Is it a sin to be happy Bin Laden is dead?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hoxbar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am deeply saddened that thousands of innocent Iraqi and Afghans who had absolutely nothing to do with 9/11 had to die. They died because of American and British intervention in these countries, how will they get justice?

One man dies and people seems to rejoice, thousands die in retribution, where are our prayers for these victims?

Blessings

Eric
I disagree that thousands of innocent Iraqis and Afghans died because of American and British intervention in those countries. Follow the thread back and you’ll see that the intervention you speak of was the result of the fear and terror unleashed by Bin Laden’s diseased view of the world and of Islam. These innocent deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan should be laid at his feet and the feet of the Taliban who gave him shelter and allowed him to use Afghanistan as a base for his operations. If a child is injured when rescued from the jaws of a rabid dog, why do you blame the rescuer and slayer of the dog? Isn’t the dog more at fault for the injury than the rescuer? If you are praying for the victims in Iraq and Afghanistan, I join you in prayer. I also pray that the citizens of Iraq and Afghanistan may know a greater peace and justice than they ever knew under Saddam Hussein or the Taliban.
 
I am deeply saddened that thousands of innocent Iraqi and Afghans who had absolutely nothing to do with 9/11 had to die. They died because of American and British intervention in these countries, how will they get justice?

One man dies and people seems to rejoice, thousands die in retribution, where are our prayers for these victims?

Blessings

Eric
Seeing as all the mess recently in the Middle East would have been avoided nine years ago if 9/11 didn’t happen in the first place, I don’t think it’s fair not to hold the man accountable for those deaths too.
 
Why are people feeling relieved about this? Someone will surely take his place or extremists will retaliate.

I don’t see the point in being happy about his death. Nothing has been won, except a ransom and revenge. We are now having to increase our security.

I’m glad it proves that the extremists will never prevail, but that’s the only positive thing IMO.
 
Hello Tsuwano;
These innocent deaths in
Iraq and Afghanistan should be laid at his feet and the feet of the Taliban who gave him shelter and allowed him to use Afghanistan as a base for his operations.

When evil is repaid with evil, then more evil happens, why should thousands die in the pursuit of one man? I am not sure that the relatives of all the innocent Iraqis and Afghans killed would blame the Taliban, they are more likely to blame the invading army. These innocent victims deserve justice, but who can they go to, certainly not their own governments, they have no power over an invading army.

How would you suggest these Iraqi and Afghan victims appeal for justice, after the death of a loved one, the destruction of their property and livelihood?

Blessings

Eric
 
Most people are unwilling to take a position of non-violence, because it means they may be injured or die.

Why do we hold on so strongly to this life and justify the death of others for our own security and safety?

We should be ready to die at any moment and our whole life should be a preparation for it. That doesn’t mean we should take steps to hasten our own death, but if you truly understand and accept the teaching of Christ to “turn the other cheek,” you should not tie yourself to this life . . . prepare for the next.

I do not rejoice in the death of Bin Laden and God have mercy on my soul if I find joy in his demise. Too often I sin by being concerned about the wrongs others have done and I pray to God to help me be more humble.
 
😦 I think the joyous celebrations over this killing are barbaric. I am ashamed to see them on the news. Ashamed for America.

God hates killing and grieves over the death of the unrepentant sinner.

Osama Bin Laden’s life was a true threat to many other lives, and killing him was likely the ONLY way to save many, many other lives. Therefore the killing of Bin Laden was a necessary evil, and that’s all. The Navy Seals were simply doing their job. That those involved in that mission rejoice in a dangerous mission accomplished is understandable. But for our nation to party over it? Its a very sad reflection on a spiritual abyss in our nation.

Expressions of relief are understandable. But happy? Not appropriate.
 
Proverbs 24:17:

“Do not rejoice when your enemy falls, and let not your heart be glad when he stumbles; lest the Lord see it, and be displeased, and turn away his anger from him…”
Ah but
Proverbs 21:15 says
“The exercise of justice is joy for the righteous, But is terror to the workers of iniquity.”

