Is cohabitation always completely wrong?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tobi-Wan_Kenobi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tobi-Wan_Kenobi

Guest
My girlfriend and I have been together for about a year and a half now (our relationship became official back in October of 2016). At that point in my life, I was living with my mom and stepdad and due to some poor decisions on my part, I moved out of their house and moved in with some guys I knew all the way across the metro area (45 minutes away from my parents and girlfriend). I didn’t have a car at the time, so my girlfriend was always the one to have to drive down to see me and hang out, but because she was also in college, she had class all day every day of the week. After a few months of living with my friends, it became clear to me that my living situation was a bad one. In the two months I lived with them, my bass guitar got stolen by one of the other guys for drug money, I was far from my family and friends, was far from my girlfriend, and wasn’t within walking distance of a Catholic parish. After a while of thinking about it, I decided to move back to the town where my parents and friends and girlfriend lived, but I knew that living with my mom and stepdad again was not going to be a possibility. So, my girlfriend offered to let me move in with her. At the time, I truly didn’t see anything wrong with it. She had already used money she received through scholarships and financial assistance at her college to pay off the entirety of her rent at her apartment, so the only expenses I would have would be food, my phone bill, and putting gas in her vehicle, and I would also be able to walk to mass at one of the few parishes there in town because they were close to her apartment. Her and I live together there for the remainder of the lease and then her and I move back to her hometown and her parents give us a place to stay at their house, which is super nice, but I’ve just been wondering how morally and ethically right or wrong it is for her and I to be living together for a while now. I truly never thought about it being a problem a year ago when we first moved in together. I thought the problems and the sins would arise from having premarital sex (which we have actually abstained from) and being indecent around each other, not from simply living under the same roof. Some of the priests I have talked to about this say they don’t necessarily see any problem with us living together under the same roof at her parents’ house as long as we have separate rooms and sleeping arrangements However, my girlfriend and I are wanting to move back to my hometown so that I can finish up my last year of college and get my degree, and she keeps talking about her and I getting our own place together. At this point, I really don’t know that I can live with her and feel right about it. Her and I are not engaged and obviously not married, but even if we had separate sleeping arrangements and lived together for purely economic reasons, I now know how scandalous it would look, and my faith is the most important thing to me. All this being said, I guess I am looking for some clarification and some direction and advice. If it is only for economic reasons and we have separate sleeping arrangements and just don’t make our shared apartment known, is it still wrong?
 
I sympathize with your story, blah, blah, etc. etc. -
It’s wrong.

I think of my grandmother -
My grandfather had died - and she went for a check up -
She met this flirtatious guy her age - they hung out -
Then, he moved in - underneath same roof - same bed -
Because - it was cheaper -
They didn’t marry - weren’t engaged -
That made - the entire family scratch their head.
If they had married…it might have been more welcoming…

So marry - or move on -
 
(which we have actually abstained from)
Quite and admirable feat. You guys are in increased risk of ruining your relationship and undergo increased hardship at a spiritual level. Because, the main thing is your love and your relationship. I’d recommend reading “Love and Responsibility” by Karol Wojtyla. Well, a couple of friends of mine after terrible hardship through their lives went strong with their love and relationship. And it seems it will work out, their are fathering a child and eventually getting married. Was it sinful? Well, that is an extremely subtle issue best discussed between a couple and a specialized priest. Because it touches on your lives and your love. The problem with my friends, was that in their “state of life” they couldn’t confess or receive communion (and scandal isn’t the key issue here). So, a couple in that situation can, nevertheless, have a prayer life and grow closer to Jesus and in sanctity. Cohabitation is nothing to desire, what is to be desired is the gift of life and the sacrament of marriage. But if you are in that situation, there are intelligent and catholic ways to go about it and make it work and make the best of it. - I am however not the right person to comment on the issue.

Do seek a priest who specializes on marriage preparation and make an appointment with him. You’ll find it a valuable meeting and reflection, your relationship will grow stronger from it.
 
If it is only for economic reasons and we have separate sleeping arrangements and just don’t make our shared apartment known, is it still wrong?
Are you are saying that you are not scandalizing (tempting) each other?
 
You should take this under the direction of your priest, not strangers on the Internet. It is not necessarily sinful for two people of the opposite sex to live in the same house. There could be temptations, there could be occasion of sin, there could be any number of things, but your priest knows you and he has advised you. Do not bring this sort of thing to the Internet with people who do not know you.
 
It seems you are trying to justify the reason you are living together. close to the church…less bills…I think you already know the answer about living together. We are suppose to avoid the ‘near occasion of sin’. I am not going to judge you. Your grown, you know what you are doing, only you will choose. I hope you find the answers you are looking for within yourself. God Bless you.🦋🦋
 
Speak with your priest.

Of course, if you are unsure, refrain from receiving the Eucharist until you have spoken with your priest and have everything settled. I know it may be difficult without the Eucharist to be able to resist temptation, but perhaps also pray a bit more to maybe help a bit, like the Rosary and mental prayer if not already.
 
Last edited:
Why on earth would you ask for advice from a forum full of amateurs.
Get a spiritual direction relationship with a chosen priest and take it from there.
God bless.
 
Hello.

If your faith is most important to you, treat it as such.

I’m actually very happy that you reached out to ask this question, if only to confirm your own suspicions about the morality of living together.

Can you brainstorm about some other types of living situations where you won’t be so close to the near occasion of sin? How about renting a room? Looking for a roommate of the same gender? Advertise in church bulletin for room & board in exchange for doing some home maintenance or taking care of an elderly person?

You are in my prayers. Please pray for me. Keep fighting the good fight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top