I can't stand religion

  • Thread starter Thread starter LostSoul87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was in a similar place as you 40 some years ago, and I wanted TRUTH. I craved it.
  1. Do you? That’s the first question that you, or anyone, needs to answer for themself. If you do, then the next step is to ask the question -
  2. Who knows the TRUTH? Who do I go to to find out the truth? Who determines/decides what is TRUTH? When you recognize that if there is such a thing as TRUTH, that it is God alone who knows and determines it, then you know where to go, so
  3. Plead with God to give you the TRUTH.
He’ll answer.

Nita
That I also have found to be true Nita, God will answer you and teach you if we just simply ask him. No one on earth, is greater than their creator who created them.

God Bless
 
I don’t understand how someone cannot doubt something that isn’t fully understood. It’s so contradictory…
Well, the analogy I gave was with respect to science, and how it too is not fully understood (i.e., natural science, just like theology, still includes much mystery). Yet, I can assent to much of what science teaches even if I don’t fully understand it. As an engineer, I’ve spent a lot of time studying science, and yet I still don’t understand it all. Do I have to fully understand everything about nature to be able to assent to certain scientific facts and theories? That’s impractical, in my view. In my career I’ve helped to launch 6 spacecraft into orbit. I wouldn’t have been able to do that if I remained indecisive about things I didn’t fully see or understand. I submit that the same goes for the decisions of our everyday lives, both small and large. We take risks or we don’t progress.

Let me offer another analogy. I’m color blind. Well, color “deficient” is the more precise term really, as I can see many colors, but have difficulty distinguishing between some shades of certain colors due to a hereditary lack of cones in my eyes. As a young child, I realized something about faith because of my color blindness. My mom painted the room blue. To my eyes, it was pink. What I saw (and initially understood) differed from the testimony of everyone around me. Should I trust my own senses, or should I trust the testimony of others who claim something to be true which I cannot see? Reason and the trustworthy testimony of others comes into play in our beliefs, doesn’t it? Would it be reasonable to affirm that everyone–especially those I love the most–would lie to me about their own eyewitness testimony? I had to take a risk, a “leap of faith” in order to deny that which I saw with my own eyes, and assent to the testimony of others. It would be unreasonable of me to assume everyone was involved in some great conspiracy against me to dupe me into believing “pink” was really “blue.” Was it reasonable to cling to the belief that those who I trusted the most would lie to me about this? They are the one’s I knew loved me and had no reason to lie to me, so holding to the “primacy of my own senses” seemed rather unreasonable to me, even as a young child. So, I placed faith in the trustworthiness of the testimony of others, because that was the reasonable thing to do. It wasn’t “blind faith” but instead, “reasoned faith.”

But faith does include risk, which is unavoidable in human growth. We take risks all the time. For example, when I first fell in love, I trusted that the one I fell in love with also loved me. I wasn’t sure. How do you know? You can’t “see” love, can you? You can only see its effects, and sometimes only dimly. Sometimes, like my color deficient eyesight, our ability to see the more important things in life are somewhat obscured by our fallen nature. My first love, for example, later decided that she didn’t love me back, at least not in the way I loved her. Such “leaps of faith” can result in sorrow sometimes. Why? Because we put trust in something we cannot see, and sometimes we are wrong. Yet, I don’t know anyone that had their heart broken who years later wouldn’t say, “It was worth the risk.” Because the reward of finding real “love” is too great to not take the risk, even if that risk includes placing much faith in something you cannot see perfectly.

Although my eyes are not perfect, I can be confident enough in that which I do see, can reason towards, and do hear from others I trust to make reasonable choices for the good of my soul.
 
Yes, but faith is supernatural - it is a gift from God. You cannot summon it up within yourself. We need God’s grace to achieve almost anything and most important of all, you need to accept it. Do you think that the saints like Padre Pio or others maintained their strong faith through some intellectual exercises? No, but they gave their whole self to God and found their strength and courage in Him.

Now, doubt isn’t something that Christians don’t experience. On the contrary. It is absolutely normal to have doubts. The question is what you do with them. You can turn back after the first obstacle or you can continue in your pursuit of the truth. Are you familiar with the great doubts people like St. Thérèse of Lisieux or more recently Bl. Mother Theresa were experiencing. Some media even suggested that Mother Theresa was living as an atheist. But this allegation is ridiculous and only demonstrates how the popular media doesn’t not understand faith nor God.