To me I see the sense of *relief *we experience as a nation as a sense of justice much like we read about from David in many of the Psalms. I don’t believe we are as much happy and exultant as we are relieved althoug many of us think of this feeling as happy.
 
😦 I think the joyous celebrations over this killing are barbaric. I am ashamed to see them on the news. Ashamed for America.

God hates killing and grieves over the death of the unrepentant sinner.

Osama Bin Laden’s life was a true threat to many other lives, and killing him was likely the ONLY way to save many, many other lives. Therefore the killing of Bin Laden was a necessary evil, and that’s all. The Navy Seals were simply doing their job. That those involved in that mission rejoice in a dangerous mission accomplished is understandable. But for our nation to party over it? Its a very sad reflection on a spiritual abyss in our nation.

Expressions of relief are understandable. But happy? Not appropriate.
👍 Agreed. I was utterly shocked to see the street parties happening over in the States on TV - as if Bin Laden’s death means anything in the long term. Your soldiers are still fighting in the Middle East, nothing is over yet, so why all the celebrations again? 😦
 
Ah but
Proverbs 21:15 says
“The exercise of justice is joy for the righteous, But is terror to the workers of iniquity.”

To me I see the sense of *relief *we experience as a nation as a sense of justice much like we read about from David in many of the Psalms. I don’t believe we are as much happy and exultant as we are relieved althoug many of us think of this feeling as happy.
Thank you , for this post YankeeRC.
I felt Bin Laden, knew when he faced those Navy Seals , that his time had come to pay the price for the evil he had done, had caused, and the true feeling, of most people, was a sense of justice. God will judge Bin Laden as He will all of us! Peace, Carlan
 
👍 Agreed. I was utterly shocked to see the street parties happening over in the States on TV - as if Bin Laden’s death means anything in the long term. Your soldiers are still fighting in the Middle East, nothing is over yet, so why all the celebrations again? 😦
Yes, its terrible. So what, ONE truly evil person is down. We cannot kill off all the evil in the world! It will rise up elsewhere! We can only turn to God for mercy.

LemonandLime! You are a brand new convert from England! How wonderful. I think I read somewhere that Catholics in England now surpass Anglicans? Can that POSSIBLY be true? I must have read it wrong!

I just thoroughly enjoyed the Royal Wedding - a far more worthy a cause of celebration IMO! Its about love and life. And marriage is a Holy Sacrament! Killing is not. Yes, our “celebrations” compared to yours are a bit shocking, and distasteful.

Just please know its only a small group of well-publicized people partying over this! I think they are making a big deal of magnifying that with ridiculous media coverage because something useful actually happened during Obama’s reign, and with re-election coming up they think this is their only hope for garnering some votes from the right.

Nobody does pageantry and royalty like England. I think we all love it because we long for the glory of the Kingship of God. It is a gorgeous earthly example of kingliness - which is our destiny in the Eternal Kingdom of God, where we will have the joy of worshiping the true King and exalting the humble and beloved Queen that He has exalted, for all of eternity!

I loved how the Westminster wedding ceremony was very close to Catholic, and is presented as a Sacrament. Exteriorly, such wonderful perfection! Perfection on earth is a shadow of what our hearts know we will experience in Heaven some day. Many flaws can be found of course, such as the once Catholic Cathedral has been Anglican since King Henry VIII! The most glaring flaw to the Sacramental Royal Wedding is we all know that William and Catherine have lived with each other before marriage. However, overlooking that, you can see the outline of how things should really be.

Lemonandlime, guess what? - I am setting up my workspace to complete an oil painting of lemons and limes this month! (its to be a wedding present for a couple choosing those colors for their kitchen…).

Sorry for the off-topic ramble…
 
I don’t think it’s a sin to be glad that Osama Bin Laden, and his efforts for evil are now gone from the world. That justice has been meted out, and that hopefully the resolute pursuit of justice, however delayed will dissuade others from following that path. Remember that after the US went into Iraq, Iran and Libya both became far more cooperative in terms of allowing nuclear inspectors, giving up material etc. It was when the west waivered and began arguing amongst themselves that Iran turned back towards it’s nuclear ambitions.

