Is Matthias an Apostle?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adrift
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What the Holy Father says never rises to that critical level of calling Matthias an Apostle.
Popes do refer to Matthias as an Apostle. Naturally, as the Church celebrates liturgically (as others have noted) the Feast of Matthias, Apostle.

vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/audiences/2006/documents/hf_ben-xvi_aud_20060510_en.html

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/alpha/data/aud19890125en.html

Also, there are Catholic parishes names for St. Matthias, Apostle (not just St. Matthias).

You can interpret Acts 1:26 however you want to, but clearly Church tradition considers Matthias an Apostle.
 
Quote:

quote:
I have no idea as to what is in your mind. However, from what you have posted here it appears that reason and logic are in short supply.

. As for Matthias being made a bishop I have already made my case quoting the Holy Father. The Holy Father I quoted was the first one, Peter. He said it in Acts 1:20 when he quoted the Psalm, “Let another take his office.” The word translated as "office is episkope which means office of bishop. Do you see where Peter makes a distinction between Judas’ office and his house [habitation] No one can take over his house but another can take over his office of bishop.
You ignore the title
Judas Iscariot and Matthias

Which gives who the piece is about
The Pope identifies Judas as an apostle
we cannot fail to mention the one who has always been named last in the list of the Twelve
The Pope than says that Matthias has replaced Judas
Judas Iscariot. We want to associate him with the person who is later elected to substitute him, Matthias.
It must be remembered that there were 12 apostles for a reason. The twelve represented the twelve tribes. It is why they had to elect someone to replace Judas.
Though modern bishops succeed the apostles as the highest shepherds of the Church, and though they belong to unbroken lines of ordination going back to the hands of the apostles themselves, the office of bishop is not identical to the office of apostle. If it were, Christ would not have allowed the apostles to disappear from the scene but would have continued to appear to and commission new apostles for the Church. There are differences between the offices of bishop and apostle:
No, it is not a personal attack. I don’t know you from Adam. All I know is what you post and it is your posts that seem to have a sparcity of logic and reason
Because this adds nothing to your argument it is an ad homine attack.

It does make me wonder if you know what logic is.
You do know that logic is if then statements even if only implied?

If Judas was called an apostle and Matthias replaced him, then Matthias is an apostle is an logical statement. This is the statement that those who know that he was an apostle are saying to you.
 
Popes do refer to Matthias as an Apostle. Naturally, as the Church celebrates liturgically (as others have noted) the Feast of Matthias, Apostle.

vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/audiences/2006/documents/hf_ben-xvi_aud_20060510_en.html

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/alpha/data/aud19890125en.html

Also, there are Catholic parishes names for St. Matthias, Apostle (not just St. Matthias).

You can interpret Acts 1:26 however you want to, but clearly Church tradition considers Matthias an Apostle.
The liturgical calendar has been dealt with before. It has not remained constant over time. New saints are added while others like St. Christopher are dropped. As such it hardly is an example of inerrant Church teaching.

As for parishes named for St. Matthias that only stands to reason. Parishes are usually named for the saint on whose feast day the parish was formed. Any parish formed on the feast day of St. Matthias would be named for him and thus we are back to the liturgical calendar.

As for church tradition that is not to be confused with Apostolic Tradition which is composed of the Written Tradition [Holy Scripture] and the Oral Tradition. No one has provided any proof from either of these sources that says of Matthias what Apostolic Tradition says of Paul. Again I reiterate. Scripture unequivically calls Paul an Apostle no less than thirteen times. Scripture does not unequivically call Matthias an Apostle even once. As for Acts 1:26 being counted or numbered with the apostles is not the same as being one of the apostles. There were eleven apostles before Matthias was selected and Acts 1:26 says there were still eleven apostles after he was selected. Well I don’t know where you all learned mathematics but the good sisters taught me that 11+1=12 not 11.
 
The liturgical calendar has been dealt with before. It has not remained constant over time. New saints are added while others like St. Christopher are dropped. As such it hardly is an example of inerrant Church teaching.
It is not just the calendar, but the liturgy associated with the calendar. Do you have reason to expect the Church will drop St Matthias (or his designation as “Apostle”) because of dubious historicity, a la St Christopher? :confused:

Do you expect the Church to alter her liturgy (with emphases added)?

