Is "true love" just a feeling or is it action?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SonOfMan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SonOfMan

Guest
We see “true love” described as doing things for the good of another, even if it doesn’t “feel” convenient or even if you don’t “feel” loving doing it. Its the actions that count, many will say.

Then as justification for believing in God (who is described as being Love itself), people always say “they just feel it” but there are never any actions attributed to this Being of Love.

So is Love just a feeling or is it actions?
 
We see “true love” described as doing things for the good of another, even if it doesn’t “feel” convenient or even if you don’t “feel” loving doing it. Its the actions that count, many will say.

Then as justification for believing in God (who is described as being Love itself), people always say “they just feel it” but there are never any actions attributed to this Being of Love.

So is Love just a feeling or is it actions?
Both, as well as other things, depending on the context and usage.
 
We see “true love” described as doing things for the good of another, even if it doesn’t “feel” convenient or even if you don’t “feel” loving doing it. Its the actions that count, many will say.

Then as justification for believing in God (who is described as being Love itself), people always say “they just feel it” but there are never any actions attributed to this Being of Love.

So is Love just a feeling or is it actions?
What about the action of God giving me life and then when we screwed it up so bad he came and died for me so that I could live with him. That is the primal example of love. This idea is used over and over again in all the “love stories” ever written.

What you describe is someone trying to describe their assurance of Gods love. That’s very different than limiting Gods love to individual experiences.
 
If God is true love, where are his actions? I see none. Is God not true love?
God’s Truest action of love is also the Truest form of love - sacrificing Himself. Think about it this way - God, in the Person of God the Son, Jesus Christ, allowed Himself to be killed (publicly, and in one of the most torturous ways possible) so that we might be spared. That is true love. In the Christian faith, husbands are to love their wives and children just as Jesus loved us. This means, we men must be willing to lay down our lives for our wives and children. True love is not simply infatuation - a feeling that can fade away over time. True love is sacrifice - in the shape of the crucified Christ.
 
Understanding that God is the Creator of all things, His major actions are:
  • the Universe,
  • life as we know it, including our very own life, and
  • sending us His Only Son, Jesus Christ, to provide us a way to eternal salvation.
He asks us, in return, to Love Him and love others. See Matthew 22: 36-40. Note all the Law depends on Love. Law is what we must do and what we must not do. Obeying or disobeying the Law are acts and acts have consequences. Forgiveness is an act of Love. See also John 20: 19-23.

Feeling love is not enough. Love is action. We cannot just talk the talk. We have to walk the walk as well.
 
We see “true love” described as doing things for the good of another, even if it doesn’t “feel” convenient or even if you don’t “feel” loving doing it. Its the actions that count, many will say.

Then as justification for believing in God (who is described as being Love itself), people always say “they just feel it” but there are never any actions attributed to this Being of Love.

So is Love just a feeling or is it actions?
Both, but not always feelings. Because the Holy Spirit is within you and you are living a life of grace actions will come. Friendship of God will come as well, with or without feelings.

Some of the great Saints went through a dark night of the soul where they thought God abandoned them, although that is where God was the strongest in them.
 
God’s Truest action of love is also the Truest form of love - sacrificing Himself. Think about it this way - God, in the Person of God the Son, Jesus Christ, allowed Himself to be killed (publicly, and in one of the most torturous ways possible) so that we might be spared. That is true love. In the Christian faith, husbands are to love their wives and children just as Jesus loved us. This means, we men must be willing to lay down our lives for our wives and children. True love is not simply infatuation - a feeling that can fade away over time. True love is sacrifice - in the shape of the crucified Christ.
I didnt witness that. Where are Gods actions of his love for me personally? A man who ate well with food that was donated to him 20 years ago doesnt satisfy the hunger of the rest of the world’s need for food. Love (actions) must be shown regularly. Doing one good deed isn’t enough to let one off the hook from doing good deeds ever again.

Unless of course, God doesnt love everyone and that could very well be why we dont experience his love (actions).
 
I didnt witness that. Where are Gods actions of his love for me personally? A man who ate well with food that was donated to him 20 years doesnt satisfy the hunger of the rest of the world’s need for food. Love (actions) must be shown regularly. Doing one good deed isn’t enough to let one off the hook from doing good deeds ever again.

Unless of course, God doesnt love everyone and that could very well be why we dont experience his love (actions).
You don’t get it…without God you do not take your next breath. Without Christ you are damned to hell eternally separated from God.

That’s the gift that keeps on giving.

Not to mention God gives gifts in the form of grace to anyone that’s willing to accept it. This can look like many things, but ultimately it is a sense of peace and satisfaction and comfort.

