Is gossiping ever moral?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ajac
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

ajac

Guest
If someone is spreading falsehoods behind my back, may I gossip about them in order to reveal the truth? Not lying but just telling people about the person behind their back because they are spreading lies so that the truth is revealed.
 
Why not just approach the person who you believe is spreading false information and politely challenge them on this?
 
Last edited:
I think you can correct people with the truth without gossiping about the other person. Why stoop to their level?
 
Gossip - casual or unconstrained conversation or reports about other people, typically involving details that are not confirmed as being true.
Click to expand...
That’s a secular definition, not a Church one, but I think it still applies here. If someone is known to be spreading falsehoods about you, correcting said falsehoods and letting someone know that what the gossiper is saying about you is false seems fine to me. I would not consider your own actions in that regard to be “gossip.”

Counter-gossip should of course be avoided.
 
Last edited:
I really doubt gossiping back would get to the truth. It would just turn into a he-said, she-said situation. As Brendan says, why not talk directly to the person gossiping and correct them?

I would say what you propose isn’t really gossip, but it will come across that way to everyone else. I would avoid it - don’t stoop to their level.
 
I agree that there are non-gossiping ways to dispel rumors.

You don’t have to get too specific, but what is the general context of the gossip? Is the rumor being spread through the workplace? Church? Extended family?

Broadly, what was the rumor about? Your personal life? Your work life?

Some gossip is the kind of thing that you can take care of publicly or through a mass email. “Dear Family or Co-Workers, I just want to clarify that despite some recent concerns, I am not/did not X, Y, or Z. I hope this clears up any misunderstandings.”

Our priest handles rumors masterfully this way at the end of Mass: "I want to reassure everyone that contrary to what you may be hearing, I am not retiring . . . "

Other times, that approach is inappropriate. So again, it will depend on context. But whatever you do, counter-gossip is the wrong way to go.
 
Maybe speak to the person spreading rumors alone, not in front of others, informing him or her of the immorality of gossip.

Jesus told us to correct someone after taking them away
 
Last edited:
Gossip doesn’t necessarily have to be lying. It is always better to go to the source first
 
If you’re talking about verifiable events that are being misrepresented, then eventually the falsehoods are going to be realized. But if you’re talking about falsehoods regarding things that are intrinsically unverifiable, then there’s nothing you can do.

If a person consents to listen to someone who is talking about you behind your back, that is because he wants to accept the gossiper’s judgement as truth.

If you attempt to correct the falsehoods, you cannot be heard, because once that person has absorbed the falsehoods as fact, he can only see and hear you through that filter. That means he won’t be capable of seeing you for who you are, only as the gossiper has chosen to present you. And because you can no longer be seen or heard, there is absolutely nothing you can do to change it.

There is simply no way to correct that kind of situation. You could sin through gossip or anger, but you still couldn’t correct it. Pray, pray, pray, pray, pray and lean very hard on Jesus.
 
Gossip is never good. There are a couple of ways to gossip, in violation of the Eighth Commandment:
by libel, slander, or calumny - telling lies about someone in order to destroy their reputation, or
by detraction - telling the truth about someone’s faults in order to destroy their reputation.

You may try to correct the falsehoods but it would be best not to tear down the source of the falsehoods while doing so. Also, try to confront and stop the source from spreading more gossip about you in the first place.

@MrsAngelala’s advice is good…you may have to simply burden this cross with humility and pray, pray, pray.
 
Could someone please provide a Catholic definition of “gossip”?
 
This is not exactly what you asked but maybe helpful, here is Fr. Grondin explaining why venting is not gossip:
  • Code: 
     Has no intention of what is said being spread to anyone else
  • Code: 
    Takes no joy in exposing someone else's fault(s)
  • Code: 
    Does not carelessly relate false or incomplete information
  • Code: 
    Seeks no harm to another's reputation
  • Code: 
    Seeks no harm to another and no exaltation of self
  • Code: 
    Takes place at an appropriate time and place with someone who can 
reasonably be trusted.
 
Last edited:
I don’t think it’s even counted as gossiping if you just want to reveal the truth to them. For example, if Person A tells Person B that you did X but you didn’t, I don’t think there’s any sin at all in you telling Person B “I didn’t do X”. Do check up the Catechism and a Priest regarding this just to confirm, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top