Is smoking really that bad?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Melissa_Laurita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thats because doctors dont have to go outside to smoke, they have lounges inside the hospital and in most, they are allowed to smoke if they want, but usually these rooms have unique air filtration units in place, so the smoke doesnt go elsewhere…
Mmmm…I don’t think so. :rolleyes:
 
It should be sinful, in a way, because we have had it bashed over heads for how many years now and people still take up the sticks kick. After all these years how could anyone NOT know how dangerous it is?

BTW, there is also third hand smoke…ewwww…
Because every study on the dangers of smoking is done on people that smoke 3+ packs a day. (20 cigarettes per pack, 5 minutes each, that’s 5 hours a day smoking! There is no way to say that isn’t abuse!) I could make a huge campaign against any alcohol use by assuming everyone that has a glass of wine in the evening has the same risk as a 3 liter a day vodka drinker. It is a massive marketing campaign out there to make YOU think smoking is the worse thing you would ever do (but casual sex is perfectly safe), to the point of third hand smoke being a thing, give me a break… any house old enough for that to be a factor the fiberglass insulation (or asbestos), dust, and animal droppings is worse for you than any smoke that got soaked into the walls of your house! They are even extending the evils of smoking to vaping. I guess water vapor is only good for you coming out of your mold filled cold water vaporizer when you have a cold.
 
That’s because they hide out back to smoke:D

Seriously, I work in healthcare and am shocked how unhealthy healthcare workers are sometimes. I started in Respiratory Therapy and both bosses smoked along with half the staff. Fast forward to now and the current administration will not hire you if you smoke. Security goes around and if you get caught you get wrote up. Can’t smell like smoke either.
I think because I live in California, I’m a little out of the mainstream where smoking is concerned since we have had anti smoking laws for many years. My dear Brother In Law who is a neurosurgeon told me that in the three hospitals he is associated with there has been no smoking area or lounges in twenty years! I also asked my nephew who is on staff at the University of Michigan Medical School and there is also no smoking allowed on their medical campus. When I was in the deep South a few years ago, i was totally shocked when I entered a very upscale restaurant and the first thing the hostess asked was “Smoking or non smoking?”. Right - i don’t know many people in 2014 who want to spend over one hundred dollars on a nice meal and have to smell smoke all evening.:confused:
 
Are physicians so priveleged that they have a place where they can smoke indoors??? This really shocks me. I’ve been around quite a few places, and my impression is that in recent years, INDOOR SMOKING in any public facility is ILLEGAL everywhere. And … especially in a hospital…
Its not about being privileged, Its about convenience for the doctors who do smoke, so they can be ‘reachable’ if needed, I doubt they want doctors just standing around outside smoking anyway.

I believe its illegal to allow the public to smoke it such places, but the owners can create and allow anything they like for their own employees, especially doctors.

I know for a FACT a hospital I had surgery at a couple years ago has such a lounge for doctors, as I was in it with my doctor at the time before the surgery, this doctor smoked a pipe. This is a very large hospital in Cincinnati, OH metro area, so if they have such a lounge, Id imagine other hospitals do too, but I have a few friends who work in hospitals, I can ask them about this just to be sure.
 
Its not about being privileged, Its about convenience for the doctors who do smoke, so they can be ‘reachable’ if needed, I doubt they want doctors just standing around outside smoking anyway.

I believe its illegal to allow the public to smoke it such places, but the owners can create and allow anything they like for their own employees, especially doctors.

I know for a FACT a hospital I had surgery at a couple years ago has such a lounge for doctors, as I was in it with my doctor at the time before the surgery, this doctor smoked a pipe. This is a very large hospital in Cincinnati, OH metro area, so if they have such a lounge, Id imagine other hospitals do too, but I have a few friends who work in hospitals, I can ask them about this just to be sure.
This info IS totally shocking to me. I am a healthcare provider and have been inside a few Dr.'s lounges, and never saw any evidence of smoking. Also, these days, any hopsitals, clinics, and other health facilites (at least in my state, which BTW is quite conservative) are not only smoke-free on the inside, but the the ENTIRE GROUNDS surrounding the facility is smoke-free.
 
I really don’t know. My husband smokes, my dad smokes, my mom smokes (well, vapes), and yet they’re all dedicated Catholics. Even our Priest smokes! And he doesn’t try to hide it or anything. I know a lot of people bring up the verse about our body being a temple, but let me ask this: What about drinking coffee? Caffeine is horrible for your body. What about eating junk food? With all those artificial flavors and dyes? Surely that’s not too great, right? What about drinking soda? Do I even have to explain why that’s bad? My husband believes that, if you’re not doing these things with the intent to cause bodily harm, then they’re okay. Thoughts?
Do you think cancer is bad? Want to roll the dice?

