Interpreting Suffering and God's Plan for Creation

  • Thread starter Thread starter JeannetteCML
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are an atheist, the purpose of converting someone to atheism may simply be to help him/her see the truth as an atheist sees it. But an atheist might discuss an issue for purposes other than conversion. An atheist may have no interest in that. And it might be kind of bold, because, ulitmately, I don’t think it’s good for a person to be an atheist in all that it entails. Afterall, if the truth is really unknown, why would you want to talk someone out of his/her belief in Heaven or in an all-loving, all-powerful God? Anyway, an atheist might argue for the sake of an interesting discussion, to see how others think, or to see how others respond to an atheist view.

…Or, an atheist might deep down have questions himself about religious beliefs that he wants to have clarified. 😃
 
It has occurred to me over the course of this discussion that we only sporadically touch on an interpretation of the purpose of suffering as the title of the thread suggests. We may have disappointed many a visitor to this thread, for understanding suffering is a worthy pursuit. So far, we have looked at the compatibility of the doctrine which seeks to describe the origin of suffering with the theory of evolution. (And by the way, a “theory” properly understood is more than just a “guess.” One might, for example, refer to the theory of relativity or the theory of gravity.) From this discussion, we have two causes for human suffering, and those would be a punishment as a result of sin, and, according to evolution, a mechanism that helps preserve life, for we tend to avoid things that cause us to suffer and these things often threaten life.

From the evolutionary standpoint then, the ability to suffer is a kind of advantage or, if you like, a gift from God to help us make our way on earth. But I am also interested in the benefits of suffering that have spiritual significance if suffering is to be seen as a remedy for sin to bring us back to God. (Whether suffering is just we have already tried to determine partly by looking at Original Sin, although the question is still open for discussion.) But I am interesting in hearing any thoughts specifically on:
  1. Why God’s allowing suffering is helpful to us
  2. Why it is that willing suffering of the innocent (or the generous) is that which contributes to Redemption and makes atonement for sin in the Body of Christ; and
  3. Why Christ’s suffering and death has made the distribution of grace possible, as well as the “opening of the gates of Heaven”
Why is this mysterious experience of something that goes against our first natural inclinations profitable for salvation now that there is sin, and why, in suffering, does the natural order seem to be at odds with the supernatural when we choose to suffer rather than to do evil or in order to preserve some higher ideal according to reason?

There is also, of course, the question of eternal suffering of the damned. And this is part of God’s justice if not part of God’s original plan and will. Is it beneficial to anyone in any way? For God allows everything out of love. Is it better to remain in Hell with the knowledge of the gravity of one’s transgression rather than, instead, just being wiped from existance or being seperated from God somehow peacefully?
 
If you are an atheist, the purpose of converting someone to atheism may simply be to help him/her see the truth as an atheist sees it. But an atheist might discuss an issue for purposes other than conversion. An atheist may have no interest in that. And it might be kind of bold, because, ulitmately, I don’t think it’s good for a person to be an atheist in all that it entails. Afterall, if the truth is really unknown, why would you want to talk someone out of his/her belief in Heaven or in an all-loving, all-powerful God? Anyway, an atheist might argue for the sake of an interesting discussion, to see how others think, or to see how others respond to an atheist view.

…Or, an atheist might deep down have questions himself about religious beliefs that he wants to have clarified. 😃
Or the atheist may simply enjoy leading horses to water.
 
I did not intend to offend you in any way. my point was what exactly would be the purpose of converting someone to atheism?
There was no offense taken. For an answer on why I participate, please refer to my previous post above.
 
“I will only say that it is my opinion, looking at things from a purely natural standpoint, human beings were already bound to suffer and die even before they committed their first sin.”

this to me sounds somewhat calvanistic, or that we were predestined to sin , suffer, and die. but i believe God created everything good and that man sinned by freewill. and God does not just start over but manifest his glory through our suffering. God does not just predestine us to eternal life but gives us the choice, but that choice requires our participation with his will.He calls us and gives us the means but it is our choice.
 
