J
JimR-OCDS
Guest
Existing in the mind of God is only thought, not the soul.You are absolutely correct. You cannot apply physical properties to a metaphysical reality. And this physical world is not the “real” world… the spiritual world is, because it is a world that is beyond the one we are living in right now. If there was a massive black hole that swallowed up the entire physical universe as we know it, the spiritual world would still live on, because it is not dependent on the physical world to exist. Same goes for us. We continue to live on in spirit after our body dies… our spirit is not dependent on our body to live, but the same cannot be said vice versa. So… existing in God’s mind for all eternity certainly means that you did exist prior to having a body in the form of a soul/spirit… and your soul/spirit was placed into a body before birth. So saying that you didn’t exist at all prior to having a body is a false statement. Exisiting even in mind or idea is still existing.
The Church teaches that there must be material, the flesh, when the soul is created.
A friend of mine tried to interpret the Catechism of the Catholic Church in a way that we existed spiritually, before conception. A theologian we consulted corrected him.
That all being said, you seem to be on the right track in that God dwells within us. We become one with God, as we move toward union with him, but he still remains God, and we his creatures.
Jim