So you believe that if I am on my way to make a sincere confession but get hit by a bus, God can forgive me, but he can’t if I genuinely believe that I didn’t commit a mortal sin because the priest cleared me of it and I don’t reconfess?
God INSTITUTED confession - he is not bound by it. How do you think he forgave sins before Christ died? How do you think he forgives the sins of non-Catholics?
Now I agree, if the penitent knew the priest was wrong, that would be a different story. But I think in this hypothetical scenario, his conscience was assuaged by the priest and he genuinely believed that he was in the all-clear./QUOTE]
Yes, the added bolding is precisely the scenario’s confines I’ve created here for the sake of discussion. I would like to think that because of the example you gave, which I have heard before to strengthen and support that it is not we humans who have the power, but God, and that His providence forgives sins. He would not doom us to Hell if we committed mortal sin and were truly sorry but died on the way to confess that sin. This is not a God I would want to worship as it would be a God of strict rule-following to me. That is what causes scrupulosity, something I’ve struggled with in the past, but as I grow in faith it lessens its hold on me, and for the grace of God I am duly bound to praise Him for that!
But again, I posed the questionable scenario because I know what I don’t know and therefore know that there are “things” within the Church that cause me pause when I learn them; saying to myself, “I would not have thought it to be so, but rightly, the Church doctrine says it so, and therefore I am bound to believe it.”
This discussion has certainly been interesting and as Lion IRC put it, I would like to pose it here to Ask An Apologist or even call Catholic Answers Live with it (although I’ve never called a radio show…)