I don’t disagree with you that it is our choice. Yet, it was Peter’s choice to deny God and Judas’ choice to betray Him, and God knew about both ahead of time and had a plan surrounding these choices. God also had a plan surrounding the choice of Mary to accept Jesus as her Son. So it seems reasonable to me that God could arrange the earth according to the foreknowledge of choices to be made by freewill. Yet the Bible and the Catechism are clear on what God’s intentions were if humans were not to sin. It’s clear that suffering was not God’s original idea but only the remedy for sin.

I would like to refer you to my post #7 which talks about free will and God’s justice.
 
I don’t disagree with you that it is our choice. Yet, it was Peter’s choice to deny God and Judas’ choice to betray Him, and God knew about both ahead of time and had a plan surrounding these choices. God also had a plan surrounding the choice of Mary to accept Jesus as her Son. So it seems reasonable to me that God could arrange the earth according to the foreknowledge of choices to be made by freewill. Yet the Bible and the Catechism are clear on what God’s intentions were if humans were not to sin. It’s clear that suffering was not God’s original idea but only the remedy for sin.

I would like to refer you to my post #7 which talks about free will and God’s justice.
I think this is a good point. Passages from the Bible, such as, Wisdom 1:12-16 and 1 Corinthians 15:21-23, are not easy to reconcile with an evolutionary origin of humanity. But they are not impossible either.

On the one hand, it may simply be that animals prior to Adam and Eve, even pre-humans, did not spiritually die in the same way that we humans do when we sin. I think this is true. But I don’t think it’s as simple as that either.

On the other hand, if the Devil’s sin led to death “from the beginning”, I think this allows a deeper understanding to the Original Sin that Adam and Eve actually did. I think the Bible does make it very clear that Adam and Eve would not have sinned if not for the Devil’s temptation. So I think this definitely places the Devil as the initial instigator, having in some way fallen prior to Adam and Eve’s fall.

Merging both hands and grasping for an answer, it seems to me that the suffering was not intended but was nonetheless used by God for the greatest good given the circumstances of our freedom. In this sense, I think a theistic evolutionary model produces a clearer vision of how God usually operates in nature (when not performing miracles).

The language of the Book of Genesis uses a poetic language which, in my opinion, should not be taken too literally. However, there are spiritual truths contained within the Book of Genesis too. These truths should not be ignored or confused with the poetic language used to express these spiritual truths.

In my opinion, the latent image of Christ was impressed onto God’s creation so that all of God’s creation would then, via reflecting God’s glorious light, reach upward toward God despite any ‘labors pain’ it might go through. Then, as creation endured the hardships the Devil’s rebellion, she still would have had the latent image of Christ developing in her like film being developed in darkness. Then, once the time was right, Christ would have appeared to restore that which God had originally intended, despite the Devil’s fall.
 
ly on:
  1. Why God’s allowing suffering is helpful to us
  2. Why it is that willing suffering of the innocent (or the generous) is that which contributes to Redemption and makes atonement for sin in the Body of Christ; and
You posed so many good questions in your post Jeannette - questions I’ve also pondered many, many times. I don’t have any sure answers, just some of my thoughts.

The Church teaches that the evils/burdens of human pain, suffering and death became part of our human existence as a result of Original Sin. What has always seemed so beautiful to me is that Our Lord took these bad things and transformed them into good - into the very means that would obtain our salvation. The curse of death is swallowed up in Our Lord’s passion and death as He makes them instead the instruments of salvation. “O death, where is your sting?” (1 Cor 15:55)

**1. Ways in which I see suffering can be helpful: **
It can evoke love in those who have contact with the suffering.

It can increase compassion (in the sufferer) for others who suffer and perhaps help them in assisting others.

In the person who undergoes the suffering, it can serve as a catalyst to examine their life - it’s meaning, final goal; what is truly important. (Am thinking of stories where permanently injured person was actually grateful later on; became much happier than before; etc.)

Suffering provides an opportunity to imitate Our Lord - by accepting it as God’s will and offering it up for the salvation of souls. Two goods result: a) increased eternal rewards for the person who offered their suffering; b) help received by the soul who benefits from the graces bestowed because of the offering.

**2. Why innocent suffering makes atonement **
I suppose the first and most obvious reason is because God has willed it to be that way.