Here I’m specifically referring to a phase in faith sometimes called ‘dark night of the soul’ (read St. John of The Cross, he write a lot about it). This is what happens when your faith seizes to be to some extend dependent on material things. In the beginning God gives you his hand to the extend that you can almost feel it. The time will come however when we grow up. Then the only thing that would be left would be our soul’s relationship with God. In a sense the people like that suffer and most Christians know this because they experience this from time to time. If you know what I’m talking about you probably do not understand how can these people maintain their faith. Nor do I. But I guess the point is that they can’t - only God can.

So my point is, don’t seek faith in chemical reactions that happen in your brain nor in writings of famous intellectuals but seek it in God. Ask and you shall receive. Of course the other things I mentioned are very good and helpful but they will not give you what you seek. You can read the Bible, the works of the Church Father and all the saints and find no faith. You can turn to God and you can find treasures beyond imagination.

May I ask something? Is it because they have what you don’t (at the moment)?
Finally, God’s sweet blessing to you! Your message is beautiful and inspiring to all and my belief exactly! The dark night of the soul! Yes, many saints speak of that and it is real. Our Dear Mother Theresa, was judged by the media. I prayed for them for such evilness spoken against her. God does have treasures beyond imagination we need but simply ask!

God Bless…a very little child of God
 
Good question, but it’s not something I can answer immediately. I have mixed feeling on this subject.

Part of me believes he has no direct influence anymore. Indirectly through people’s beliefs and motivation (faith) would God be influencing us.

The other part of me, I put myself in his position. If I created all of this, there is no way I could abandon it. But as far as influencing, I can’t see it being much different than the above if we truly have free will.
Well, you must decide what it is you believe. Feelings must not have anything to do with it. How one feels about an objective reality is irrelevant. One does not say that one does not happen to like that two and two are four because this sum does not fit in with one’s personal aesthetic preference. One does not decide that gravity does not exist based on one’s own strong desire to fly. Theology can be no different.

You say that part of you believes one such thing and part of you believes this other, contradictory thing. You’ll forgive me the observation that it does not appear as if there is very much thinking rather than feeling behind this quandary.

You have, in a previous post, stated that you have arrived at your beliefs through a process of logical reasoning. So, let’s have it! Produce for me the chain of deduction that has led you to the conclusion you now embrace. I have explained my reasoning for the way in which I believe, what is yours?
 
… believing in a creator is as far I will go right now.
That’s a good start. Let me share with you why I moved beyond Deism toward belief in a personal God who involves himself directly in the lives of His creation.

Deists affirm belief in the existence of God, but do not believe that He enters into a direct personal relationship with us, including a denial of supernatural revelation from God.

When I was “Deist” in my thinking, I discovered that I had this notion of truth as being subjective. I would often think, “That’s true for you, but not true for me.” However, as I got older I came to realize that a mistake can be discovered and amended if and only if objective truth exists and can be known and is loved and searched for. If objective truth does not exist, there are no mistakes. I think most of us can sense that there must be an objective truth, because the contrary makes nonsense of our every day existence, which is often marked by mistakes.

Protestant author C.S. Lewis wrote:
“if Truth is objective, if we live in a world we did not create and cannot change merely by thinking, if the world is not really a dream of our own, then the most destructive belief we could possibly believe would be the denial of this primary fact.” (C.S. Lewis, “The poison of Subjectivism” in Christian Reflections)
I came to realize that I could not simply redefine the word “truth” into something I wanted it to be. I had to get back to the basics and begin to doubt even the very foundations of my doubt. How, for example, did the dictionary define “truth?”

Truth is “that which corresponds to reality.” This is the dictionary definition for the word “truth.” So it seems that if I wanted to avoid “linguistic confusion,” then by definition, truth is objective. If we share the same reality (“totality of real things, events, and facts”) then “truth for me” must be the same as "truth for you.” Hitler, Stalin, etc. had beliefs that were clearly untrue, mistaken. We could not even say this if truth were not objective, because we could believe any nonsensical postulate having nothing to do with reality, so long we decided it was “true for me.”

