Is it a sin to wish hell upon an enemy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornInMarch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Did any of you read my original post, or did you just read the title and jump to comment?

I’ve seen almost everybody here say a variation of “No, you have to forgive or else you’ll go to Hell too!” and yet almost none of you provide elaboration or further explanation. Even worse than that is that almost none of you spoke with any understanding or empathy for one who feels anger, acting as though you’ve never felt anger before or as though you would honestly be able to forgive an enemy even if he killed your spouse and experienced neither punishment nor remorse. Self-righteousness doesn’t make you holy.

Only a single person even acknowledged the psalm quotes I listed which outright ask God to take lethal vengeance, and nobody really addressed them. Psalm 58 outright says that the righteous will wash their feet in the blood of the wicked, and calls that a reward from God. Psalm 83 asks for God to make the wicked perish in disgrace. Deuteronomy 32:35 has God telling us that he will take revenge and that destruction rushes upon wrongdoers, and uses a tone that suggests we should take comfort in this. Additionally there is a large wealth of Old Testament verses about God punishing the wicked.

So are the writers of these bible verses liars?
 
…Even worse than that is that almost none of you spoke with any understanding or empathy for one who feels anger, acting as though you’ve never felt anger before or as though you would honestly be able to forgive an enemy even if he killed your spouse and experienced neither punishment nor remorse. Self-righteousness doesn’t make you holy.
It is not self-righteous to offer an answer to the question objectively.

Were you in some doubt about the question of empathy? I would have thought that all of us can simultaneously empathise with the person who has been wronged and - at least for a time - harbours hatred and a desire for vengeance, and yet recognise that there is nothing “good” in desiring harm to others.

Wiser folks than I would need to address the Old Testament questions.
 
It is not self-righteous to offer an answer to the question objectively.
No, but it is self-righteous to not acknowledge the difficulty in it. Claiming to be without sin is the worst kind of pride; only Jesus can make that claim.
Were you in some doubt about the question of empathy? I would have thought that all of us can simultaneously empathise with the person who has been wronged and - at least for a time - harbours hatred and a desire for vengeance, and yet recognise that there is nothing “good” in desiring harm to others.
Yes, I am in doubt about that. I know from firsthand experience that forgiveness isn’t always possible, and that sometimes you can try and try and not get any closer to that.
Wiser folks than I would need to address the Old Testament questions.
Well at least you admit to not knowing everything. That’s better than some people.
 
No, but it is self-righteous to not acknowledge the difficulty in it.
I quoted the questions from the OP that I was answering in Post #19, and those questions did not probe the question of whether doing the right thing is difficult. You asked some objective questions in a dispassionate manner, not revealing any personal dimension, and now criticise my response for being similarly dispassionate and for not addressing your (unrevealed) personal struggle!
Claiming to be without sin is the worst kind of pride; only Jesus can make that claim.
Has someone made that claim? Certainly I made no such claim - so your assertion is a straw man.
 
Yes. It would be a grave sin to wish hell upon someone. Remember, the Bible tells us that we can kill someone in our heart like we can commit adultery in our hearts. God loves all His creation. At the very least, we should view our neighbors as Jesus and love them. It can be extremely difficult at times, but hey, God forgives our sins, and I know I committed more than I can count.
 
I see that I made a mistake posting this here; why on Earth did I ever think it was a good idea to ask if something was a sin on this forum? The answer is always yes; because merely existing is a mortal sin according to the people here. Even your thoughts can send you to hell, even if they aren’t don’t effect actions.

A large amount of the people here think that everything is a mortal sin, that they alone are going to heaven, and that we are obliged to fight tooth and nail against our every instinct and feeling.

I didn’t get a variety of different opinions, I didn’t get any new explanations (the few explanations I got were small and most people have no explanation to justify their answers), and i am not sure of a single person even tried to explain how the two psalms I listed are accounted for in their answer.
 
I see that I made a mistake posting this here; why on Earth did I ever think it was a good idea to ask if something was a sin on this forum? The answer is always yes;
In your OP, you didn’t ask about personal sin, but whether a certain behaviour is “ethical” or “acceptable”. Objective questions to which mostly objective answers were given.
Because merely existing is a mortal sin according to the people here.
Noone said that.
Even your thoughts can send you to hell, even if they aren’t don’t effect actions.
One can sin in their thoughts. "I confess to almighty God and to you, my brothers and sisters, that I have greatly sinned* in my thoughts *and in my words, in what I have done and what I have failed to do…"
A large amount of the people here think that everything is a mortal sin…
It is grossly erroneous to suggest that all immoral acts constitute serious sin. If you see some make an erroneous claim of that kind, better to point it out specifically.
…that they alone are going to heaven, and that we are obliged to fight tooth and nail against our every instinct and feeling.
Noone made these claims.
I didn’t get a variety of different opinions,
Readers had broadly the same opinion given the subject and “yes/no” nature of your question. 🤷
I didn’t get any new explanations (the few explanations I got were small and most people have no explanation to justify their answers)
I suppose explanations hardly seemed necessary. We are called to Love our Neighbour, and while that is not prescriptive, it is directional. How could desiring ill for a person be in alignment with that call?
…and I am not sure of a single person even tried to explain how the two psalms I listed are accounted for in their answer.
Well I guess we stand condemned for our lack of Scriptural insight. Perhaps you could post specifically on that point in the Scripture Forum?