As to the mechanics - the how and why - I have only my own wonderings which came after reading the biographies of several victim souls (eg. Sr. Josepha Menendez, St. Padre Pio). The sense I got was, it’s as tho sin grants Satan power in some way to afflict us. (I’m having difficulty expressing this.) With victim souls, God asks them if they will suffer for a particular soul (the suffering can be direct satanic attack, or various kinds of suffering). It’s as tho the innocent soul takes on the suffering (or other detrimental consequence) released by the sinner - which would/should be experienced by the sinner - if strict justice was applied. These victim souls are able to “handle” the evil without sinning (eg. sin by despair, anger, hate). They truly imitate Our Lord by accepting what is due for the sins of others and offering it up for their salvation.

Those types of victim souls are (comparatively) rare.
But it’s also possible that God allows suffering to come to others who are innocent when He knows they will be able to handle it without sinning.

As to why He lets the innocent suffer what is justly deserved by others - again, just my “wonderings”.
God loves everyone, including the one who is doing the sinning. Perhaps if that sinner were to suffer the evil he has released, he would not be able to “handle” it and it could perhaps result in the loss of his immortal soul (eg. commit suicide without repentance; become totally hardened in serious sin)

I HAVE TO STRESS, THE ABOVE ARE MY OWN THOUGHTS - NOT CHURCH TEACHING. But I do not think they contain anything contrary to Church teaching.

Nita
 
It has occurred to me over the course of this discussion that we only sporadically touch on an interpretation of the purpose of suffering as the title of the thread suggests. We may have disappointed many a visitor to this thread, for understanding suffering is a worthy pursuit.
I think one of the best questions to ask is whether suffering is the result of a sin or whether suffering is the result of a blessing.
So far, we have looked at the compatibility of the doctrine which seeks to describe the origin of suffering with the theory of evolution. (And by the way, a “theory” properly understood is more than just a “guess.” One might, for example, refer to the theory of relativity or the theory of gravity.) From this discussion, we have two causes for human suffering, and those would be a punishment as a result of sin, and, according to evolution, a mechanism that helps preserve life, for we tend to avoid things that cause us to suffer and these things often threaten life.
I find it an interesting parallel that physical death, although a curse, may also be a blessing in disguise too.

For example, if Adam and Eve were allowed to live forever, they may have been trapped in their sin forever, never actually reaching the greater glory God intended for them. It could be argued that God allowing the curse of death to befall humanity happened precisely so that they would have a means to escape an immortal life trapped in the bondage of sin.

The parallel of the curse of death during the fall with speciation via evolution, in my opinion, is that death and decay seem to be the key events which allow species to “break free” of their bondage to their own species.

In other words, as with the fall of humanity pertaining to death and decay, natural selection and mutation seem to likewise be the deciding factors which allowed primordial species to gradually evolve into humanity.

In fact, without these key factors, it seems highly probable that humanity would have never come about. I haven’t totally discounted a “special creation”. However, I do believe that the natural evidence we have is now sufficient to rule out special miraculous creation events (unless further evidence were presented).

In short, death and decay coming to Adam and Eve in order to free them from an eternal life trapped in sin seems to strongly parallel natural selection and mutations happening within various species to free them from a life which is permanently fixed and unable to adapt to change, likewise leading to death.

Just as death and decay may now be required for humanity to be free from sin, natural selection and mutations may have also been required for humanity to arrive in the first place.
From the evolutionary standpoint then, the ability to suffer is a kind of advantage or, if you like, a gift from God to help us make our way on earth.
I would only note that our sufferings can be an advantage if they are in some way joined with Christ’s suffering. They must lead to a genuine hope that is authentically fulfilled in Christ. Perhaps this can happen on a subliminal level. But I don’t really know for sure. It seems possible to me. I know that without Baptism it cannot happen.
 