Opening Prayer
*Deus, qui beatum Matthiam
Code:
Apostolorum collegio
sociasti, eius nobis interventione concede, ut, dilectionis tuae sorte gaudentes, cum electis numerari mereamur. Per Dominum nostrum Iesum Christum, Filium tuum, qui tecum vivit et regnat in unitate Spiritus Sancti, Deus, per omnia saecula saeculorum.*
Father, you called St. Matthias to share in the
Code:
mission of the apostles
.
By the help of his prayers may we receive with joy the love you share with us and be counted among those you have chosen.
We ask this through our Lord Jesus Christ, your Son, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever.

Prayer Over the Gifts
Lord, accept the gifts your Church offers on the feast of
Code:
the apostle, Matthias
, and by this eucharist strengthen your grace within us.
We ask this through Christ our Lord.

Prayer After Communion
Lord, you constantly give life to your people in this holy eucharist.
By the prayers of
Code:
the apostle Matthias
prepare us to take our place among your saints in eternal life.
We ask this through Christ our Lord.

Yes, the Church *can *alter any or all of these – But is there reason to expect her to do so?

:hmmm:
tee
 
This is the type of logic I see from typical Catholics. It really is no logic. In addition it is wrong and it contradicts Church doctrine. Now apply this same logic to any other apostle, Like Peter. Linus was the replacement for Peter. Was Linus an Apostle too? If one follows the logic of Rosary Fan he has to be but the church does not teach that. The Church teaches that Peter’s replacement was a bishop not an Apostle. Same is true for all the other apostles.
“Apostle is derived from the Greek word, pronounced ap-os-tol-os, which means messenger, or ambassador. Although the term is most often used to describe The Twelve Apostles, certain others, including Paul (see On The Road To Damascus) and Barnabas, were also designated as apostles according to God’s purpose at a given time.”

So, again, I say… Yes, Matthias was an apostle.

Thank you for calling me a typical Catholic. 😃
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by inkaneer
This is the type of logic I see from typical Catholics. It really is no logic. In addition it is wrong and it contradicts Church doctrine. Now apply this same logic to any other apostle, Like Peter. Linus was the replacement for Peter. Was Linus an Apostle too? If one follows the logic of Rosary Fan he has to be but the church does not teach that. The Church teaches that Peter’s replacement was a bishop not an Apostle. Same is true for all the other apostles.
“Apostle is derived from the Greek word, pronounced ap-os-tol-os, which means messenger, or ambassador. Although the term is most often used to describe The Twelve Apostles, certain others, including Paul (see On The Road To Damascus) and Barnabas, were also designated as apostles according to God’s purpose at a given time.”
This is old stuff that was rebuked on the other thread entitled “First Pope”. The Greek word apostolos means “one who is sent”. When applied to the group known as the TWELVE APOSTLES it refers to those Twelve who were called and sent by Jesus. . Only eleven of the original twelve called to be Apostles were sent by Jesus. Judas was called but never sent. Matthias was never called nor sent. Paul was both called and sent by Jesus. Those other so called 'apostles, like Barnabas were never sent by Jesus. Indeed the Eastern Churches differentiate between the Twelve Apostles and the 70 disciples sent out by Jesus with very limited authority referring to the seventy disciples as the ‘minor apostles’.
"So, again, I say… Yes, Matthias was an apostle.
You can say it all you want. But Matthias was not an Apostle of Jesus Christ. Church teaching [from the CCC] says there are twelve apostles. Scripture [Rev 21:14 also says there are 12 apostles. Scripture definitely calls Paul an apostle 13 times and Matthias 0 times.
"Thank you for calling me a typical Catholic. 😃
You are most welcome to it. But given the state of typical Catholics today it is not something to brag about. By the way you are not Roman Catholic unless you are a member of the diocese of Rome. You are Catholic, more specifically a Latin Rite Catholic. Roman Catholic was a derogatory term created by the English of King Henry VIII’s day to rally support for the Church of England headed by the English monarch versus the Catholic Church headed by a foreign sovereign, the pope in Rome. It played on the sense of Nationalism that was growing at that time. Another such derogatory term used to refer to Catholics was ‘papists’. Both of them are still in use in protestantism.
 
It is not just the calendar, but the liturgy associated with the calendar. Do you have reason to expect the Church will drop St Matthias (or his designation as “Apostle”) because of dubious historicity, a la St Christopher? :confused:

Do you expect the Church to alter her liturgy (with emphases added)?

