Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael T.
*… remember that in confession we must not only say the specific type of sin (species) but also the number of times we fell into that sin … *
What happens if you are honestly unsure of the number of times that you committed a certain offense? Would saying “a few times” or “numerous times” be acceptable as long as it accurately described the number of times?
I think the whole idea behind the number thing is to help the confessor get an idea if the sin has risen to the level of habit or addiction. I would say there are three levels, the first being the easiest to resist and good reason to try stopping there if one has knowledge.
Level 1: Occassional (few times yearly or in a lifetime)
Level 2: Habit (few times monthly)
Level 3: Addiction (nearly daily)
Each of these areas needs to be addressed differently. Once one has persisted in something long enough for addiction to take place, it will take more help. For example, for one who masturbates a few times a year, it is one thing and not likely to prompt a confessor to suggest a specific confession routine or other advice. However, if one is in Level 3, the confessor may suggest that the penitent make a committment to coming to confession weekly until it is under control, or may recommend therapy or hooking the person up with one of many organizations dedicated to helping people to stop this and other impure practices.
The burden however, is on the penitent, imho, to inform the confessor if it has risen to level 2 or 3 and request help and suggestions for stopping. They have much experience in helping people and it would be ashamed to not ask for that help. If a confessor is rude right out of the shoot with someone who asks for help, then it is time to look for another confessor.
Also, one has to evaluate with deep sincerity, the origin of their arousal. Is it brought on by viewing porn? If so, we know what must go first before the resultant action must go. If it is brought on by certain TV shows or the internet, then measures must be taken to avoid them until the condition heads safely back down the scale to an occassion or is gone entirely. I don’t believe that such temptations will leave and there is much comfort in knowing that many of the saints battled temptations of impurity.
We also have to understand that priests, nuns and other religious are human and they too will struggle with these things. The priest hearing a confession may be fighting that fight and may have conquered it himself so he would have valuable information. To think that those who serve God have no such feelings or temptations would be a sorry state of ignorance.
Believe it or not, I sometimes think that God allows us to fall so we an experience our weakness and understand his mercy. We are also in a better position to help others once we have conquered our internal enemies.