Is breaking laws always sinful? (Excluding contradicting laws)

  • Thread starter Thread starter BensFaithJourney
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just to be clear, booked means arrested, fingerprinted and photographed. Are you saying that in your state you get arrested for going 5 or 10 over? Or do you mean you get a ticket? That’s something completely different, though here judges automatically dismiss any speed less than 12 over, and I don’t know a single officer who will write for less than 15-20 over.
 
Sorry, no, I just meant I’d get a fine/speeding ticket. Well, I certainly wish there were more of you here in my city!

ETA -
booked means arrested, fingerprinted and photographed.
in my mind, I think of that as being arrested and charged which is when you’d be handcuffed, taken to the station, fingerprinted etc and formally charged etc.
 
Last edited:
venial sins are forgiven at Mass. Which might be easier to go to than confession. I’d hate to see the lines if people confessed speeding.

However, I don’t think it is a venial sin either in most cases.
 
Last edited:
If minor traffic violations are sinful then I’m guessing most people should not drive ever. I don’t know any of you personally but I would wager a plugged nickle that if you drove me around for an hour I could condemn your soul by the standards set here.

What was it Elanor Roosevelt said about America and speed? 😉

And no one has obviously been in a car in Italy with a priest.
 
Last edited:
For your information CRV, the top speed for a Honda CR-V is 121 MPH.

So I guess we know how fast you go now!
 
Last edited:
venial sins are forgiven at Mass
That is one other way - yes. But there isn’t anything wrong in confessing venial sins if one does not have mortal sins to confess. Otherwise the past Popes and Saints were wasting their time and the confessor as well. Confessing venial sins used to also be known as confessions of devotion. Saturday afternoon there was always a line up to go to Confesssion, unlike nowadays, when in the average parish there are only a few going to confession.

If done deliberately thus knowingly breaking a just law, then yes, there is sin. Obviously there are other factors that would need to be taken into account to determine whether it was an imperfection, venial or mortal/grave sin for any particular individual.
If minor traffic violations are sinful then I’m guessing most people should not drive ever. I don’t know any of you personally but I would wager a plugged nickle that if you drove me around for an hour I could condemn your soul by the standards set here.
As in all things, there are venial and grave matter and I have not stated all traffic violations are serious enough to condemn a soul. I think that is an unnecessary and unhelpful exaggeration.

After all - all sin is offensive to God and we should be striving to eliminate all sin from our lives with the grace of God. I think most people including myself will be struggling to overcome various sins right up until the day we die, but that doesn’t mean a person should become complacent and adopt the attitude of “hey, it’s no big deal, don’t sweat it, don’t worry about it, it’s only venial so it doesn’t really matter” etc.
For your information CRV, the top speed for a Honda CR-V is 121 MPH.

So I guess we know how fast you go now!
And? Oh, humor or sarcasm… … … … not.
 
I know of one gentleman who got booked for going 1 over.
one town I drive thru, where the limit is 35, had a sign that stated 36-40 $$, 41-50 $$$, etc.

this town is a speed trap, but they do warn you before you hit the city limits.

each town has their own rules.
Sorry, no, I just meant I’d get a fine/speeding ticket.
and probably an increase in insurance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top