Opening Prayer
*Deus, qui beatum Matthiam
Code:
Apostolorum collegio
sociasti, eius nobis interventione concede, ut, dilectionis tuae sorte gaudentes, cum electis numerari mereamur. Per Dominum nostrum Iesum Christum, Filium tuum, qui tecum vivit et regnat in unitate Spiritus Sancti, Deus, per omnia saecula saeculorum.*
Father, you called St. Matthias to share in the
Code:
mission of the apostles
.
By the help of his prayers may we receive with joy the love you share with us and be counted among those you have chosen.
We ask this through our Lord Jesus Christ, your Son, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever.

Prayer Over the Gifts
Lord, accept the gifts your Church offers on the feast of
Code:
the apostle, Matthias
, and by this eucharist strengthen your grace within us.
We ask this through Christ our Lord.

Prayer After Communion
Lord, you constantly give life to your people in this holy eucharist.
By the prayers of
Code:
the apostle Matthias
prepare us to take our place among your saints in eternal life.
We ask this through Christ our Lord.

Yes, the Church *can *alter any or all of these – But is there reason to expect her to do so?

:hmmm:
tee
I can think of a real good reason. It is called truth. It is called obeying the Scriptures. Liturgy changes. We will shortly change the current liturgy in the new liturgical year. So all this stuff about liturgy referring to Matthias, parishes named after him and feastdays calling him an apostle, by the very fact that they have changed, are changing and will change again sometime in the future, do not constitute the inerrant teaching of the Church or Scripture. They rise to no higher level than that of the issue of celibacy which is only a discipline and can change anytime. I can assure you that if the Pope would dogmatically and infallibly proclaim that Matthias was no apostle that the liturgical calendar, parishes and liturgy will drop the word ‘apostle’ faster than one could say “JPII The Great”.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by inkaneer
This is the type of logic I see from typical Catholics. It really is no logic. In addition it is wrong and it contradicts Church doctrine. Now apply this same logic to any other apostle, Like Peter. Linus was the replacement for Peter. Was Linus an Apostle too? If one follows the logic of Rosary Fan he has to be but the church does not teach that. The Church teaches that Peter’s replacement was a bishop not an Apostle. Same is true for all the other apostles.

This is old stuff that was rebuked on the other thread entitled “First Pope”. The Greek word apostolos means “one who is sent”. When applied to the group known as the TWELVE APOSTLES it refers to those Twelve who were called and sent by Jesus. . Only eleven of the original twelve called to be Apostles were sent by Jesus. Judas was called but never sent. Matthias was never called nor sent. Paul was both called and sent by Jesus. Those other so called 'apostles, like Barnabas were never sent by Jesus. Indeed the Eastern Churches differentiate between the Twelve Apostles and the 70 disciples sent out by Jesus with very limited authority referring to the seventy disciples as the ‘minor apostles’.

You can say it all you want. But Matthias was not an Apostle of Jesus Christ. Church teaching [from the CCC] says there are twelve apostles. Scripture [Rev 21:14 also says there are 12 apostles. Scripture definitely
calls Paul an apostle 13 times and Matthias 0 times.

You are most welcome to it. But given the state of typical Catholics today it is not something to brag about. By the way you are not Roman Catholic unless you are a member of the diocese of Rome. You are Catholic, more specifically a Latin Rite Catholic. Roman Catholic was a derogatory term created by the English of King Henry VIII’s day to rally support for the Church of England headed by the English monarch versus the Catholic Church headed by a foreign sovereign, the pope in Rome. It played on the sense of Nationalism that was growing at that time. Another such derogatory term used to refer to Catholics was ‘papists’. Both of them are still in use in protestantism.

Oooph. Did someone do something nasty in your Corn Flakes this morning? I didn’t make up that definition for “apostle”. I looked it up. While we’re nit-picking, my parish, WHERE I LIVE, is called “St. [name] ROMAN Catholic Church”. If you don’t believe me, drive on by and take a look at the sign on the front lawn! I don’t live in Rome. The leader of my church lives in Rome.

Maybe Matthias was not one of the original 12, but he was chosen to replace Judas, giving him the 12th spot, after Judas’ betrayal of Jesus and death. Was the question “Who are the original 12 apostles”? or was the question “Was Matthias an apostle”?

So I tried to answer the question, and you called me a “typical Catholic” and then insist that I’m not Roman Catholic, which has NOTHING to do with this post whatsoever. Are you looking for a fight, or are you trying to get an answer to a question. If you are looking for a fight, might I suggest you check out other web sites. I don’t think Catholic Answers Forums is meant for that purpose.
 
