I really messed up at Mass Saturday

  • Thread starter Thread starter jpowers
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jpowers

Guest
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
 
If you’re not a Priest I don’t think she was asking for a blessing. I mean, yeah you can pray for a person but I doubt your blessing is the same as the ‘official’ one given by a Priest acting in personae Christi.

So, you probably did the right thing.
 
She may have been baptized in an Eastern Rite church and thus has been receiving the Eucharist since she was an infant. Or she looked young for her age but really was of age, or she really was too young and decided to try her luck. Either way, you did your part. You didn’t mess up. Your job isn’t “bouncer”. 😉
 
If a child has made his or her First Communion, he or she may most certainly approach to receive the Precious Blood from the chalice if it is being offered to everybody else.

My daughter chose to receive the Precious Blood. We “test drove” it at home with a light zinfidel first, checking for “yucky” faces, backwash, and balance of a cup from one person to another.

As for age, you don’t have to worry about carding them.😉 it’s only if you get “floaties” or backwash that it becomes a problem.
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
You did fine. You don’t have to second guess yourself or the communicants.

One thing has me puzzled though. You’re an extraordinary minister, but your profile says you are protestant!
 
One thing has me puzzled though. You’re an extraordinary minister, but your profile says you are protestant!
He(She?) joined in 2004 - its possible that s/he’s since converted to Catholicism and hasn’t changed his profile.

Aanyway, back to the topic…😃

Seems fine to me. If she didn’t do anything obviously wrong when she took the Blood that anyone who had received Communion previously should have known, its safe to say she was legit. If it turns out she hadn’t taken Communion before, then it isn’t on your soul, because you had no way of knowing for sure, and she approached you. Not your problem.
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
You didn’t mess up. Anyone who approaches in public is to be given the Eucharist, that is the rule. If she were not supposed to receive she should not have been allowed to APPROACH by whatever adult was responsible for her.
 
As for age, you don’t have to worry about carding them.😉 it’s only if you get “floaties” or backwash that it becomes a problem.

This brings up good question, if the EM knows there are “floaties” when there shouldn’t be, are they still supposed to continue offering the Precious Blood?
 
Somewhat off-topic, but I’ve heard from several sources, that EMHC’s are not to bless anyone, as it pretty much does nothing.
 
Somewhat off-topic, but I’ve heard from several sources, that EMHC’s are not to bless anyone, as it pretty much does nothing.
I would assume this, although it’s routinely done in one of the churches we attend often. I find it humorous and sad at the same time, and brings to mind how I feel the overuse of extraordinary ministers serves to blur the line between the priest and the layman. I’m quite sure you don’t need an extraordinary minister (does anyone really use that term in real life?) for *every *Mass, regardless of attendance.
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
Don’t worry. We all mess up at one time or another. God is big enough to straighten out our honest mistakes. 👍
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
What do you think you did wrong? :confused:
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
I doubt you messed up my friend. Most children are very good at crossing their arms to let you know. I doubt she would have come to the cup if she couldn’t. I am an EM as well and I know when you first start doing it, it can be overwhelming. I made a few mistakes as well.

Take heart, you will get used to it and learn. If you have any questions or things like that come up, talk to the trainer/coordinator or the priest. I asked the priest not long ago if I was holding the cup right and the cloth, It was really awkward for me at first.

Don’t give up, it’s such a wonderful way to serve. 🙂
 
…One thing has me puzzled though. You’re an extraordinary minister, but your profile says you are protestant!
If you read through her brief history of posts, she came into the Church at Easter 2005, so all is good! (except she should update her profile! 🙂 )

'thann
 
Somewhat off-topic, but I’ve heard from several sources, that EMHC’s are not to bless anyone, as it pretty much does nothing.
This is true. However, the whole “arms across your chest” thing (makes you look like a dead body, if you ask me! 🤷 ) has caused confusion and akwardness. The priest or deacon can give a blessing, but a layman cannot. So, when I act as EMHC, my reaction depends on where I am stationed: Generally, if I am distributing the Precious Blood, few come to me for a blessing. They usually receive that in the line for the Host. However, when I am distributing the Body of Christ, if I am stationed next to the priest and someone comes in my line in that ridiculous “blessing posture”, I tap the priest on the shoulder and he gives the blessing. If I am away from the priest, I put my hand on the persons shoulder and say “God Bless You”. It’s my personal wish for that person. I am not distributing it for the Church. I do not adopt a special posture for it, and it seems to satisfy.

It’s quite funny how things steamroll…this all started when priests would bless young children who were too young to receive who would come forward with their parents…

See what happens when we innovate?
 
I too doubt that you messed up. There is usually a parent close behind any child who will signal you if you are in trouble.
 
I was an extrodinary minister at the Saturday vigil and I had a little girl approach and I couldn’t tell if she wanted a blessing or to take the cup. So, I offered her the cup and she took it and did fine. But now I am wondering if I messed up? It seems like everytime I am serving, I mess something up. It makes me want to tell them not to put me on the schedule.
I would suggest that if this has happened to you more than once (feeling like you messed up) then you may wish to talk to someone about some refresher training to make sure you know how to handle ambiguous situations like this. Even do some role playing so you ask all the questions you might have regarding how to handle a certain situation.

As for this one - it doesn’t sound like you did anything wrong. I’ve heard priests ask children if they have received their First Communion before if they are unsure - don’t see why you can’t ask that either.

~Liza
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top