But I am also interested in the benefits of suffering that have spiritual significance if suffering is to be seen as a remedy for sin to bring us back to God. (Whether suffering is just we have already tried to determine partly by looking at Original Sin, although the question is still open for discussion.) But I am interesting in hearing any thoughts specifically on:
  1. Why God’s allowing suffering is helpful to us
I think the blessing in disguise for death may be one possible example. I think are many things that happen to us that, although we can’t see the purpose for us at the time, are eventually seen to have had a good purpose all along.
  1. Why it is that willing suffering of the innocent (or the generous) is that which contributes to Redemption and makes atonement for sin in the Body of Christ; and…
It seems to me that when we desire something we are actually internally measuring our own souls. The things we are willing to sacrifice our time for are directly related to the value we place on our soul too.

In this sense, perhaps our wills are what holds our soul together at death. More precisely, perhaps our wills, when joined with God’s will, allows us to survive the transition from death to eternal life.

I’m not suggesting that the soul completely dies at death. The soul is eternal and never technically ceases to exist, even when in hell. But a spiritual death most certainly does occur and I think the ability to willingly suffer along with Jesus may be the key that holds the soul together at death.
  1. Why Christ’s suffering and death has made the distribution of grace possible, as well as the “opening of the gates of Heaven”
I think that Jesus, as the Son of God, was the only person who continued to believe in God even when dead. I think that He shared this faith with us at the moment of His death too. I would guess that this is related to the idea of the Communion of Saints. But I certainly would not be able to claim any certain knowledge on this merger at death.
Why is this mysterious experience of something that goes against our first natural inclinations profitable for salvation now that there is sin, and why, in suffering, does the natural order seem to be at odds with the supernatural when we choose to suffer rather than to do evil or in order to preserve some higher ideal according to reason?
These are very good questions that I would like answers for. I don’t know for sure how this part works. But I have some ideas.
There is also, of course, the question of eternal suffering of the damned. And this is part of God’s justice if not part of God’s original plan and will. Is it beneficial to anyone in any way?
I don’t honestly know if it’s entirely beneficial. But it does seem fair to me. Indeed, when we have sinned, we have eternally separated either ourselves or else others from God’ grace. We don’t have the power to overcome the eternal distance that our sins cause. Jesus does, which is why I think we need to be buried with Christ in our baptism.

The reason why hell is forever is because the results of our actions can never be taken back by mortal means. It would take something or someone who is immortal and transcends time to fix the past.
For God allows everything out of love. Is it better to remain in Hell with the knowledge of the gravity of one’s transgression rather than, instead, just being wiped from existence or being separated from God somehow peacefully?
I think if God absolutely annihilated the soul that sinned then this could be construed as God, on a spiritual level, murdering the soul. If so, I don’t think that God, by His holy nature as Pure Spirit, can do this.

I’m not 100% sure. But I honestly think that God Himself would be sinning if He murdered the soul of a person by absolutely annihilating it into total oblivion.

In this sense, it may be that hell is the most just means that God can punish someone with without God Himself being guilty of a sin.
 
yes the Church teaches that God is outside of time because he created it and he is ever present in all time. Meaning he is present in the past the now and the future. and its not that we were predestined to sin or bound to sin but that God being ever present foreseen man would be tempted and sin. so God has set in time the way for our redemtion if only we repent and turn back to him. St. leo the great states that the blessings through Christ’s condemnation of sin are far greater that the original justice that adam and eve had. and Paul states where sin abounds Grace abounds all the more, not that we should sin in order to receive greater graces but that God’s goodnes is far greater than the wickedness of the devil. and God alows sin and suffering to bring about a greater good. the Church teaches that original sin is not an act but a state, where Adam and Eve were created in the state of original jusctice and holiness and when they sinned ( which i believe to be a result of the envy of the devil ) they lost original justice and holiness and were subject to toil and strife and suffering and lost harmony with creation. so all decendents then are born into this state of original sin.
 
  1. Why God’s allowing suffering is helpful to us
im suprised there are no more responses. I did find some scripture to support suffering as a remedy for sin.

1 Since therefore Christ suffered in the flesh, * arm yourselves with the same thought, for whoever has suffered in the flesh has ceased from sin, so as to live for the rest of the time in the flesh no longer by human passions but by the will of God.

Therefore let those who suffer according to God’s will do right and entrust their souls to a faithful Creator.

these are from first Peter ch.4 rsvce but you should read all of first Peter so it is not taken out of context,because it is not talking about all kinds of suffering but those who suffer as Christ sufferd,for the sake of our salvation. God Bless
 
Very interesting topic. I was thinking about starting a thread just like this, but I’ll contribute instead.