Beliefs, on the other hand, are subjective—meaning they vary from person to person. As I stated earlier, people come to believe something to be true based upon three things: 1) experience, 2) reason, and 3) the testimony of others. Since all three of these things often vary from person to person, it is no wonder that beliefs often vary from person to person.

We should maintain the linguistic distinction between the words “truth” and “belief.” The latter is subjective, the former is not.

Since objective truth exists, I realized that I should not merely “just pick” a belief, but should conform my beliefs to that which is objectively true. I needed to search for the truth.

continued…
 
continued…

*** So, why not Deism?*** Is Deism true? Does God have a personal relationship with His creation, and if so, how? As I continued to study engineering, and especially after I became a father, I came to distrust the claims of deism.

Engineers design and build things like spacecraft and robots. They don’t do so without a purpose. As an engineer, I cannot imagine creating something as amazing as the universe, simply to ignore it and to never directly interact with it again.

Moreover, if I were an all-powerful God and could relate with my creation in a direct, personal way, wouldn’t I do so? I’m a father who has had a small part in creation. I don’t find it convincing that the Creator would not want a relationship, a direct interaction with his creation. I am compelled to intervene directly in my children’s lives, and I was only an instrument in their creation. After much prayerful contemplation about Deism, I was compelled to dismiss it as very unlikely, because I believe based upon reason, experience, and the overwhelming testimony of human history that God is a God of “personal relationships.” I could not believe in a God that didn’t want to relate personally with his offspring.

God did not simply poof nature together from nothing and then ignore it. That’s not a compelling view of the Creator in my personal experience. Nor does it accord with the constant testimony of humanity throughout every century of human history. Human history testifies that the Creator has in the past and does indeed continue to interact supernaturally with his creation. If you study theology, there’s a pattern of belief common to every human community that has ever existed: every known human community has always believed in God and believed that God maintains a personal relationship with and directly interacts and intervenes in the affairs of man. It’s difficult for me to discount this constant testimony when drawing my conclusions about God.

Consequently, based upon reason, experience and the testimony of humanity, I believe that God can and does “speak” to man. His revelation must then include: 1) Natural revelation (indirect interaction) – God speaks through the things he has created, and 2) Supernatural revelation (direct interaction) – God can and has spoken directly, supernaturally on more than one occasion. He continues to intervene in lives of human beings in a personal and supernatural way so that we may live in accordance with His will.

After setting aside Deism, the next step in this journey of faith must now seek the answer to the question: ***of all the different claims to how God has directly revealed himself to man, and entered into a personal relationship with man, which way corresponds to reality, the preponderance of real evidence? ***I think if you follow the trail of evidence, it leads to the Truth.
 
I agree with you, I don’t like “Religion” either. People have used religion to gain power, fortune and fame. Jesus message was simple, “Love”. It was his love for us that he came here and died on the cross for you and I. It should be our Love for Him because of what he did for us on that cross that guides our lives. It isn’t the name on the church building thats going to get you to Heaven, only giving your life to the one who died for you is going to do that, for it is Christ’s church, not any one particular denomination.
 
I’ve asked myself on so many different occasions, “Why is it that I believe in God?” I think for me, personally, while I am totally able to admit a lot of it comes from my culture and surroundings, there’s something deeper than that. I live in the Bible Belt and am a contrarian by nature. Being controversial is a strange passion of mine… But as much as I’d like to scare a Bible-toter by declaring that the empirical laws of the universe demonstratively disprove their so-called “God,” I would first have to bring myself to believe that before proclaiming it to them.

The first time I began reading the Catechism, I was taken aback by the whole chapter concerning man’s search for God. He, it said, testifies that he contains neither his first principle nor final end. He is looking, however–searching for something beyond him, bigger than him, greater and more magnificent. Someone once asked me why I thought this was: that is, why it is that we all search. I thought and thought, and I finally answered quietly, having come to an amazing realization:

“Because… because maybe God wants us to search for him.”