And as an aside - someone once put it this way, about kissing a smoker: “Who wants to lick an ashtray?”

Never have been able to scrub that image out of my mind…😛
 
Do you think cancer is bad? Want to roll the dice?

And as an aside - someone once put it this way, about kissing a smoker: “Who wants to lick an ashtray?”

Never have been able to scrub that image out of my mind…😛
I once read the story, long ago, about a man who fell in love with a woman who was a smoker. I forget the exact details but it still sticks in my mind; when it became clear that the relationship was heading towards matrimony, after trying many ways to get her to quit, finally admitted “you know I love you to pieces, but I can’t stand cigarette breath, it nauseates me; I’ll marry you, but until you quit smoking, I’ll never kiss you again”.

They married. It worked. She quit. 😉
 
I will weigh in with what two priests have said to me on the issue, and what I read in a private revelation.

Almost a year ago I discovered something called “The Volumes” by someone named, “Anne” a “lay apostle”. In the volume I read (I believe Volume 2, a red book), she mentioned that she had a smoking problem. Regardless of the true status of her alleged locutions, there is nothing objectionable in the following which she related as having come from Jesus – He asked her: Would you blow smoke into the tabernacle? Perhaps the context was her receiving Holy Communion with cigarette breath, I don’t remember, but in any event, that question stayed with me.

Despite that…

I had until recently in my possession a cigar that was a souvenir from when my aunt had her baby boy a few years ago. As I was undergoing a lot of stress and anxiety over the last few months, I was tempted to try smoking. However, cigarettes did not appeal to me much. No, I wanted to try a cigar as it was less common and therefore probed at my curiosity more, and it also seemed more “sophisticated”, but I resisted.

I decided to email my spiritual director and I asked if it was wrong or okay to smoke a cigar. **He told me that he doesn’t recommend it, I won’t like it, smoking is a vice, and ask Jesus if he wants you to smoke. **

Some weeks later, I was in confession. I don’t remember the context but I brought up to my confessor the issue of smoking a cigar, and mentioned to him what my spiritual director had told me. I related that I was tempted to smoke, but I hesitated, as I was in doubt about whether it was sinful.

**He said that: If I don’t begin to smoke – if there is no first time – I will not develop the habit of smoking. He said that there was a time in which the detrimental effects of smoking were not known as they are today. But today they are known. **

Nevertheless, he said that in and of itself, it isn’t wrong. But clearly he meant occasional moderated, i.e. self-disciplined use.

I conclude that: Ignorance might mitigate culpability, but the harmful effect are common knowledge in this country. In my opinion, therefore, AT BEST, smoking infrequently and moderately, is morally neutral, with a proximity to moral evil.

I didn’t smoke the cigar. In fact I can’t find it, and I suspect I threw it away when I was cleaning out my dorm (after what my spiritual director said). I probably did that to get rid of the temptation since I am unlikely to go through the trouble of making a trip to the store just to buy one.

I am still tempted in moments but I keep thinking about Jesus!!
 
I will weigh in with what two priests have said to me on the issue, and what I read in a private revelation.

Almost a year ago I discovered something called “The Volumes” by someone named, “Anne” a “lay apostle”. In the volume I read (I believe Volume 2, a red book), she mentioned that she had a smoking problem. Regardless of the true status of her alleged locutions, there is nothing objectionable in the following which she related as having come from Jesus – He asked her: Would you blow smoke into the tabernacle? Perhaps the context was her receiving Holy Communion with cigarette breath, I don’t remember, but in any event, that question stayed with me.

Despite that…

I had until recently in my possession a cigar that was a souvenir from when my aunt had her baby boy a few years ago. As I was undergoing a lot of stress and anxiety over the last few months, I was tempted to try smoking. However, cigarettes did not appeal to me much. No, I wanted to try a cigar as it was less common and therefore probed at my curiosity more, and it also seemed more “sophisticated”, but I resisted.

I decided to email my spiritual director and I asked if it was wrong or okay to smoke a cigar. **He told me that he doesn’t recommend it, I won’t like it, smoking is a vice, and ask Jesus if he wants you to smoke. **

Some weeks later, I was in confession. I don’t remember the context but I brought up to my confessor the issue of smoking a cigar, and mentioned to him what my spiritual director had told me. I related that I was tempted to smoke, but I hesitated, as I was in doubt about whether it was sinful.

**He said that: If I don’t begin to smoke – if there is no first time – I will not develop the habit of smoking. He said that there was a time in which the detrimental effects of smoking were not known as they are today. But today they are known. **

Nevertheless, he said that in and of itself, it isn’t wrong. But clearly he meant occasional moderated, i.e. self-disciplined use.

