Yup! If you notice I didn’t say “caused,” I said “allowed” also.
Actually, I did notice that.
I like your Corinthians-based distinction between “worldly sorrow” and “Godly sorrow.” I think the difference between the two can best be summarized as “look down with anger and a scowl” or “look up with tears and a smile.”
I think a passage from the Bible like
that really cuts to the
lowest common denominator in all these discussions. Pain is going to happen in this life. There’s no getting around it. So what are we going to do with it?
Look toward Jesus on the cross.
If the pain is intended by God Himself for a “good purpose” will we embrace it or will we flee from it?
And is there really any difference aside from the choices we make when confronted with this pain?
Side-topic:
The role of human freedom in all this is still something I grapple with. I’ve tried to have conversations with others on the subject, but they don’t seem to go anywhere.
I know how you feel.
Adam and Eve, in my opinion, were not given the “right” to sin against God by God himself. This seems to be a post-fall conclusion which may have actually resulted from the fall itself.
They gave themselves this “right” against God’s will when they choose not to trust God. This seems to capture the pre-fall Wisdom from God which He warned Adam and Eve about from the beginning.
By holding out the chance for them to become “divinized” so to speak, He offered them a chance to be part of God’s family. When I say “divinized” I am referring to God sharing His essence with them so that they rise above the creation and are no longer merely behaving no differently than forces of nature or the animals below.
I have
St. Athanasius’s words in mind when discuss this…
“God became human, so that humans might become God.”
However, Adam and Eve seem to have taken the ability to be “divinized” (having a supernatural free-will which can act independently of nature) all the while rejecting the life of the Divine One (His Holiness) who shared His essence with them. Now, instead of “freedom from choice” they have led people into a state of “having to choose between good and evil”.
I honeslty don’t think we’re here because we’re
free. I think we’re here because we’re
not free. In other words, we are “condemned to be free”.
But I also think this is part of the “Happy Accident” that we Catholics often speak of with Adam, something which seems to have had great precedence many times in the Old testament, such as Genesis 50:20 for example. There were indeed many happy accidents happening in the time prior to the coming of Christ. In fact, one could also say that these same kinds of happy accidents have had great precedence many times past according to an evolutionary theistic view of God’s creation too. Indeed, one could say that many “happy accidents” along the evolutionary chain led toward the creation of humanity. Adam’s happy accident seems to have been following in the footprints of many happy accidents which had been happening all along. The most fortuitous
Happy Accident seems to have come full circle when the Devil accidentally defeated himself when he tricked the religious leaders of his time to crucify our Lord and Saviour.
Think about it.
Saying that God gave them the “right”, in my opinion, somehow indicates that God
wanted them to choose between good and evil. I don’t think this is the case. I think that God
told them to choose the good and was
protecting them from choosing the evil. When they forsook his protection, however, then they entered into state where they have to henceforth “choose” between good and evil, living in a state of spiritual death.
Instead of simply “knowing” both good and evil in original justice (as they were originally created) they were now “experiencing” both good and evil in a state of condemnation (which they created themselves).
This is my opinion anyway.
There’s obviously a “Plan” that God has set in motion, but I don’t think that implies that everything is planned out. Otherwise, predestination becomes predetermination.
I think it could be a little of both.
God does know, in advance, what our actions will bring about. There’s simply no way to get around this part when dealing with an Omniscient Being. However, knowing in advance what will happen does not mean that God necessarily made it happen either.
This comes to the flip side of the debate. God, at least as Pure Spirit, does not appear to directly make us do things either, so He does seem to have taken a hands-off approach to His creation. I think that God knew the outcome of our actions regardless of whether we obeyed Him or not.
So, in one sense,
it is fixed from the beginning. But in the other sense, precisely because the outcome of their choices (whether good or evil) were fixed from the beginning, they could ultimately only end up in one of two places, Heaven or Hell. There are no other options that I am aware off.
Ah! Maybe I’ve finally made the connection! When we say an event is “destined” it means that an “intention” exists for it to happen, but there is no guarantee within a given time-frame. But something being “determined” is an
absolute: it will happen, and at this or that proscribed time. Obviously God knows what’s going to happen, he has destined it; but in the end, we are the determiners. Is this right, or did I just become a heretic?
I don’t know if it’s heretical, but it
can lean into a form of
process theology if it suggests that God didn’t actually know what would happen. I’m ok with process theology to the extent that it allows God’s Will to act via contingent processes which have already been fixed by God Himself (which isn’t the same as Deism, despite the similarities on the surface).
However, I would strongly warn against the idea that God didn’t actually know what was going to happen in the future because He works through contingent processes. God really does know in advance what will happen, which is what makes Him the perfect judge of all the earth. There’s no getting around this part in my opinion.