Is contraception more evil than abortion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rejoice
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What you have to do is try to imagine what Gods will is for us.

God blessed us with the ability to create life. When we turned from God a counter truth to everything that God gave us came into existence. Like everything in our world sex is corrupted and twisted just like life and death.

If we are to enter the kingdom of God then we have to be willing to understand and respect the Gift of life.

In a perfect world we would have no need to have sex for our own sexual satisfaction. There would be NO fear and there would be only love around us. In such a world we would always want to join for the sake of procreation. The act of creation would be so sacred and it would always be blessed with love. There would be nothing to be ashamed of.

So the question isn’t “what sin is greater?” The questions are “what do you truly believe in?” How much to you want to live without evil? How much to you want your life to be a reflection of a perfect world without evil and fear?

In the end we can only hope God will have mercy on us. He will grant you eternal life if you have shown respect for life and the creation of life.

When we practice abstinence we are showing God that we have respect for the creation of life.
 
40.png
JamesG:
In a perfect world we would have no need to have sex for our own sexual satisfaction.

.
I’m sorry but what is evil about that? this really is what it’s about insn’t it, birth control aside, the idea of a married couple making love out of a desire for intimacy, THAT is what offends some Catholics.
 
40.png
cynic:
I’m sorry but what is evil about that? this really is what it’s about insn’t it, birth control aside, the idea of a married couple making love out of a desire for intimacy, THAT is what offends some Catholics.
I can’t speak for “most Catholics,” but that is not church teaching. Married couples should be making love for intimacy. They just can’t ignore or make go away the procreative side.
 
40.png
magdelaine:
I guess I just don’t accept the “contraception (excepting abortificants) is inherently evil” argument, which is why it made sense to me.
Luckily, you don’t have to “accept” it. However, as you are aware church teaching, that doesn’t mean that you can ignore it without committing the sin. (I don’t mean to judge “you”, but keep in mind that when a person is aware that it is a grave sin, and use contraception of his/her own free will, that is a mortal sin.) Informing your conscious means that you work towards understanding why it is wrong. Please do some research on why the church teaches what is does regarding sexuality.

I have to be honest with you. I did not agree with these teachings (and many others) years ago. Learning the why’s is how I became truly Catholic. I have learned that there is always a very good and logical reason to every teaching–even the ones I have difficult with! (And now I don’t have many of those difficulties as I have seen that the Church’s teachings are reliable!)😉
 
40.png
JamesG:
What you have to do is try to imagine what Gods will is for us.

God blessed us with the ability to create life. When we turned from God a counter truth to everything that God gave us came into existence. Like everything in our world sex is corrupted and twisted just like life and death.

If we are to enter the kingdom of God then we have to be willing to understand and respect the Gift of life.

In a perfect world we would have no need to have sex for our own sexual satisfaction. There would be NO fear and there would be only love around us. In such a world we would always want to join for the sake of procreation. The act of creation would be so sacred and it would always be blessed with love. There would be nothing to be ashamed of.

So the question isn’t “what sin is greater?” The questions are “what do you truly believe in?” How much to you want to live without evil? How much to you want your life to be a reflection of a perfect world without evil and fear?

In the end we can only hope God will have mercy on us. He will grant you eternal life if you have shown respect for life and the creation of life.

When we practice abstinence we are showing God that we have respect for the creation of life.
Great post!👍
 
1ke wrote,
Contraception is not a mortal sin because it “prevents a soul from existing”.
While I suspect we’d disagree on the contraception issue itself, I’m glad to see a Roman Catholic who is “pro Humanae Vitae” who “gets it.” The whole assertion that contraception is bad because it “prevents a soul from being conceived” is itself a very ill-conceived argument and actually does the Vatican-line on contraception no favours. Read that again folks (you know who you are) - you’re not helping your cause with this type of argument.
 
40.png
cynic:
like someone else said, what is the difference between preventing sperm from meeting egg (abc) and carefully measuring for a time when there is no egg (nfp)? Surely if there is no egg, there is no fertility, and the part of sex you call inseparable is missing anyway. And to do it knowing that there is no egg, well that means that the procreative element is missing from the couples conscience/awareness aswell.

If the fact that contraception interferes with the reproductive parts fo the the body makes it a sin, then fine, but spare us the “these couples are using each other” stuff, because you condemn nfp users along with them, and contradict yourselves.
NFP is not a man made thing interfering with fertility. God created the human body and all its cycles, therfore there is nothing wrong with it. There was nothing in the bible that said a husband and wife could not have sex when the wife was not fertile. AND as far as nfp goes there ARE people who abuse it, in order for nfp to be used to prevent pregnancy without being a sin there must be grave circumstances, then and ONLY then can nfp be used for that reason. The whole issue about contraceptives (and nfp abuse) is that it is unnatural, leads to the abuse of a sacred act and of an individual.
I understand where you are coming from and it is confusing which is why couples are suposed to take classes and converse with a priest before getting married. Anyways, like I said before, the bottom line is that no unnatural means can be used to prevent pregnancy. NFP can only be used under certain circumstances (and should be approved by a priest). Is that good enough?
 
40.png
JamesG:
In a perfect world we would have no need to have sex for our own sexual satisfaction… In such a world we would always want to join for the sake of procreation.

.
that says it all, sex should be free of desire, free of personal attachments, an entirely platonic gesture made for the sake of procreation only. Thanks for making that clear.
 
I dont agree with James G, in Heaven we won’t need sex or realtionships because we will be perfect with God and His love. But here on earth we are unable to experience a love or life as perfect as heaven. Sex b/w husband and wife is to mimic that love as best we can here on earth. In a perfect world we woun’t need to physically express anything because we would have it directly from God into our being.
 