I conclude that: Ignorance might mitigate culpability, but the harmful effect are common knowledge in this country. In my opinion, therefore, AT BEST, smoking infrequently and moderately, is morally neutral, with a proximity to moral evil.

I didn’t smoke the cigar. In fact I can’t find it, and I suspect I threw it away when I was cleaning out my dorm (after what my spiritual director said). I probably did that to get rid of the temptation since I am unlikely to go through the trouble of making a trip to the store just to buy one.

I am still tempted in moments but I keep thinking about Jesus!!
Cigars are generally not dangerous though, mainly because a person does not inhale the smoke, they just take it in and blow it right back out, plus, theres not nearly as many harmful chemicals in most cigars compared to cigarettes, Ive never heard of any cigar smoker who got cancer from only smoking cigars…dont think its even possible.
 
Cigars are generally not dangerous though, mainly because a person does not inhale the smoke, they just take it in and blow it right back out, plus, theres not nearly as many harmful chemicals in most cigars compared to cigarettes, Ive never heard of any cigar smoker who got cancer from only smoking cigars…dont think its even possible.
I wish! If they were quite safe and I could be assured of it, I would probably go for it (although for the wrong reasons… curiosity killed the cat as the saying goes…)

These two links are some of the ones I’ve found comparing the dangers of cigars with cigarettes:

mayoclinic.org/healthy-living/quit-smoking/expert-answers/cigar-smoking/faq-20057787
Despite what you might have heard, cigar smoking isn’t safer than cigarette smoking — even if you don’t intentionally inhale the smoke. Like cigarette smoking, cigar smoking poses serious health risks, including:
  • ** Cancer.** All tobacco smoke contains chemicals that can cause cancer, and cigar smoke is no exception. Regular cigar smoking increases the risk of several types of cancers, including cancers of the mouth, lip, tongue, throat, esophagus, larynx and lung.
  • Code:
    **Lung** and heart disease. Regular cigar smoking increases the risk of lung diseases, including emphysema and chronic bronchitis. It also might increase the risk of heart disease, such as coronary artery disease.
  • Code:
    **Oral disease**. Cigar smoking has been linked to oral and dental disease, such as gum disease and tooth loss.
cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/Tobacco/cigars

So I guess I’ll just recreate with a nice glass of tea and inhale candle scents 🙂
 
Cigars are generally not dangerous though, mainly because a person does not inhale the smoke, they just take it in and blow it right back out, plus, theres not nearly as many harmful chemicals in most cigars compared to cigarettes, Ive never heard of any cigar smoker who got cancer from only smoking cigars…dont think its even possible.
oral cancer.
not pretty
 
I really don’t know. My husband smokes, my dad smokes, my mom smokes (well, vapes), and yet they’re all dedicated Catholics. Even our Priest smokes! And he doesn’t try to hide it or anything. I know a lot of people bring up the verse about our body being a temple, but let me ask this: What about drinking coffee? Caffeine is horrible for your body. What about eating junk food? With all those artificial flavors and dyes? Surely that’s not too great, right? What about drinking soda? Do I even have to explain why that’s bad? My husband believes that, if you’re not doing these things with the intent to cause bodily harm, then they’re okay. Thoughts?
I used to smoke. Then I gave up, cold turkey, years ago. Let me tell you- it’s been absolute hell since then…

If I get to Heaven, I look forward to lighting up a cigarette, without guilt or shame…
 
I will try my best to answer the OP question, “Is smoking really that bad?”:

About me: I have NEVER smoked, but have several good friends who are current smokers with a 30+ year smoking history. I approached these people to be able to best answers the question. Below, are thoughts/views which are common to all of these individuals.
  • All deeply regret ever trying a cigarette.
  • All agree that young people should never experiment with cigarettes.
  • It takes a relatively SHORT time to become addicted.
  • They all have some physical health issues related to their smoking.
  • Quitting, or staying off cigarettes is near-impossible. Some of them have quit for stretches of time, but ALWAYS go back to smoking in times of stressful life events.
  • They are all embarrassed about being smokers, some of them more than others.
  • They have, at one time or another, received a “dirty look,” when out in public.
  • They feel trapped by this addiction.
 
My mother had a problem with addictions, smoking was one of them. The addiction, what ever it is, becomes your master, and we become it’s slave. We are told in scripture that you cannot serve 2 masters…
Now I’ve seen it all.
 
Smoking is not a sin, it is only considered a sin when it is abused.
 
Smoking is not a sin, it is only considered a sin when it is abused.
How can a person smoke and NOT abuse it? its an addiction, of course people are going to abuse it.

I still say, its very dangerous for your soul, as we know it will kill you if you keep doing it, so if a person does it willingly, that is just slowly committing suicide imo. Technically, its poisoning yourself to death, just takes many years to kill.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top