderator)ut from others on an anonymous forum helps to see things from different perspectives when I am unable to turn to another in my little microcosm of life.

My marriage struggles do not go without deep and constant prayer. Posting questions on a Catholic forum is how I can obtain others’ (name removed by moderator)ut without any bias. Simple as that.

Peace.

+JMJ+
Imho-you are not being oversensitive in this situation. In fact, your husband is being insensitive.

He had a choice- either make his wife uncomfortable, or the other woman uncomfortable.

The only way I would accept this is if he has some kind of social anxiety that makes him be compulsively extra nice to women. And I don’t think this exists.
 
I don’t see how the described behavior can be interpreted as anything other than flirtatiousness. If the description matches reality, I don’t see how jmj777 could be accused of being oversensitive. And the fact that this behavior has been addressed multiple times by jmj777, and that she has been told by her husband that she is overreacting, suggests that marital counseling is crucial.

If a husband repeatedly flirts with other women in front of wife, and wife has already addressed how awful that makes her feel, and he continues to do it, and then does so at a party with a former friend who mistreated his wife, and then when she objects once again, he tells her she is overreacting, well, that sounds a lot like gaslighting. That is a tactic to manipulate someone, to deflect criticism and to make the victim doubt their own perception. There is no reason to assume he is purposefully manipulating, but perhaps he is just embarrassed or he is subconsciously engaging in passive aggression.

jmj777, just because you have been abused or manipulated in the past and now have habits of allowing yourself to be manipulated, does NOT mean that your husband is not also guilty of manipulating you. I had to address similar patterns in my own marriage. It has caused some serious discussions and led to some necessary counseling, but we are doing much better now as a result. My husband had to acknowledge that he was benefitting from continuing the cycle in our marriage. And he had to stop and apologize and learn more respectful ways.

So I encourage you to read that book I recommended, and do lots of praying that Jesus will heal your soul and enlighten your mind to see these patterns. God bless!
 
**But you do have a problem with it. You expect him to suppress his nature in order to make you feel better about yourself. **

**So what would you have him do? Stand beside you silently gazing upon you adoringly? That seems by itself, fairly unrealistic. **

Good!

**Well, I’m not sure why you expect him to get into your issue with this woman at all. It’s between you two ladies, frankly, not the entire world. **

**Might have missed an opportunity to mend fences. **

**How does one laugh with discomfort? That seems fake to me. If you were THAT upset, walk away. **

**This seems kind of like high school behavior. I’d take a hard look inward, and see if his being an extrovert can be a blessing to you. Maybe he’s trying to get you to lighten up. 🤷 At any rate, your post comes off kind of harsh…I don’t think it’s about loyalty. It’s more about he fact that you really really don’t like this woman.
Fair enough. Don’t socialize with her, and move on. **
👍
 
I don’t see how the described behavior can be interpreted as anything other than flirtatiousness. If the description matches reality, I don’t see how jmj777 could be accused of being oversensitive. And the fact that this behavior has been addressed multiple times by jmj777, and that she has been told by her husband that she is overreacting, suggests that marital counseling is crucial. …
I agree with this.

And it’s very easy to avoid obvious signs of flirtatious behavior (multiple times) and label the op as ‘too sensitive’ ‘no big deal’ when it’s not you who have been in the same situation. Perhaps she can’t explain well and ends up coming out as the one with the problem. And this is supposed to be a Catholic forum…
 
I do see your side however. I know that if my wife had an “enemy”. That person would be mine as well. ;). No matter if my wife was right or wrong. I would always back my wife especially in public.
I vote loyalty to spouse, just like above. ( do you see what I mean? In their situation they choose loyalty to spouse, for your situation they say ’ no big deal’

I’m praying for you and your husband.
 
I was thinking about this–if her husband is an exhuberant complimentary person in general-with both men and women, this would then be his temperment-

If he is only exhuberantly friendly towards women, then it’s not.
 
I was thinking about this–if her husband is an exhuberant complimentary person in general-with both men and women, this would then be his temperment-

If he is only exhuberantly friendly towards women, then it’s not.
…or if he’s only exuberantly friendly to good-looking women between 18-50.
 
I think I read the whole thread rather carefully, and don’t recall seeing an answer to what the woman in question did that was a betrayal. To me, this would make the difference in whether the husband was being disloyal. Are we talking about someone who couldn’t make it to a movie one night because she had a serious headache, or someone who slept with the OP’s husband or killed her brother while drunk driving and shrugged it off?

I’m being only a little bit facetious in these exaggerations (hopefully they’re exaggerations!), in trying to say, without having some idea what constitutes ‘betrayal,’ I don’t think it can really be said by anyone here whether it’s disloyalty or no big deal. Which is part of why I think it’s unfair to chastise the OP as immature and some of the other things she’s been called (which do not seem to me as charitable as things could have been said.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top