Some initial thoughts:
(1) Suffering: It is plain to see that lower forms of animal life do experience pain and this pain can be protracted such that an animal suffers. However, we can either say that this suffering is pretty much the same as the suffering of human beings, or we can point out the obvious and say that the addition of consciousness and spirit (emotion, reflection, etc.) makes human suffering a qualitatively different thing. Thus, while lifeforms have always “suffered” (I don’t think this can be refuted), and basic suffering was probably inherited into the human physical make-up through evolution, the suffering we are discussing is Suffering proper, that suffering which is unique to the human condition.

(2) Death: There’s death, and then there’s Death. The Christian understanding of Death is not mortality of the body, but the state of the Soul. If we are living in communion with God, we are Living, if not, we are Dead. Physical death releases the Soul, and the Soul is eternal, so death ushers in either eternal Death or eternal Life, the sole decider (in the end) being God. As with suffering, death was probably inherited with our physical bodies, but takes on more powerful dimensions because of our ability to comprehend it: an end to existence in the material world.

From these two considerations, I think we can say that suffering and death for humans are not suffering and death in natural, scientific terms. For us, these things are infinitely more meaningful that, say, to a gazelle which is being eaten alive by a lion.

With all that out of the way (please debate my assumptions if you wish)…

The ideas of the posters in this thread are much like my own. death and suffering have been turned into useful things by God, and perhaps are not worthy of considering conceptually as evil, so long as they do not prevent human beings from seeking God as seems to be happening right now with the rise in public atheism. As the Cathechism states (paraphrasing): “God does not allow such things except where they can be used to bring out a net increase in Good.”

To Jason W:
Your idea about linking our suffering to that of Christ sounds spot on to me. If we simply wallow in our own suffering or let it turn us into resentful and angry beings, we certainly have not followed His example. And while Christ suffered for our salvation, He suffered more generally for Us. Thus, the conceptual and spiritual linking of our suffering to that of Christ is perhaps (in a practical sense) simply allowing ourselves to suffer. And if we too suffer and / or die for another (legitimately, not just in our heads), such things are infinitely more meaningful.

More importantly, it implies as a pre-requisite that we should not be so scared of life that we close ourselves off from any chance of suffering (or one of its weak siblings, inconvenience), because if we do, we are not living anymore, we are just waiting to die with the hope that we stay as comfortable as possible in the meantime, and that would be truely sad.
 
The ideas of the posters in this thread are much like my own. death and suffering have been turned into useful things by God, and perhaps are not worthy of considering conceptually as evil, so long as they do not prevent human beings from seeking God as seems to be happening right now with the rise in public atheism. As the Catechism states (paraphrasing): “God does not allow such things except where they can be used to bring out a net increase in Good.”
These are really good points.

As far as I believe there are bad things that happen to people which prompt them to go closer to God. But I don’t think that God Himself deliberately “causes”, for example, children to die just to bring their surviving parents into a deeper faith. Indeed, what about the children who died-- would God not want to bring them into the ‘fold’ as well?

Look as Genesis 50:20…
You intended to harm me, but God intended it for good to accomplish what is now being done, the saving of many lives.
I think when people talk about ‘God’s plan,’ I think they sometimes phrase it in such as way so that it appears as if God directly did it. But I think there’s a big difference between God “allowing” something to happen as a consequence of the freedom He permitted and God directly “causing” it to happen just to make it work according to His plan.

If God is going to step back to allow people the freedom to act independently of His will, then bad things happening can be (and have been) a consequence of their refusal to act according to His will. And the innocent will suffer as a result of this.

Of course, someone might insist that God step in and correct the wrong.

But where does that leave human freedom?

I think He is offering to step in and correct the wrong whenever He explains that we have to forgive others in order to bring healing. Actually, I think the ability to forgive (out of genuine divine love) is the ultimate expression of God’s power at His Most Highest.