You ignore the title
Judas Iscariot and Matthias

Which gives who the piece is about
The Pope identifies Judas as an apostle

The Pope than says that Matthias has replaced Judas

It must be remembered that there were 12 apostles for a reason. The twelve represented the twelve tribes. It is why they had to elect someone to replace Judas.
Paul replaced Judas as the twelfth apostle. Paul was called and sent by Christ. Judas was called to be an apostle. But Judas does not meet the requirementts that you claim makes Matthias an apostle. To wit Judas died and did not live to see the Ascencion when Christ was “taken up” as Peter puts it. Judas quit the apostleship when he left at the Last Supper.

As for the twelve Apostles representing the twelve tribes of Israel that is only half of it. The Davidic kings chose twelve ‘stewards’ to help the king govern. Of these twelve ‘stewards’ one was chosen to be the ‘chief steward’ and to the ‘chief steward’ was given authority to act in the name of the king. He was entrusted with the keys of the kingdom and what he would shut no one could open and what he could open no one could shut. I’ll leave the NT perfection of this OT foreshadowing to you to determine.
If Judas was called an apostle and Matthias replaced him, then Matthias is an apostle is an logical statement. This is the statement that those who know that he was an apostle are saying to you.
Judas was called to be an Apostle. He washed out of the training program and never made it. He was never sent by Jesus and never saw Jesus taken up. Judas had no authority to consecrate the Eucharist nor authority to forgive sin as did the eleven Apostles. What authority Matthias inherits from Judas is nothing more than what protestant ministers possess today. That is no Apostle.
 
I can think of a real good reason. It is called truth. It is called obeying the Scriptures. Liturgy changes. We will shortly change the current liturgy in the new liturgical year.
*Mea culpa *-- My question was inspecific. Do you have reason to expect the Church to alter her liturgy with respect to the designation of Matthias as an apostle?

Yes, I know the new English translation is coming, and I hope it will be an improvement on the ICEL texts posted above – But the Latin above is current. If the new English makes no reference to the apostle, it will be a p!ss-poor attempt at translation. :twocents:

tee
 
You are most welcome to it. But given the state of typical Catholics today it is not something to brag about. By the way you are not Roman Catholic unless you are a member of the diocese of Rome. You are Catholic, more specifically a Latin Rite Catholic. Roman Catholic was a derogatory term created by the English of King Henry VIII’s day to rally support for the Church of England headed by the English monarch versus the Catholic Church headed by a foreign sovereign, the pope in Rome. It played on the sense of Nationalism that was growing at that time. Another such derogatory term used to refer to Catholics was ‘papists’. Both of them are still in use in protestantism.
FYI, Inkaneer…

**Why do we use the term “Roman Catholic” instead of “Catholic”?
We use the phrase “Roman Catholic” in place of “Catholic” to avoid confusion. Most Christian faith groups acknowledge the Nicene Creed and thus regard themselves as “Catholic,” at least as far as being part of the “catholic and apostolic church.” Within any one given faith group, the meaning of the term “Catholic” is relatively clear. But our site deals with all Christian denominations and all other religions. To assure clarity and to avoid ambiguity, we use the term “Roman Catholic” when referring to the church headed by the pope in Rome. We use similar terms (e.g. Evangelical Catholic, Anglo-Catholic, Old Catholic) when referring to some other faith groups. **
 
*Mea culpa *-- My question was inspecific. Do you have reason to expect the Church to alter her liturgy with respect to the designation of Matthias as an apostle?

Yes, I know the new English translation is coming, and I hope it will be an improvement on the ICEL texts posted above – But the Latin above is current. If the new English makes no reference to the apostle, it will be a p!ss-poor attempt at translation. :twocents:

tee
I think the church will prefer to let sleeping dogs lie. I would not expect any changes unless it is part of a larger effort like the one that removed St, Christopher and others from the martyrology.
 