Perhaps you posed your question in fact seeking comfort that some ill will you are holding onto is “understandable” (it may well be), or somehow “good” (it is not), or will not be held against you by God (no one here can answer that). If the matter is deeply personal for your, then you really ought to seek counsel from your Priest.
 
Did any of you read my original post, or did you just read the title and jump to comment?

I’ve seen almost everybody here say a variation of “No, you have to forgive or else you’ll go to Hell too!” and yet almost none of you provide elaboration or further explanation. Even worse than that is that almost none of you spoke with any understanding or empathy for one who feels anger, acting as though you’ve never felt anger before or as though you would honestly be able to forgive an enemy even if he killed your spouse and experienced neither punishment nor remorse. Self-righteousness doesn’t make you holy.

Only a single person even acknowledged the psalm quotes I listed which outright ask God to take lethal vengeance, and nobody really addressed them. Psalm 58 outright says that the righteous will wash their feet in the blood of the wicked, and calls that a reward from God. Psalm 83 asks for God to make the wicked perish in disgrace. Deuteronomy 32:35 has God telling us that he will take revenge and that destruction rushes upon wrongdoers, and uses a tone that suggests we should take comfort in this. Additionally there is a large wealth of Old Testament verses about God punishing the wicked.

So are the writers of these bible verses liars?
The writers of the scripture verses were not liars, they just had a different understanding of God before the Incarnation. The verse where God says “I am holier than Thou” should provide a clue to some people’s self-righteousness, as God is the only one who IS actually “Holier than thou”.

God had to bring His Chosen people to a level of spiritual consciousness where He could reveal himself in the Incarnation without being rejected as his many prophets were beforehand. This is the meaning behind the Parable of the Wicked Tenants. There was a suggestion in the New Testament which echoes these old sentiments: James and John called to Christ to send down fire and brimstone from heaven to punish the villagers in a town in Samaria for not being responsive to the words of Christ, and were given the name “Sons of Thunder” as a result. God transformed them into great men, which is really what we are all called to be, to channel our anger and vengefulness into love for God and for those who persecute us. The men of old, for some reason, were unable or unwilling to do so, and couldn’t receive the true message of mercy hidden in the Torah.
 
The writers of the scripture verses were not liars, they just had a different understanding of God before the Incarnation. The verse where God says “I am holier than Thou” should provide a clue to some people’s self-righteousness, as God is the only one who IS actually “Holier than thou”.

God had to bring His Chosen people to a level of spiritual consciousness where He could reveal himself in the Incarnation without being rejected as his many prophets were beforehand. This is the meaning behind the Parable of the Wicked Tenants. There was a suggestion in the New Testament which echoes these old sentiments: James and John called to Christ to send down fire and brimstone from heaven to punish the villagers in a town in Samaria for not being responsive to the words of Christ, and were given the name “Sons of Thunder” as a result. God transformed them into great men, which is really what we are all called to be, to channel our anger and vengefulness into love for God and for those who persecute us. The men of old, for some reason, were unable or unwilling to do so, and couldn’t receive the true message of mercy hidden in the Torah.
Thanks for actually addressing the things I brought up. Most of the others on this thread simply decided to ignore the verses. I’m glad you’re actually thinking about it.

Though I must admit that I am not entirely convinced by what you have said. There are actually lots of bible verses about asking God to hurt your enemies; in the book of Psalms alone there are 19 Imprecatory Psalms. The Old Testament still counts; Jesus said in 5:17 that he’s not overturning the Old Testament. And even in the New Testament imprecatory verses appear. In Matthew 11:20-24, Jesus tells three towns that they are going to go to Hell for ignoring his miracles. In Matthew 23:13, Jesus tells the Pharisees that they are going to Hell for their hypocrisy. In Revelation 6:10-11, all the martyrs ask God when he is going to avenge them and instead of refusing to he simply tells them to wait a little bit longer. Then Revelation ends with the damned being cast into Hell, and this is treated not as a tragedy but as something the righteous can take comfort in. And outside of the bible some saints and theologians (such as Saint Aquinas, who himself was a hell-bound sinner prior to his conversion) even claimed that part of heaven will be knowing that the damned are in Hell.

These parts of the bible about Mercy and Loving Your Enemies seems irreconcilable with the parts of the bible about Divine Fury and Praying Harm Upon Your Enemies, but because we are Christians we have to accept them both.
 
If we genuinely understood Hell, it is said, we would not wish that anybody should go there.

ICXC NIKA
Exactly…

Jesus - Who forgave from the Cross - said we should pray for everyone. Therefore, we can know that forgiveness does NOT include wishing hell on anyone. We KNOW the sheep/goats, wheat/tares will be permanently separated at the end of time because Jesus said this would be so. But He ALSO said we are to pray for our enemies, which tells me that we should all be praying that the number of goats/tares is as small as possible.
 
Exactly…

Jesus - Who forgave from the Cross - said we should pray for everyone. Therefore, we can know that forgiveness does NOT include wishing hell on anyone. We KNOW the sheep/goats, wheat/tares will be permanently separated at the end of time because Jesus said this would be so. But He ALSO said we are to pray for our enemies, which tells me that we should all be praying that the number of goats/tares is as small as possible.
If this is the case, then why do so many of the Psalms pray for God to torture and kill the wicked? Why does revelations have a scene where all the martyrs ask God to take revenge on their behalf?
 
If this is the case, then why do so many of the Psalms pray for God to torture and kill the wicked? Why does revelations have a scene where all the martyrs ask God to take revenge on their behalf?
Have you posted that question in the scripture forum? Then put a link here when done.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top