This is probably more properly expressed in 2 Corinthians 7:8-10 very well…
Even if I caused you sorrow by my letter, I do not regret it. Though I did regret it—I see that my letter hurt you, but only for a little while— yet now I am happy, not because you were made sorry, but because your sorrow led you to repentance. For you became sorrowful as God intended and so were not harmed in any way by us. Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation and leaves no regret, but worldly sorrow brings death.
There is simply nothing that has ever happened that can not be overcome with sincere repentance in the face of the divine offer of forgiveness. This, I think, highlights the difference between Judas’ and Peter’s reactions to Jesus offer of salvation.

Judas seems to have had worldly sorrow which brought death.

Peter seems to have had Godly sorrow which brought repentance that led to salvation and left no regret.
 
As far as I believe there are bad things that happen to people which prompt them to go closer to God. But I don’t think that God Himself deliberately “causes”, for example, children to die just to bring their surviving parents into a deeper faith. Indeed, what about the children who died-- would God not want to bring them into the ‘fold’ as well?

I think when people talk about ‘God’s plan,’ I think they sometimes phrase it in such as way so that it appears as if God directly did it. But I think there’s a big difference between God “allowing” something to happen as a consequence of the freedom He permitted and God directly “causing” it to happen just to make it work according to His plan.

If God is going to step back to allow people the freedom to act independently of His will, then bad things happening can be (and have been) a consequence of their refusal to act according to His will. And the innocent will suffer as a result of this.

Of course, someone might insist that God step in and correct the wrong.

But where does that leave human freedom?

I think He is offering to step in and correct the wrong whenever He explains that we have to forgive others in order to bring healing. Actually, I think the ability to forgive (out of genuine divine love) is the ultimate expression of God’s power at His Most Highest.

This is probably more properly expressed in 2 Corinthians 7:8-10 very well…

There is simply nothing that has ever happened that can not be overcome with sincere repentance in the face of the divine offer of forgiveness. This, I think, highlights the difference between Judas’ and Peter’s reactions to Jesus offer of salvation.

Judas seems to have had worldly sorrow which brought death. Peter seems to have had Godly sorrow which brought repentance that led to salvation and left no regret.
Yup! If you notice I didn’t say “caused,” I said “allowed” also.

I like your Corinthians-based distinction between “worldly sorrow” and “Godly sorrow.” I think the difference between the two can best be summarized as “look down with anger and a scowl” or “look up with tears and a smile.”

Side-topic:
The role of human freedom in all this is still something I grapple with. I’ve tried to have conversations with others on the subject, but they don’t seem to go anywhere. There’s obviously a “Plan” that God has set in motion, but I don’t think that implies that everything is planned out. Otherwise, predestination becomes predetermination.

Ah! Maybe I’ve finally made the connection! When we say an event is “destined” it means that an “intention” exists for it to happen, but there is no guarantee within a given time-frame. But something being “determined” is an absolute: it will happen, and at this or that proscribed time. Obviously God knows what’s going to happen, he has destined it; but in the end, we are the determiners. Is this right, or did I just become a heretic? 🤷
 
Yup! If you notice I didn’t say “caused,” I said “allowed” also.
Actually, I did notice that. 🙂
I like your Corinthians-based distinction between “worldly sorrow” and “Godly sorrow.” I think the difference between the two can best be summarized as “look down with anger and a scowl” or “look up with tears and a smile.”
I think a passage from the Bible like that really cuts to the lowest common denominator in all these discussions. Pain is going to happen in this life. There’s no getting around it. So what are we going to do with it?

Look toward Jesus on the cross.

If the pain is intended by God Himself for a “good purpose” will we embrace it or will we flee from it?

And is there really any difference aside from the choices we make when confronted with this pain?
Side-topic:
The role of human freedom in all this is still something I grapple with. I’ve tried to have conversations with others on the subject, but they don’t seem to go anywhere.
I know how you feel.

Adam and Eve, in my opinion, were not given the “right” to sin against God by God himself. This seems to be a post-fall conclusion which may have actually resulted from the fall itself.

They gave themselves this “right” against God’s will when they choose not to trust God. This seems to capture the pre-fall Wisdom from God which He warned Adam and Eve about from the beginning.