My realization was a grand one in that I, for the first time, began to discover that God wanted to be found. For this reason, I had to reject all religions that touted an impersonal god or force… I knew better. I know that love is the thing most valued by man, and that, in the world of Idealism, all society is built upon this incomparable virtue.

I knew then that not only did God want to be found, but he was a God of love. He was in love with me…

Scary, right? Imagine just finding out that someone’s been hiding in your bushes for the last eight years who you never even knew existed–but was madly in love with you. Drunk with love, really. That’s how shocked I was. But I wasn’t disturbed, but more so incredulous, because at the time I had a tough time loving myself. How, then, could a thing as great as God love me?

I still don’t know… I don’t think that there’s a reason really. No reason other than he is who he is: and God* is* Love, after all. A God that loves unconditionally, that loves by his very nature, that, I thought, is the God that deserves worship…

The realization that God loved me made me think a lot about what other religions said about their God, about what he was like. Judaism said Yahweh was “compassionate and merciful, slow to anger and full of unfailing love and faithfulness,” Islam said God was “Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful,” and Christianity said, bolder still, “God is Love.” I realized that though Islam worshipped the one Creator and Sustainer of the Universe, the Muslims thought God to be too dignified, too exalted, to lower himself in order to pick man up from the mud and mire in which he found himself.

(CONT.)
 
On the other hand, this is exactly what the God of Judaism did. He stooped low to pick us up when we had fallen, and when we were in over our heads, he rescued. But the way I saw it, Judaism was constantly sidestepping the issue of man’s corruption, constantly asserting that he is ibasically good but environmental factors make him act in evil ways… But where did evil come from? And how could one deny its root in our hearts and souls, in the depths of our beings? The Christian notion of Original Sin just made so many things make sense. It explained why man wants to do good (because, after all, he is still made in the image of God) but does not most of the time (he has been corrupted). So there is both good and evil in man, and thus the inner struggle.

The God of the Christians reminded me a lot of the God of the Jews, because just as it was in the Old Testament, he never hesitated to get dirty in order to rescue his creation from its own depravity. I knew that these weren’t two separate gods, but one: The God that wasn’t too puffed up to lower himself to the position of a slave in order to die a shameful and agonizing death in order to save and redeem his children.

This made me, I think, a Christian by virtue of belief. By virtue of an earlier baptism, though, I now realize I had long before been one, even if indifferent and lacking the oh so essential faith. I spent some time in my parent’s Baptist church, which was awesome. Everyone was nice; the people were real. The kids wanted to worship God. It blew my mind. For a while I was content, till I began to discern my calling and ask various questions about doctrine in general, and what we, as fundamentalist Protestants, believed and why.

“Why is it the Church Fathers, as early as (insert super-early date here) said this, but we practice this?” and “What about this? This totally seems to contradict Scripture!”

I think that the road to Christ and the road toward his Bride the Church are the same road, and one I was quite a ways down already. For me, personally, after much frustration, confusion, anxiety and fear–and maybe one rosary offered on behalf of all this–I found myself hoping to enter into the Catholic Church, the Church which for centuries had proclaimed the Gospel with such fervor and faith. Christ’s Bride. I wanted my Mother to nourish me with the sacraments. I wanted to, in letting her do so, be touched by Christ.

I realize now that not everyone walks this road. Some never question things or really search for answers. Some never search for God. Others do, but what he looks like still remains such an ambiguous thing to them. Still others search with all their heart and soul and end up a Buddhist, or a Muslim, or a Jew. I have to believe the “he who seeks, finds,” and that means in these cases, in one way or another, God has indeed been found. I for my part remain convinced that God looks like Love, like a man bleeding upon a Cross because he loved so intensely that he was ready to suffer–was willing to do anything it took to win back even a single soul.

A lot of people don’t see eye-to-eye on this, and that’s okay. As long as God looks like Love, I have to believe we are all worshipping the same one. And no, I don’t think this is a cop-out, because as firmly convinced as I am that the fullness of truth is found alone in the Catholic Church, I could never deny how many people I’ve been blessed to know that have found God and know him and are of a very different “religious persuasion.” I ask them, “What does God look like?” and when they tell me, I smile, and say, “Yeah… that sounds right…”

People like to hound one another about things like this, but it’s sad, because then we make God more about religious affiliation than about heart. We will be judged according to our hearts, according to the truths we embraced, and the lies we believed, as well. We are judged according to a lot of things, but essentially, most of all, by our hearts, and where they stand with God. Just because Job looked nothing like and Israelite–and wasn’t one, in fact–doesn’t make him any less “blameless.” Just because someone may not look like a Christian doesn’t make them any less closer to God.

