I am not happy in my relationship, but I'm afraid to break up with him anytime soon

  • Thread starter Thread starter JCats12
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JCats12

Guest
I’ve been in a relationship with my boyfriend for almost 3 months and I realize that I have made a mistake in ever choosing to date him. I’ll give you the events of leading up to this.
I went through a horrible breakup back in the beginning of October. It was my very first heartbreak and it had affected me in a lot. As the month went on, I began to get better, however, I wasn’t fully healed. I thought that in early November I was healed and ready to move on, so I began to meet other guys. Around this time, I began to question aspects of Catholic dating. I began to wonder “why we as women had to have such high standards for guys and why couldn’t we just date whoever we wanted. There is no such thing as a soulmate and why did we have to wait to date until we were ready for marriage?”
I met a guy in the middle of December. He was raised Jewish but doesn’t practice anymore. We were getting to know each other and I realized that I liked him a lot, despite our differences in faith. I honestly believed that we could work it out. We made things official on the 1st of February. I genuinely was happy.
The fact that we didn’t share the same faith really bothered me every since the beginning, however I didn’t pay attention to it. I notice that he has a tendency to be selfish and does not understand sacrificial love- something we as Catholics believe in. He doesn’t respect me the way that a guy should. Another aspect is that we have gotten physical in our relationship. We haven’t had intercourse but we have made out and done other things. I know this is wrong and I told him I wanted to pull back on this stuff, but didn’t agree with me, so I gave in yet again. Our relationship does not have a foundation; I feel as if it is very superficial. He is sometimes critical to me and I don’t feel as if he cherishes me. I honestly don’t see myself marrying him. In fact, I’ve been longing to be single again.
However, I know when I see him again next week, I’m going to forget all of our problems. Everytime I’m with him, infatuation comes in and think he’s a good guy after all. Which is why I find it difficult to break up with him. He is a good person overall, and is considerate. He sends me sweet things which make me feel good. He honestly makes me want to work harder on my academics because of how smart he is. I like his companionship and I know that he’ll be there for me. However, am I in this for the sake of being in a relationship?
However, as I recently reflected on a lot of things, all those Catholic speakers had it right about Catholic relationships. That is the type of relationship that my heart desires. I know that as a daughter of God, I deserve better, and I deserve to be treated as such. The thing is, I don’t take breakups well. I know I will need some time away from campus in order to collect myself and heal from this. If I do decide to end things, it will have to be in May, so that I’ll be able to leave campus for a couple of months for the summer and start fresh in late August.
I’ve been so restless on this. I know plenty of people will think that I am so naive, but this is difficult. I don’t know what exactly to do now.
 
The thing is, I don’t take breakups well. I know I will need some time away from campus in order to collect myself and heal from this.
You’ve been dating this dude for a month. If you think you are that serious that you have to be away from campus and “heal” then you need some counseling before you get in any more relationships. seriously, it’s bene one month of dating this guy.

Break up with him. Note your lessons learned. Move on.

You don’t need a guy in your life. You have friends, interests, and plenty to keep you busy, Invest in your friends and in your hobbies and studies.
If I do decide to end things, it will have to be in May, so that I’ll be able to leave campus for a couple of months for the summer and start fresh in late August.
This is you, making excuses. Tell him you don’t want to date him anymore and don’t give it another thought. This is only as big of a deal as you make it. Right now you are feeding on your own drama. Stop it!

You are better than that.
 
At a month I wouldn’t even feel bad breaking up by text or simply ghosting. All you need to do is send a text, “I think we should c other ppl” and move on.
 
It’s not fair to the man to string him along. You and he have been dating, he’s nice, you like him, but you don’t think the relationship is viable longterm. Also, the longer you date him, the likelier you are to have sex with him. Dating is a bonding process–not as much as marriage–and the longer you date, the more bond-severing you’ll have to do.
 
Break up with him now. He doesn’t respect you, and you don’t want to date him. Do it over the phone if seeing him will make you forget it all. But do it.
 
However, I know when I see him again next week, I’m going to forget all of our problems.
Then maybe you shouldn’t see him again. I know that’s easier said than done. But you recognize the problems, you recognize that marriage is not where this is going. You mention that he doesn’t share your values – I don’t think fooling him into thinking everything is OK is among your values.
 
I know when I see him again next week, I’m going to forget all of our problems
This is because when you have done the “other stuff” sexual messing around, your body releases Oxytocin. Oxytocin | Psychology Today Canada

This is the hormonal bonding that God created to bond families together.

It will take you months to get this chemical bond out of your system.
 
You are quite early into this and still have a way out before your heart is even more vested. If you see potential flaws where you are not getting the respect you deserve, it’s time to leave.

There’s a flip side to this as well from his point of view as eventually he may not notice you are devoting your feelings and happiness to him completely. If it’s not serious and has no intention of getting serious, please save yourself from heartbreak.

Good luck and God bless.
 
You aready know what you need to do. If you have doubts about the relationship after just a short time, do you think it’s going to get any better? Most people are on their best behavior in the early stages of a relationship so if there are doubts now, what’s it going to be like later?
 
Good advice on this thread, and you notice that everyone is on the same page.
Yes, you are naive, and you are headed for more heartbreak. The longer you postpone breaking up, the harder it will be. If you want it to be as painless as possible, you must be brave. End the relationship on the phone if you don’t trust yourself in person.
YOU ARE SINGLE. You are not committed to anyone. “Making it official” – what is that, going steady? Adults get engaged prior to marriage. Please stop playing with fire and people’s hearts, primarily yours.
God bless. You can do the right thing.
 
All I can do is agree with the advice already posted. You have decided you and he aren’t right for each other. The sooner you break up with him, the better it will be.

If you’re afraid you’ll get into another, less than ideal relationship too soon, don’t try and meet anyone, where the purpose is finding someone to date/marry. You have to have time to discern just what you want in a relationship, and look where such men can be found. The idea of taking a few months off all dating is good. If you can, get some counseling. No relationship is perfect, but try and lay down a few rules. For example, this man got you to a level of intimacy you weren’t comfortable with. So, make that a rule…if a man you date repeatedly pushes for more intimacy than you’re comfortable with, then break up with him. Never let anyone put you in a situation that makes you feel ashamed. It may also help to make a few new friends, so you don’t become socially awkward or uncomfortable. Then, when you’re ready to date again, you’ll know your own comfort level, and be able to protect it.
 
No, you shouldn’t wait until May to break it off with him. Do you not see how ridiculous that sounds? You are going to stay in a relationship that you have already concluded is not right for you, for a variety of reasons.
It sounds like you are fearful of him, or of having to deal with him, or to actually confront him.

If that is the case, just send him a text. It’s only been a month. “This relationship is not working for me, and I am not interested in continuing it. I wish you all the best.” That’s all. He knows your concerns, and you owe him no further explanation.
 
Im sorry you feel upset, I know ending relationships is hard. But there’s no point in stringing him along and he isn’t right for you. I agree with all the posters here. Take a break from dating. Go to confession, focus on your faith, studies, friends, family, etc but not boys right now. In future relationships, look for and date a faithful Catholic to match your values. In the beginning, take it slow, keep things casual. In the first month of dating things shouldn’t be serious, you barely know the guy after 1 month. It should just be going out on dates every now and then in the first few months as you are getting to know each other.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top