Is there such a thing as a spiritual IQ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Sock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Robert_Sock

Guest
Psychologists are now well aware of the many different types of intelligence, such as having a social IQ, and I was wondering about us having a spiritual IQ, a special grace from God? How would a spiritual IQ be measured?
 
“Spiritual IQ” seems to me to be a rather misplaced combination of two different things, since “IQ” is intrinsically measurable and “spirituality” is intrinsically non-measurable.

Therefore, whatever you decide the definition of “spiritual IQ” is, it’s quite definitely non-measurable because there’s no unit for spiritual progress or holiness.
 
“Spiritual IQ” seems to me to be a rather misplaced combination of two different things, since “IQ” is intrinsically measurable and “spirituality” is intrinsically non-measurable.

Therefore, whatever you decide the definition of “spiritual IQ” is, it’s quite definitely non-measurable because there’s no unit for spiritual progress or holiness.
Slightly different question: If I measured the regular IQ of people, and then carefully rated their spiritual experiences, I’ll bet that they are positively correlated. Would you agree?
 
Slightly different question: If I measured the regular IQ of people, and then carefully rated their spiritual experiences, I’ll bet that they are positively correlated. Would you agree?
I don’t think there is a direct correlation. There are some very intelligent people who deny the very existence of a spiritual realm, and plenty of simple folks who are quite spiritually inclined. There are also towering geniuses who are very spiritual, and lesser minds who couldn’t care less about anything spiritual.

I wonder too what makes a person spiritually aware, but I’m not sure intelligence is the deciding factor.
 
As a psychologist, you are certainly aware that IQ is a proxy for the “general intelligence factor” (which is derived by the correlation of the various subtests on the IQ test). It is understood that IQ is highly heritable (meaning that most of the variance within a given population is associated with genetic factors and not amenable to environmental enrichment within the normal variance of the environmental factors experienced by that population).

Job performance is said to be correlated with IQ, but performance cannot be conflated with aptitude even though it would be expected to be correlated with it. Regarding spiritual IQ, there has to be a means to distinguish performance (such as Mass attendance or faithful adherence to the salat) with spiritual aptitude. Perhaps, such as a measure could be administered Confirmation candidates and it would predict apostasy rates or Mass attendance twenty years later, independently of personal factors such as conscientiousness and openness to experience.

Spiritual IQ has to be an aptitude that correlates with performance to domains of spiritual proficiency and it cannot be significantly affected by environmental factors.

Note, that I did not even attempt to describe what it is (but rather compare it to IQ), but instead focus on a means to measure it and use the measurement to make reasonable predictions with it. This reflects my empiricism and instrumentalism in my philosophy of science.
 
I don’t think there is a direct correlation. There are some very intelligent people who deny the very existence of a spiritual realm, and plenty of simple folks who are quite spiritually inclined. There are also towering geniuses who are very spiritual, and lesser minds who couldn’t care less about anything spiritual.

I wonder too what makes a person spiritually aware, but I’m not sure intelligence is the deciding factor.
I was just suggesting a correlation and not necessarily a direct causal relationship. But we should expect a correlation between traditional IQ and the various subcategories of IQ, including spirituality.
 
“Spiritual IQ” seems to me to be a rather misplaced combination of two different things, since “IQ” is intrinsically measurable and “spirituality” is intrinsically non-measurable.

Therefore, whatever you decide the definition of “spiritual IQ” is, it’s quite definitely non-measurable because there’s no unit for spiritual progress or holiness.
Then how is it that the Church canonizes saints?
 
Psychologists are now well aware of the many different types of intelligence, such as having a social IQ, and I was wondering about us having a spiritual IQ, a special grace from God? How would a spiritual IQ be measured?
Perhaps we can look at:
1 Corinthians 13:4-7New International Version (NIV)

4 Love is patient,
love is kind.
It does not envy,
it does not boast,
it is not proud.
5 It does not dishonor others,
it is not self-seeking,
it is not easily angered,
it keeps no record of wrongs.
6 Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth.
7 It always protects,
always trusts,
always hopes,
always perseveres

If these virtues could be measured?
 
I have my doubts that intelligence is quantifiable, honestly. Those scores seem to me only an indicator that a given person is good at taking “IQ tests”. With that said, obviously I’m even more dubious about the prospect of emotional or spiritual IQ tests.
 
Perhaps we can look at:
1 Corinthians 13:4-7New International Version (NIV)

4 Love is patient,
love is kind.
It does not envy,
it does not boast,
it is not proud.
5 It does not dishonor others,
it is not self-seeking,
it is not easily angered,
it keeps no record of wrongs.
6 Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth.
7 It always protects,
always trusts,
always hopes,
always perseveres

If these virtues could be measured?
It’s interesting whether these virtues are positively correlated to IQ, but my question, restated, is whether highly spiritual people (whether sinner or saint) also tend to have higher IQs.
 
If there is Spiritual IQ, I must have a Developmental Disability: Spiritual Retardation. Good thing I have the best support staff!😃

In the same way the Spirit also helps our weakness; for we do not know how to pray as we should, but the Spirit Himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words,and He who searches the hearts knows what the mind of the Spirit is, because He intercedes for the saints according to the will of God.
 
It’s interesting whether these virtues are positively correlated to IQ, but my question, restated, is whether highly spiritual people (whether sinner or saint) also tend to have higher IQs.
I doubt it.

Highly spiritual sinners??
 
I doubt it.

Highly spiritual sinners??
Satan tempts by spirit, for that’s all Satan is. Yes, sinners can be highly spiritual. I was an Atheist for a long time, sinning all along the way, yet my spirituality was high and I was inadvertently worshiping Satan.
 
No, everyone is unique. How they and God interact is unique. A lot is determined by the choices the person makes and experiences can vary significantly for the individual with long periods of dryness, moments of spiritual insight and wonderment, and so on.
 
No, everyone is unique. How they and God interact is unique. A lot is determined by the choices the person makes and experiences can vary significantly for the individual with long periods of dryness, moments of spiritual insight and wonderment, and so on.
Thanks, buts I fail to see where spiritual aptitude would fail as a construct simply because God interacts with us individuality.
 
Satan tempts by spirit, for that’s all Satan is. Yes, sinners can be highly spiritual. I was an Atheist for a long time, sinning all along the way, yet my spirituality was high and I was inadvertently worshiping Satan.
Ho do you define “spiritual”?
 
Ho do you define “spiritual”?
Not too sure, but the ability to detect, communicate and interact with good and/or evil spirits. I think every criminal is interacting with Satan, but few are spiritual enough to take notice and become aware of the evil spirits affecting them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top