By holding out the chance for them to become “divinized” so to speak, He offered them a chance to be part of God’s family. When I say “divinized” I am referring to God sharing His essence with them so that they rise above the creation and are no longer merely behaving no differently than forces of nature or the animals below.

I have St. Athanasius’s words in mind when discuss this…
“God became human, so that humans might become God.”
However, Adam and Eve seem to have taken the ability to be “divinized” (having a supernatural free-will which can act independently of nature) all the while rejecting the life of the Divine One (His Holiness) who shared His essence with them. Now, instead of “freedom from choice” they have led people into a state of “having to choose between good and evil”.

I honeslty don’t think we’re here because we’re free. I think we’re here because we’re not free. In other words, we are “condemned to be free”.

But I also think this is part of the “Happy Accident” that we Catholics often speak of with Adam, something which seems to have had great precedence many times in the Old testament, such as Genesis 50:20 for example. There were indeed many happy accidents happening in the time prior to the coming of Christ. In fact, one could also say that these same kinds of happy accidents have had great precedence many times past according to an evolutionary theistic view of God’s creation too. Indeed, one could say that many “happy accidents” along the evolutionary chain led toward the creation of humanity. Adam’s happy accident seems to have been following in the footprints of many happy accidents which had been happening all along. The most fortuitous Happy Accident seems to have come full circle when the Devil accidentally defeated himself when he tricked the religious leaders of his time to crucify our Lord and Saviour.

Think about it. :hmmm:

Saying that God gave them the “right”, in my opinion, somehow indicates that God wanted them to choose between good and evil. I don’t think this is the case. I think that God told them to choose the good and was protecting them from choosing the evil. When they forsook his protection, however, then they entered into state where they have to henceforth “choose” between good and evil, living in a state of spiritual death.

Instead of simply “knowing” both good and evil in original justice (as they were originally created) they were now “experiencing” both good and evil in a state of condemnation (which they created themselves). 😦

This is my opinion anyway.
There’s obviously a “Plan” that God has set in motion, but I don’t think that implies that everything is planned out. Otherwise, predestination becomes predetermination.
I think it could be a little of both.

God does know, in advance, what our actions will bring about. There’s simply no way to get around this part when dealing with an Omniscient Being. However, knowing in advance what will happen does not mean that God necessarily made it happen either.

This comes to the flip side of the debate. God, at least as Pure Spirit, does not appear to directly make us do things either, so He does seem to have taken a hands-off approach to His creation. I think that God knew the outcome of our actions regardless of whether we obeyed Him or not.

So, in one sense, it is fixed from the beginning. But in the other sense, precisely because the outcome of their choices (whether good or evil) were fixed from the beginning, they could ultimately only end up in one of two places, Heaven or Hell. There are no other options that I am aware off.
Ah! Maybe I’ve finally made the connection! When we say an event is “destined” it means that an “intention” exists for it to happen, but there is no guarantee within a given time-frame. But something being “determined” is an absolute: it will happen, and at this or that proscribed time. Obviously God knows what’s going to happen, he has destined it; but in the end, we are the determiners. Is this right, or did I just become a heretic? 🤷
I don’t know if it’s heretical, but it can lean into a form of process theology if it suggests that God didn’t actually know what would happen. I’m ok with process theology to the extent that it allows God’s Will to act via contingent processes which have already been fixed by God Himself (which isn’t the same as Deism, despite the similarities on the surface).

However, I would strongly warn against the idea that God didn’t actually know what was going to happen in the future because He works through contingent processes. God really does know in advance what will happen, which is what makes Him the perfect judge of all the earth. There’s no getting around this part in my opinion.
 
Well, it seems there is a lot of informative history in that article. And I would agree with the author that theologians really need to pick up the pieces yet. But I don’t think the author offers an adequate solution to the contraditions between the human history that science offers and the doctrines that the Church still teaches. The little scenerio at the end does not account for the entrance of suffering and death, and it relies heavily on the notion that sinfulness and grace are hereditary matters or bound up in the community of humans which I have serious problems with. Maybe that’s because I really like to be treated as an individual and am very much at a loss than when it is other people who disturb the relationship between myself and my God. Anyway, that’s my take.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top