FYI, Inkaneer…

**Why do we use the term “Roman Catholic” instead of “Catholic”?
We use the phrase “Roman Catholic” in place of “Catholic” to avoid confusion. Most Christian faith groups acknowledge the Nicene Creed and thus regard themselves as “Catholic,” at least as far as being part of the “catholic and apostolic church.” Within any one given faith group, the meaning of the term “Catholic” is relatively clear. But our site deals with all Christian denominations and all other religions. To assure clarity and to avoid ambiguity, we use the term “Roman Catholic” when referring to the church headed by the pope in Rome. We use similar terms (e.g. Evangelical Catholic, Anglo-Catholic, Old Catholic) when referring to some other faith groups. **
First of all the Nicene Creed has been around longer that any protestant denomination. The word ‘Catholic’ in the Nicene Creed is the name of the Church that Ignatius coined in 107 AD taking his cue from the Book of Acts. Ptotestants are very quick to note that when they recite the Creed that the word “Catholic” in their version is spelled with a small 'c" to denote universal and not the actual name of the Church. There is no chuch called the Roman Catholic Church unless one is possibly referring to the Catholic Church’s diocese of Rome, Italy. The official name of the Church is the Catholic Church. There are others who claim to be or incorporate the name ‘Catholic’ in their assemblies but as the great Augustine once wrote:

“[T]here are many other things which most properly can keep me in [the Catholic Church’s] bosom. The unanimity of peoples and nations keeps me here. Her authority, inaugurated in miracles, nourished by hope, augmented by love, and confirmed by her age, keeps me here. The succession of priests, from the very see of the apostle Peter, to whom the Lord, after his resurrection, gave the charge of feeding his sheep [John 21:15–17], up to the present episcopate, keeps me here. And last, the very name Catholic, which, not without reason, belongs to this Church alone, in the face of so many heretics, so much so that, although all heretics want to be called ‘Catholic,’ when a stranger inquires where the Catholic Church meets, none of the heretics would dare to point out his own basilica or house” (Against the Letter of Mani Called “The Foundation” 4:5 [A.D. 397]).
 
First of all the Nicene Creed has been around longer that any protestant denomination. The word ‘Catholic’ in the Nicene Creed is the name of the Church that Ignatius coined in 107 AD taking his cue from the Book of Acts. Ptotestants are very quick to note that when they recite the Creed that the word “Catholic” in their version is spelled with a small 'c" to denote universal and not the actual name of the Church. There is no chuch called the Roman Catholic Church unless one is possibly referring to the Catholic Church’s diocese of Rome, Italy. The official name of the Church is the Catholic Church. There are others who claim to be or incorporate the name ‘Catholic’ in their assemblies but as the great Augustine once wrote:

“[T]here are many other things which most properly can keep me in [the Catholic Church’s] bosom. The unanimity of peoples and nations keeps me here. Her authority, inaugurated in miracles, nourished by hope, augmented by love, and confirmed by her age, keeps me here. The succession of priests, from the very see of the apostle Peter, to whom the Lord, after his resurrection, gave the charge of feeding his sheep [John 21:15–17], up to the present episcopate, keeps me here. And last, the very name Catholic, which, not without reason, belongs to this Church alone, in the face of so many heretics, so much so that, although all heretics want to be called ‘Catholic,’ when a stranger inquires where the Catholic Church meets, none of the heretics would dare to point out his own basilica or house” (Against the Letter of Mani Called “The Foundation” 4:5 [A.D. 397]).
Don’t particularly care about all your mumbo-jumbo, there. Just proving my point - I’m not the only one who uses the term “Roman Catholic”. Just about every church in the U.S. has a sign on their lawn that says “St. [fill-in-the-blank] Roman Catholic Church”, and the definition I found is also proof that other people refer to us as “Roman Catholic”. So maybe you’re the oddball here. See…You’re not the only one who can be nasty.

Good day.
 
Don’t particularly care about all your mumbo-jumbo, there. Just proving my point - I’m not the only one who uses the term “Roman Catholic”. Just about every church in the U.S. has a sign on their lawn that says “St. [fill-in-the-blank] Roman Catholic Church”, and the definition I found is also proof that other people refer to us as “Roman Catholic”. So maybe you’re the oddball here. See…You’re not the only one who can be nasty.

Good day.
Like I said a typical Catholic who doesn’t know the correct name of the Church and who calls the writing of one of the greatest Doctors of the Church, “mumbo-jumbo”.
 
Acts 1
25 to take the place in this ministry and apostleship from which Judas fell away to go to his own place"
26 And they drew lots between them, and the lot fell upon matthias; and he was numbered with the eleven apostles.

I think that Scripture is pretty clear. This is from my 1953 edition of the Catholic Family Edition of the Holy Bible. The New Testament are in the Confraternity of Christian Doctrine Text.

Now can you reply to this text of the Holy Scriptures without the an ad hominem attack against me?
 
Due to declining charity and departure from topic this thread is now closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top