I will weigh in with what two priests have said to me on the issue, and what I read in a private revelation.
Almost a year ago I discovered something called “The Volumes” by someone named, “Anne” a “lay apostle”. In the volume I read (I believe Volume 2, a red book), she mentioned that she had a smoking problem. Regardless of the true status of her alleged locutions, there is nothing objectionable in the following which she related as having come from Jesus – He asked her: Would you blow smoke into the tabernacle? Perhaps the context was her receiving Holy Communion with cigarette breath, I don’t remember, but in any event, that question stayed with me.
Despite that…
I had until recently in my possession a cigar that was a souvenir from when my aunt had her baby boy a few years ago. As I was undergoing a lot of stress and anxiety over the last few months, I was tempted to try smoking. However, cigarettes did not appeal to me much. No, I wanted to try a cigar as it was less common and therefore probed at my curiosity more, and it also seemed more “sophisticated”, but I resisted.
I decided to email my spiritual director and I asked if it was wrong or okay to smoke a cigar. **He told me that he doesn’t recommend it, I won’t like it, smoking is a vice, and ask Jesus if he wants you to smoke. **
Some weeks later, I was in confession. I don’t remember the context but I brought up to my confessor the issue of smoking a cigar, and mentioned to him what my spiritual director had told me. I related that I was tempted to smoke, but I hesitated, as I was in doubt about whether it was sinful.
**He said that: If I don’t begin to smoke – if there is no first time – I will not develop the habit of smoking. He said that there was a time in which the detrimental effects of smoking were not known as they are today. But today they are known. **
Nevertheless, he said that in and of itself, it isn’t wrong. But clearly he meant occasional moderated, i.e. self-disciplined use.
I conclude that: Ignorance might mitigate culpability, but the harmful effect are common knowledge in this country. In my opinion, therefore, AT BEST, smoking infrequently and moderately, is morally neutral, with a proximity to moral evil.
I didn’t smoke the cigar. In fact I can’t find it, and I suspect I threw it away when I was cleaning out my dorm (after what my spiritual director said). I probably did that to get rid of the temptation since I am unlikely to go through the trouble of making a trip to the store just to buy one.
I am still tempted in moments but I keep thinking about Jesus!!