Hypothetical Sin and Confession Scenario

Status
Not open for further replies.
God’s divinity is not bound by the Church’s humanity. Ask yourself what a good and loving God would do. That is the most logical and reasonable answer. Disregard those that would seem to think God must only act/re-act based on a Pharasaical interpretation of our laws and disciplines.
This is what I would lean towards; God’s divinity, rather than our humanity. But knowing that the Church is complex (the CCC is 800 pages) and our traditions rich and His Word infinite, it stands to reason that what I think may not align with what the Church has to say.
 
It would be interested to put the question to Fr Vincent Serpa.
(In a shorter form.)

If a sincere penitent confesses a real sin and the priest mis-hears or misunderstands and doesn’t feel absolution is needed would God still accept and grant the forgiveness originally being sought?
I think this is a great synopsis of the scenario. I can submit this or you can. Either way I’m okay, but I think asking Fr. Serpa is a great idea.
 
There is a priest in a parish near mine that gives illicit confessions. Like, not valid. AT ALL. Knowing this, if I accidentally went to him for confession, I would go again at the next available opportunity to another priest.
Does your Bishop know about this?
 
He would go to Hell because he wasn’t forgiven but retained the sin on his soul due to the priest withholding absolution. I am sure that God would get him a priest to absolve him prior to his death considering the strange circumstances though.
God is not bound by the sacraments. He can operate outside of them. God knows better than any the heart of the person, better than the person themselves. And given the situation described then the person isn’t culpable in retaining the stain of sin anyway, if any such stain remained.
His mercy is boundless, and His judgements are true.
 
This is what I would lean towards; God’s divinity, rather than our humanity. But knowing that the Church is complex (the CCC is 800 pages) and our traditions rich and His Word infinite, it stands to reason that what I think may not align with what the Church has to say.
I concur; I meant to imply that you had consulted with the Church by way of a well-formed conscience and going to the confessional with the hypothetical priest.

I see so many folks who come to these forums stressed and worried about details when it appears they’ve done all in their power our Lord would expect. He said (and says in every Mass and confession) that peace is his gift to us. I think we should graciously (albeit undeservingly) accept.
 
Does your Bishop know about this?
Technically not my bishop, it’s in the next diocese. Actually my diocese hasn’t had a bishop for a couple of years, but that is neither here nor there.

A lot of people know about this, at least the other priest of his order do. He has been complained about on numerous occasions. Maybe they have done something about it by now but they hadn’t for a long time. 🤷
 
God is not bound by the sacraments. He can operate outside of them. God knows better than any the heart of the person, better than the person themselves. And given the situation described then the person isn’t culpable in retaining the stain of sin anyway, if any such stain remained.
His mercy is boundless, and His judgements are true.
It would be an extraordinary grace of God if the person were absolved of his mortal sin without receiving absolution from the priest. God is not prone to act in such a way. Given the situation, I doubt God would take the penitent out of this world before giving him another opportunity to confess, but I don’t think God would pardon him of his mortal sin without the priest’s absolution. If a person went to Confession and later discovered that the priest did not validly absolve him of his sins for whatever reason, he would be bound to go to Confession again and to refrain from receiving Holy Communion. He wouldn’t just assume that God absolved him anyway even though God is not bound by the Sacraments.
 
Given the situation, I doubt God would take the penitent out of this world before giving him another opportunity to confess…
Why would God (hypothetically) allow the person more time?
That suggests that God (hypothetically) understands that the penitent really did make a sincere and remorseful confession seeking God’s forgiveness.
…but I don’t think God would pardon him of his mortal sin without the priest’s absolution.
God waiting for a priest to do something before exercising His Divine Mercy?
For how long does God need to wait - indefinitely?

Suppose we take the hypothetical one step further and ask what would happen if the penitent left the confessional mistakenly thinking that the priest HAD absolved him.
 
Why would God (hypothetically) allow the person more time?
That suggests that God (hypothetically) understands that the penitent really did make a sincere and remorseful confession seeking God’s forgiveness.

God waiting for a priest to do something before exercising His Divine Mercy?
For how long does God need to wait - indefinitely?

Suppose we take the hypothetical one step further and ask what would happen if the penitent left the confessional mistakenly thinking that the priest HAD absolved him.
It wouldn’t matter how sincere the confession was if the priest withheld or said an invalid absolution. Pardon in the Sacrament of Penance comes from the ego te absolvo of the priest. If there is no absolution, there is no pardon. It would be an extraordinary grace of God if He were to pardon the penitent without him having received a valid absolution from the priest. I see no reason to suggest that this hypothetical penitent was absolved by such extraordinary means as God rarely works in such a manner. I doubt He has ever given such a grace. The only way for this person to have been pardoned of his mortal sin without absolution would be if he had perfect contrition, which is difficult to muster.