“If there’s one thing there’s no shortage of in this world it’s people. And if some of them can’t behave themselves, we’re better off without them.” Donald Hamilton (not sure it’s exact) I believe the world is better off without OSL and his influence.

However, I believe hoping or rejoicing in someone’s eternal damnation is a sin. Just as heaven rejoices at the return of a sinner to God, I think we all should feel sadness at the concept of someone rejecting Him. I gain nothing from OSL being in hell, not one single thing, and his entering paradise with God eventually, if God shows him that mercy for whatever reason, takes nothing from me. None of us deserve or earn salvation, it is a gift to be accepted from God, and I won’t question His giving that gift to anyone as I hope to receive it, even if it is in the last moment’s of this life.
 
I’ve seen plenty of moralizing on the internet chastising people for “rejoicing in bin Laden’s death” from the usual suspects who never seem to tire of lecturing the great unwashed masses.

If he had been captured and not killed, would it have been okay to be happy then?

Have you ever seen film or photos of people celebrating V-E day and V-J day at the end of WWII? Were those people rejoicing about the death of millions of Germans and Japanese? Ever seen a military parade?
 
Yes, its terrible. So what, ONE truly evil person is down. We cannot kill off all the evil in the world! It will rise up elsewhere! We can only turn to God for mercy.
Amen to that.
LemonandLime! You are a brand new convert from England! How wonderful. I think I read somewhere that Catholics in England now surpass Anglicans? Can that POSSIBLY be true? I must have read it wrong!
I’m not sure if that’s true or not, possibly there are more practicing Catholics than practicing Anglicans, especially now that the Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham has joined us. 🙂
I just thoroughly enjoyed the Royal Wedding - a far more worthy a cause of celebration IMO! Its about love and life. And marriage is a Holy Sacrament! Killing is not. Yes, our “celebrations” compared to yours are a bit shocking, and distasteful.
Just please know its only a small group of well-publicized people partying over this! I think they are making a big deal of magnifying that with ridiculous media coverage because something useful actually happened during Obama’s reign, and with re-election coming up they think this is their only hope for garnering some votes from the right.
It is true it’s a good publicity boost for Obama. I think it’s just a bad coincidence that we had very opposite celebrations on each side of the pond. The wedding was very beautiful - I slept through the live coverage as I had just finished a night shift but I watched the highlights. 🙂
Nobody does pageantry and royalty like England. I think we all love it because we long for the glory of the Kingship of God. It is a gorgeous earthly example of kingliness - which is our destiny in the Eternal Kingdom of God, where we will have the joy of worshiping the true King and exalting the humble and beloved Queen that He has exalted, for all of eternity!
I loved how the Westminster wedding ceremony was very close to Catholic, and is presented as a Sacrament. Exteriorly, such wonderful perfection! Perfection on earth is a shadow of what our hearts know we will experience in Heaven some day. Many flaws can be found of course, such as the once Catholic Cathedral has been Anglican since King Henry VIII! The most glaring flaw to the Sacramental Royal Wedding is we all know that William and Catherine have lived with each other before marriage. However, overlooking that, you can see the outline of how things should really be.
Lemonandlime, guess what? - I am setting up my workspace to complete an oil painting of lemons and limes this month! (its to be a wedding present for a couple choosing those colors for their kitchen…).
Sorry for the off-topic ramble…
We are very fond of our Queen over here indeed 🙂 unlike politicians, she doesn’t change and isn’t in a constant power struggle and PR battle. Well, you could say she is but perhaps you could trust what she says more than our Prime Minister if you know what I mean. The wedding was a very beautiful ceremony, and yes I was surprised that they lived together before getting married. :confused:

Ooh and very good 👍 I do love lemons and limes!
 
