B
Ben_Sinner
Guest
Is there anyway to refute it and prove there is absolute truth?
I’ve seen an example of this Trilemma before. For example:
*Bob: Its going to rain today.
Jim: Why do you think that?
Bob: Because there are rain clouds in the sky.
Jim: "Why do you think that?
Bob: “Just look at them. Can’t you seem them? They’re all heavy and dark like.”
Jim: "Why do you think that?
Bob: Because I see them.
Jim: You already appealed to your visual apparatus, you used circular reasoning.
Bob*: “Why do I think the clouds are heavy and dark like?”
Jim: “Yes, why?”
Bob: Because I just do.
Jim: You are assuming your reason is true, that doesn’t actually show that it is.*
I’ve seen an example of this Trilemma before. For example:
*Bob: Its going to rain today.
Jim: Why do you think that?
Bob: Because there are rain clouds in the sky.
Jim: "Why do you think that?
Bob: “Just look at them. Can’t you seem them? They’re all heavy and dark like.”
Jim: "Why do you think that?
Bob: Because I see them.
Jim: You already appealed to your visual apparatus, you used circular reasoning.
Bob*: “Why do I think the clouds are heavy and dark like?”
Jim: “Yes, why?”
Bob: Because I just do.
Jim: You are assuming your reason is true, that doesn’t actually show that it is.*