The morality of any act, and its gravity (degree of sinfulness) is determined by the three fonts of morality.
  1. intention
  2. moral object
    3, circumstances (esp. consequences)
For this question, let’s set aside intention and circumstances, and only consider whether the moral object of contraception is more or less gravely disordered than abortion. Also, let’s consider only contraception per se (not abortifacient contraception).

The Church teaches that contraception and abortion are each objectively a mortal sin. However, one mortal sin can be more serious than another mortal sin, because one mortal sin can be more thoroughly contrary to the love of God, and the love of neighbor as yourself, that is the basis for morality.

Direct abortion is a type of murder; it is the direct and voluntary killing of an innocent human being. Such an act is very thoroughly contrary to the love of neighbor, especially since this particular neighbor is about as innocent as a human being can be.

Contraception is morally disordered because it is a sexual act which lacks the procreative meaning. The moral object is deprived of a good which God requires to be present, the procreative meaning of the sexual act.

The moral object of murder is the deprivation of life from an innocent, whereas the moral object of a contracepted sexual act is the deprivation of the procreative meaning. Since the life of an innocent person is a greater good than the procreative meaning of a sexual act, the moral object of abortion (a type of murder) has a greater degree of moral disorder and therefore is a more serious mortal sin…
 
Hi everyone,

Firstly, 3 points to review on what Pope JPII said in Gospel of Life:
  1. that BOTH are evil and are fruits of the same tree
  2. that there is a DIFFERENCE in the moral gravity.
  3. BUT he does not say which is the greater of the two evils.
So, I think this falls into the speculative theology area that is also not official/dogmatic teaching as to which is the worse evil. And like a holy priest said in today’s Sunday Mass sermon, we shouldn’t focus too much on questions that we can’t answer anyways in this life (like will Pope Francis be the last pope, or when will be the end of the world, or is Princess Diana’s soul in Heaven or Hell, etc., but rather we should focus on the essential question: what must I do to be saved?" Granted, while I don’t believe knowing the answer to which is worse will be on the “entrance exam” to the Heavenly Kingdom nevertheless it may be somewhat helpful to speculate and contemplate this question if it brings one closer to the Heart of God and one’s growth in holiness.

Secondly, I think this is a bit if an apples vs oranges discussion in one sense that has been overlooked and would, if I’m correct, mean the answer is more of a “both/and” kind of an answer. Here’s what I mean by that…

It seems to my tiny theological mind that the evil of abortion is worse for the PERSON(S) who commit this sinful act whereas the evil of contraception is worse for the WOULD-BE SOUL(S) who MIGHT have not come into existence as a result.

Let’s make this a more concrete example and apply names. Let’s say the married couple are named George and Elizabeth and the child is Teresa…

A) If George and Elizabeth intentionally kill Teresa via abortion they would deprive Teresa of the normal temporal life on earth and gravely sin In doing so. Fast forward 1 billion “years” from now and in eternity you would find George, Elizabeth, and Teresa in eternity, hopefully each with God in the kingdom of Heaven.

Vs

B) If George and Elizabeth intentionally render the marital embrace sterile which would have otherwise been fertile they would deprive Teresa of both the temporal life on earth and eternal life and gravely sin in doing so. Fast forward 1 billion years from now and you see George and Elizabeth somewhere in Eternity, but, very sadly, no Teresa.

(And to let the profundity sink in, imagine YOU in Heaven 1 billion years from now enjoying yourself; now, imagine Yourself NOT in Heaven for all eternity. Profound silence! No words can express this.)

So I say all this just to remind us all that The End (which is truly just the Beginning) is the most important thing to keep in mind (ie, Eternity) and also that the answer to this question depends on if you’re talking about the couple or the child.

Also a distinction must be made between an evil act and the consequence of an evil act.

In conclusion, I think it MIGHT go like this:
  1. For the couple, the greater evil would be abortion
  2. For the child, the greater evil would be contraception
And who better to ask than a child, so I asked our pre-teen sons “Is it better to exist or to never have existed?” and they answered it quite well I thought saying:

“It’s better to exist cuz then you got a chance to go to Heaven!”

Beautiful! From the lips of a child!

So in the end it depends on who you’re asking and if you’re looking at this from a temporal or an eternal perspective. Alas, the most important person to ask this question to is God. Instead of asking which would hurt God the most let us flip this coin over and ask which would make God happier? What would give God the greatest glory? The answer we all know is what He told us all through that very first couple and parents to us all. “Be fruitful and multiply.”

Thanks for a great question! We will all absolutely know the answer one day very soon. Let us pray we are each ready when that day comes. Meanwhile let us love one another as Christ loves us. Please say a prayer for me! And if you really love God, please say two for me! 🙂

A big hug and kiss of peace to you all in Christ! Hope to see you on the other side!

From the least of your brethren,
John
 
It is certainly true that contraception leads to abortion, among many other evils. Contraception breaks the natural link between sex and procreation. Then it breaks the link between sex and marriage, and between marriage and children. Because contraception always has a failure rate, abortion is demanded as a matter of ‘reproductive freedom.’ The ultimate result is the breakdown of family, single mothers, fatherless children, an enabling of promiscuity, an increase of cohabitation and a lessening of marriage, and finally a breakdown of the social order as we see in many communities today.

Mary Eberstadt lays out the deleterious effects of contraception statistically, in her book “Adam and Eve After the Pill.”
 
Both are mortal sins, but the punishment for abortion is automatic excommunication.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top