I decided that in order to show people the God I served, and how amazing he was, I would have to become like him. I would have to learn to do what he did best: love. And though I’m a naturally selfish person (very much so), it doesn’t always seem so hard when I consider that it’s less about me doing anything at all than it is about letting him do everything. So I guess that may sound simplified, but that’s an abbreviated history I how I found myself where I am: in Christ’s embrace.

Pax!
 
The God of the Christians reminded me a lot of the God of the Jews, because just as it was in the Old Testament, he never hesitated to get dirty in order to rescue his creation from its own depravity. I knew that these weren’t two separate gods, but one: The God that wasn’t too puffed up to lower himself to the position of a slave in order to die a shameful and agonizing death in order to save and redeem his children.

This made me, I think, a Christian by virtue of belief. By virtue of an earlier baptism, though, I now realize I had long before been one, even if indifferent and lacking the oh so essential faith. I spent some time in my parent’s Baptist church, which was awesome. Everyone was nice; the people were real. The kids wanted to worship God. It blew my mind. For a while I was content, till I began to discern my calling and ask various questions about doctrine in general, and what we, as fundamentalist Protestants, believed and why.

“Why is it the Church Fathers, as early as (insert super-early date here) said this, but we practice this?” and “What about this? This totally seems to contradict Scripture!”

I think that the road to Christ and the road toward his Bride the Church are the same road, and one I was quite a ways down already. For me, personally, after much frustration, confusion, anxiety and fear–and maybe one rosary offered on behalf of all this–I found myself hoping to enter into the Catholic Church, the Church which for centuries had proclaimed the Gospel with such fervor and faith. Christ’s Bride. I wanted my Mother to nourish me with the sacraments. I wanted to, in letting her do so, be touched by Christ.

I realize now that not everyone walks this road. Some never question things or really search for answers. Some never search for God. Others do, but what he looks like still remains such an ambiguous thing to them. Still others search with all their heart and soul and end up a Buddhist, or a Muslim, or a Jew. I have to believe the “he who seeks, finds,” and that means in these cases, in one way or another, God has indeed been found. I for my part remain convinced that God looks like Love, like a man bleeding upon a Cross because he loved so intensely that he was ready to suffer–was willing to do anything it took to win back even a single soul.

A lot of people don’t see eye-to-eye on this, and that’s okay. As long as God looks like Love, I have to believe we are all worshipping the same one. And no, I don’t think this is a cop-out, because as firmly convinced as I am that the fullness of truth is found alone in the Catholic Church, I could never deny how many people I’ve been blessed to know that have found God and know him and are of a very different “religious persuasion.” I ask them, “What does God look like?” and when they tell me, I smile, and say, “Yeah… that sounds right…”

People like to hound one another about things like this, but it’s sad, because then we make God more about religious affiliation than about heart. We will be judged according to our hearts, according to the truths we embraced, and the lies we believed, as well. We are judged according to a lot of things, but essentially, most of all, by our hearts, and where they stand with God. Just because Job looked nothing like and Israelite–and wasn’t one, in fact–doesn’t make him any less “blameless.” Just because someone may not look like a Christian doesn’t make them any less closer to God.

I decided that in order to show people the God I served, and how amazing he was, I would have to become like him. I would have to learn to do what he did best: love. And though I’m a naturally selfish person (very much so), it doesn’t always seem so hard when I consider that it’s less about me doing anything at all than it is about letting him do everything. So I guess that may sound simplified, but that’s an abbreviated history I how I found myself where I am: in Christ’s embrace.

Pax!
Thank you for your inspiring, beautiful testimony, your personal experience in seeking God and finding him! The image of God can be seen in you “LOVE”, humbleness. I just can not tell you in words how much your message as touched me.

God’s Blessing, his grace be with you always. …a little child of God
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top