Hello Tsuwano;

When evil is repaid with evil, then more evil happens, why should thousands die in the pursuit of one man? I am not sure that the relatives of all the innocent Iraqis and Afghans killed would blame the Taliban, they are more likely to blame the invading army. These innocent victims deserve justice, but who can they go to, certainly not their own governments, they have no power over an invading army.

How would you suggest these Iraqi and Afghan victims appeal for justice, after the death of a loved one, the destruction of their property and livelihood?

Blessings

Eric
Actually, from what I understand, many of the families of innocent victims killed in Afghanistan and Iraq do indeed blame the Taliban and the opposition in those countries. Many of their family members were killed by suicide bombers and roadside bombs targeting those innocents. As for those who are accidentally killed by coalition forces, there are ways in which their families can be compensated to some degree for their losses. Granted, this is not enough to cure their grief, but it is more than they are offered by the Taliban. I agree that evil is not cured by evil, but sometimes it can be slowed by justice. The pursuit of Bin Laden is not nearly as important as the development of democratic and stable institutions in the area, but that doesn’t mean Bin Laden and Al Quada should not be hunted.
 
Tsuwano;
Actually, from what I understand, many of the families of innocent victims killed in Afghanistan and Iraq do indeed blame the Taliban and the opposition in those countries. Many of their family members were killed by suicide bombers and roadside bombs targeting those innocents.
I don’t know the rights and wrongs of the conflict in Iraq, but if America and Britain invaded, then they should have left Iraq a better country than before the invasion. Why else should they invade a country?

This does not appear to be the case, Iraq seems to be in a worse state now than it was before the invasion, and it seemed bad then. The Taliban might be responsible for some of the killings now, but it seems they flourish because Britain and America destabilised their country enabling them to exist more fully now

Blessings and peace be with you

Eric
 
I don’t know the rights and wrongs of the conflict in Iraq, but if America and Britain invaded, then they should have left Iraq a better country than before the invasion. Why else should they invade a country?

This does not appear to be the case, Iraq seems to be in a worse state now than it was before the invasion, and it seemed bad then. The Taliban might be responsible for some of the killings now, but it seems they flourish because Britain and America destabilised their country enabling them to exist more fully now

Blessings and peace be with you

Eric
This is a matter of judgement, isn’t it? Many Iraqis seem to feel that their country is better off without Saddam Hussein and his sons in charge. Is there still conflict within Iraq? Yes, certainly, but there are also free elections and a government which attempts to rule according to law and not by decree. The same holds for Afghanistan. Afghanistan was a destabalized country long before the U.S. or Britain got involved and the Taliban, by the fact that it allowed Bin Laden to freely hatch terrorist plots within Afghanistan, cannot be seen as a stabalizing force. There is conflict going on in Afghanistan now. How things will turn out in the long run is still a guess, but it is debatable as to whether the present conditions in the country are worse than they were before. And besides, certain scenarios were not options for nations which suffered as the result of Al Qaeda. Leaving Bin Laden and Afghanistan alone so that terrorism could continue was not an option. This is the reason the Taliban was overthrown.
 
I don’t know if it is a “sin” to be happy that Bin Laden is dead, but I think one’s reaction to that news reflects how they were affected by how Bin Laden lived his life. My reaction to the news when I heard it was, “Wow! Have mercy on his soul.” And I admit I felt a little fear for him (Bin Laden), you know that feeling you get in the pit of your stomach, facing God with all that he did in the last 20 years.

My compassion also goes out hugely to the survivors of 9/11 and the loved ones of those killed because they are not getting the feelings of satisfaction that they imagined they would at this news. My father was killed in a terrorist bombing in Beirut in 1983 and I remember being told that the planners of the bombing were all killed either during or after interrogation by the Lebanese. There was no feeling of satisfaction or happiness at the news. My father was still dead and I still missed him terribly. I didn’t allow myself to know Christ back then so I took no comfort from Him. I hope the people still feeling the pain from their loss caused by Bin Laden allow the comfort of Christ to ease their pain.

I think any who rejoice at the death of this man might pray and ask for guidance in this matter. And remember that Christ told us to pray for our enemies.
 
