Is masturbation not sinful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dallas_r
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Welcome to a preview of the new CAF starting in September!
Thank you for the warm welcome. I have invited all of my fellow Asians to join in the effort to convert them. Yes, I actually am Asian and no it has nothing to do with the joke I made earlier.
 
You are a very wise and generally kind and witty poster I have enjoyed reading for years, and rarely disagree with, however I feel I must stand up here a bit for the way we raised our boys and also for having them read the Catechism of the Catholic church which does in fact give some leniency in this sin based on immaturity.

If you have had a child with scrupulosity and anxiety then you will know what I am talking about and NO driving those boys, especially one of them to church three times a week to confession was not an amazing thing and exercise in piety it was awful. Yes, our family also went to counseling and saw a priest as well, however the Catechism was a part of what we taught as I referenced in my original post.

The Catholic church does in fact teach that not all masturbation is mortally sinful and to certain people the circumstances may mitigate their culpability. This is not the first thing I would teach a child, but it is certainly showing mercy to tell it to a child with scrupulosity that is suffering horribly that they are fine, rather than letting them think they are damned.
I hesitated responding because I wish these threads would die. But I owe you a response.
You are right. I have no idea the situation you were in. And I believe you are a wonderful parent. In a general sense I disagree with some aspects you wrote.
HOWEVER… I’m not you. I’m not privy to the intimate details if your family.
Would I have handled the same? I don’t know. Maybe. Or maybe I would have handled worse or better. I really should have left out the part about driving the kids. I should try to keep this discussion in “generalities” and not have made it situational by singling you out like that. We all bring experiences to the table. I have mostly girls who aren’t teens yet. My four year old boy hears “don’t touch your thing” multiple times a day. And that’s just non sexual! You have the advantage of have no gone through it. And the should respect that. However I had the advantage of being a teen boy pervert with hands off parents who were not religious…😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top