This is the Church’s stand on imprecatory prayer. This came from St. Michael’s Supersite.
When we use imprecatory language, even in Jesus name, we are speaking DIRECTLY to the demons, and commanding them DIRECTLY.
This is dangerous.
Because of abuses in this practice the Church in her wisdom has promulgated that for the time being the Faithful should not DIRECTLY speak to demons. It is too dangerous, especially when one does not really know what they are doing. The Church has a pastoral mandate from God to protect the flock. They are protecting the flock with this directive.
Besides, which is really more prudent 1) we butting heads with demons personally by commanding them in Jesus name? or 2) in Jesus name asking God to command them and butt heads with them?
Anyone who prefers to butt heads with demons personally rather than having God do it, is a fool.
I realize that those who are not aware of this ruling may use the “I” language without pride. However, some do get very prideful about it. In fact, the Bible itself, shows us this.
Remember the story of how the disciple came back to Jesus all excited because the demons obeyed them when they commanded them in Jesus name? Jesus did not say, “great going”. He chastised them and said, “Do not rejoice that the demons obey your commands, rejoice only that your names are written in the Book of Life.”
There is always a danger of pride in this area. This is a rather dramatic thing to command demons. Many fall into pride – we only need to look to many Protestant “exorcist” who do a show-biz exorcism to see a prideful way of doing this. And there have been Catholics too, who have taken this show-biz approach or have otherwise been very prideful.
One proof of this pride is when I reveal to a person who doesn’t know about the ruling from the Church and the person refuses to obey but calls me names, slanders me, gossips about me, defames me merely because I informed them of what the Church teaches on this subject.
Bottomline: the first definition of humility is OBEDIENCE.
The Church says NO to this, thus it is NO. period.
Rather, I will follow St. Michael the Archangel’s lead as we read in Jude 9 to use deprecatory language. I will never personally and directly butt heads with the devil again if I can help it.
I hope this helps…
Blessings,
Shoshana