Bin Laden’s death has unmasked a very ugly side of Catholics in America. This is a sad day. I believe that it’s very important that we look at each one very carefully, not judging other, but examining our conscience, not someone else’s.
  1. We’re gloating. Since when is it Christ-like to gloat over the death of anyone? Can you imagine Bl. John Paul or Pope Benedict XVI gloating over the death of Adolf Hitler? They lived under his regime. I am reminded of my Franciscan brother, St. Maximilian Kolbe who never uttered a word against the Nazis and who encouraged his fellow inmates not to say anything negative about them, but to love them and pray for them. I remember my own Holy Father, Francis having been a prisoner of war and showing every sign of respect toward those who held him and his comrades hostage without knowing if they were going to live or die. I can’t imagine the Holy Apostles gloating over the death of the Caesars who tortured and killed the early Christians. Those who are gloating are certainly not doing any honor to our Catholic heritage.
  2. We’re setting a very bad example for other Americans. Our actions are saying, “Osama hurt America, but we finally got him back.” What are we telling our children and Americans of other faiths? We’re saying that it’s OK to want revenge. But is this true? Justice and revenge are not the same thing.
  3. We setting a horrible example for the younger generation and then we blame their coolness toward the faith on Vatican II and the new form of the mass. The fact is that we’re teaching our young that we’re Americans you just happen to be Catholic. Very few Catholics in America want to know if this death was unavoidable. Yet, this is an essential moral question. The moral law says that one may never take a life, even that of a criminal, as long as there is another way of disabling him so that he cannot do any more harm to innocent people. What we’re saying is that whatever happened is OK, because we’re America and we can do it. Well, just because we can do something does not mean that we should do something. Osama was able to kill 3,000 people in 2001. That did not make it right.
  4. We’re assuming that this man is in hell. What right have we to assume such a thing? Since when does the Church say that someone is in hell? We can say with certainty when someone is in heaven, but we commend the souls of the sinner to the mercy of God. Not to do so is a lack of charity on our part. This lack of charity begs the question, are we truly Catholic? Isn’t praying for the dead one of our spiritual duties? Or do we only pray for our dead?
  5. We’re being Americans first and Catholics second. I have seen posts on the News Forum of CAF that claim that all is fair in love and war and some things are more fair in war. That’s not true. All is not fair in war. We know that many armies and many nations have committed crimes against humanity in times of war. However, we believe that it’s OK to call other nations to task, but we see no need to call our own to task. The fact is that if our government and those who gave the orders in this situation acted within the moral law, there is nothing to worry about. If they violated the moral law, then it is our duty as citizens, to use the gift of democracy that God has given us to call our leaders on the carpet.
  6. Bin Laden committed horrible crimes against humanity. The nations of the world had every right to find him and disable him to protect the innocent. Terrorism has no place in civilized society. It constitutes a grave sin and injustice to cause the world to live in fear. We must be very careful not to harshly condemn our government or any other government for wanting to capture him. It was the right thing to do, because he needed to be stopped. Those who are critical of this action are as morally poor as those who gloat. The more powerful nations of the world have a moral duty to the less powerful to help protect the world from men like Bin Laden. It’s unfair not to give the US government its proper recognition for its effort. We have to be balanced.
  7. Finally, Catholics in the USA must remember that we are Catholics first and Americans second. The law of the Church trumps the law of the land. At the 11th hour, it is the Church who can say to us “Your sins are forgiven”. The State has no such power. If we want that forgiveness on our deathbed, then we have to show that we are in communion with the Church, not just look to her when we’re in trouble. The Church is not a utility that we call on when we need her and then shove her in a closet when we’re doing well. And the government is not above the Church. The last time I checked, the Bride of Christ is the Church, not the USA. We need to learn to listen to the Church’s moral guidance on these questions.
Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Thank you Br. JR for your response that outlines the teachings of Christ and His Church. I always look forward to your posts as they are common sense, charitable and always in line with the teaching of the Magisterium.

Peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top