That further step you took already happens in which malformed or mistaken priests don’t give valid absolutions. The confessions of the SSPX outside of the Year of Mercy comes to mind. Those people in the SSPX were not validly absolved of their mortal sins prior to the Year of Mercy. I doubt God simply pardoned them regardless.
 
It wouldn’t matter how sincere the confession was if the priest withheld or said an invalid absolution. Pardon in the Sacrament of Penance comes from the ego te absolvo of the priest. If there is no absolution, there is no pardon. It would be an extraordinary grace of God if He were to pardon the penitent without him having received a valid absolution from the priest. I see no reason to suggest that this hypothetical penitent was absolved by such extraordinary means as God rarely works in such a manner. I doubt He has ever given such a grace. The only way for this person to have been pardoned of his mortal sin without absolution would be if he had perfect contrition, which is difficult to muster.

That further step you took already happens in which malformed or mistaken priests don’t give valid absolutions. The confessions of the SSPX outside of the Year of Mercy comes to mind. Those people in the SSPX were not validly absolved of their mortal sins prior to the Year of Mercy. I doubt God simply pardoned them regardless.
So you believe that if I am on my way to make a sincere confession but get hit by a bus, God can forgive me, but he can’t if I genuinely believe that I didn’t commit a mortal sin because the priest cleared me of it and I don’t reconfess?

God INSTITUTED confession - he is not bound by it. How do you think he forgave sins before Christ died? How do you think he forgives the sins of non-Catholics?

Now I agree, if the penitent knew the priest was wrong, that would be a different story. But I think in this hypothetical scenario, his conscience was assuaged by the priest and he genuinely believed that he was in the all-clear.
 
So you believe that if I am on my way to make a sincere confession but get hit by a bus, God can forgive me, but he can’t if I genuinely believe that I didn’t commit a mortal sin because the priest cleared me of it and I don’t reconfess?

God INSTITUTED confession - he is not bound by it. How do you think he forgave sins before Christ died? How do you think he forgives the sins of non-Catholics?

Now I agree, if the penitent knew the priest was wrong, that would be a different story. But I think in this hypothetical scenario, his conscience was assuaged by the priest and he genuinely believed that he was in the all-clear.
You will only go to Heaven after perishing on the way to Confession if you had perfect contrition. I am not saying that He can’t forgive, I am saying that He won’t. I know quite well that He isn’t bound by the Sacraments, but that doesn’t mean that He’ll just pardon people regardless of whether they receive a valid absolution or not. The Church says either Penance or perfect contrition will pardon you of mortal sin, she gives no other way. The pardon in Penance comes from the absolution, not the confession of the sins. While God can pardon in whatever way He wishes, there is no substantial reason to suggest that He does, especially in this hypothetical situation.

He forgives the mortal sins of non-Catholics only if they have perfect contrition since the normal means of receiving pardon, the Sacrament of Penance, is not practiced by them. We aren’t living in the time of the Old Covenant, so it doesn’t matter how people were forgiven back then. Many people think they are “in the all-clear” but receive a sentence of damnation at their death from the divine Judge.
 
So you believe that if I am on my way to make a sincere confession but get hit by a bus, God can forgive me, but he can’t if I genuinely believe that I didn’t commit a mortal sin because the priest cleared me of it and I don’t reconfess?

God INSTITUTED confession - he is not bound by it. How do you think he forgave sins before Christ died? How do you think he forgives the sins of non-Catholics?

Now I agree, if the penitent knew the priest was wrong, that would be a different story. But I think in this hypothetical scenario, his conscience was assuaged by the priest and he genuinely believed that he was in the all-clear./QUOTE]

Yes, the added bolding is precisely the scenario’s confines I’ve created here for the sake of discussion. I would like to think that because of the example you gave, which I have heard before to strengthen and support that it is not we humans who have the power, but God, and that His providence forgives sins. He would not doom us to Hell if we committed mortal sin and were truly sorry but died on the way to confess that sin. This is not a God I would want to worship as it would be a God of strict rule-following to me. That is what causes scrupulosity, something I’ve struggled with in the past, but as I grow in faith it lessens its hold on me, and for the grace of God I am duly bound to praise Him for that!

But again, I posed the questionable scenario because I know what I don’t know and therefore know that there are “things” within the Church that cause me pause when I learn them; saying to myself, “I would not have thought it to be so, but rightly, the Church doctrine says it so, and therefore I am bound to believe it.”

This discussion has certainly been interesting and as Lion IRC put it, I would like to pose it here to Ask An Apologist or even call Catholic Answers Live with it (although I’ve never called a radio show…)
 
To clarify on my “hit by a bus” post, I did mean to imply perfect contrition, sorry if that didn’t come across.

My point is basically what Fr said in the link above. God is merciful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top