This gift is there for everyone.

Only a few choose to embrace it and accept the gift of love from God.
 
I didnt witness that. Where are Gods actions of his love for me personally? A man who ate well with food that was donated to him 20 years ago doesnt satisfy the hunger of the rest of the world’s need for food. Love (actions) must be shown regularly. Doing one good deed isn’t enough to let one off the hook from doing good deeds ever again.

Unless of course, God doesnt love everyone and that could very well be why we dont experience his love (actions).
Since Christ is Eternal, His Sacrifice on the Cross is enough. In fact because He is Infinite it is of infinite value. Even though He died for us in time, He is outside of time, and we can present ourselves before the the Cross everyday at Mass. There is He present in the Eucharist.

Peace and God Love you
 
We see “true love” described as doing things for the good of another, even if it doesn’t “feel” convenient or even if you don’t “feel” loving doing it. Its the actions that count, many will say.

Then as justification for believing in God (who is described as being Love itself), people always say “they just feel it” but there are never any actions attributed to this Being of Love.

So is Love just a feeling or is it actions?
This is one of my favorite meditations. St. Ignatius says… Love into Practice.
Code:
                         Love consists in sharing......
                               What one has.......
                            and what one is.......
                           with those,,,,,one loves

                           Love ought to show itself
                        in deed more than in words.......
People can tell you all day long they love you, but if their actions are not about love, it is words only. Action over words. Do you think a marriage of 50 years last by words only. More by Loving actions.
 
Since Christ is Eternal, His Sacrifice on the Cross is enough. In fact because He is Infinite it is of infinite value. Even though He died for us in time, He is outside of time, and we can present ourselves before the the Cross everyday at Mass. There is He present in the Eucharist.

Peace and God Love you
Since my earthly life is not eternal, infinite, and omniprese nt like Christ is, I have not experienced his sacrifice personally. I wasnt there.
 
You don’t get it…without God you do not take your next breath. Without Christ you are damned to hell eternally separated from God.

That’s the gift that keeps on giving.

Not to mention God gives gifts in the form of grace to anyone that’s willing to accept it. This can look like many things, but ultimately it is a sense of peace and satisfaction and comfort.

This gift is there for everyone.

Only a few choose to embrace it and accept the gift of love from God.
Im not sure if me just simply being alive and breathing is God loving (showing action) me, which by the way cant be proven, especially when there exists natural explanations for why I am alive that would seem to undermine that theory.

Just sustaining life isnt much of an action, its the equivalent of throwing someone on a life support machine and never feeding them or spending time with them, very impersonal.
 
Im not sure if me just simply being alive and breathing is God loving (showing action) me, which by the way cant be proven, especially when there exists natural explanations for why I am alive that would seem to undermine that theory.

Just sustaining life isnt much of an action, its the equivalent of throwing someone on a life support machine and never feeding them or spending time with them, very impersonal.
As I mentioned, when you close yourself off to God he lets you go it alone. It’s clear you’ve made a choice to do that and now your upset by that choice’s ramifications. 🤷

It’s like your drowning in the sea and God is safe on the dry land and he hears you are adrift in the sea so he risks his life to swim out to you with a life preserver and he reaches you and drowns as he is holding the life preserver out for you. All you have to do is grab it and hold on. He left his perfect safety and died to bring you that life ring, that is love. Selfless love.

It is you who, do to pride, ignorance, selfishness, or something else who refuses to grab the life ring.

Then, adrift at sea with a life ring next to you, suffering, you scream to The one who just died bringing you the life ring, “why don’t you ever show me love!”
 
As I mentioned, when you close yourself off to God he lets you go it alone. It’s clear you’ve made a choice to do that and now your upset by that choice’s ramifications. 🤷
What about when I believed and regularley attended Confession and regularly prayed? He was letting me “go it alone” which has nothing to do with the “choices” Ive made. Ive never experienced any actions, which is what real love is supposed to be, not just fuzzy feelings.

Many believers’ definition of love is ultimately action, but when it comes to God, fuzzy feelings will suffice as proof for his existence. Double standard.

By the way, inabiliy to believe doesnt seem like a choice, because without proper communication, Ive been left with no choice but to see there isnt anyone there.
 
What about when I believed and regularley attended Confession and regularly prayed? He was letting me “go it alone” which has nothing to do with the “choices” Ive made. Ive never experienced any actions, which is what real love is supposed to be, not just fuzzy feelings.

Many believers’ definition of love is ultimately action, but when it comes to God, fuzzy feelings will suffice as proof for his existence. Double standard.

By the way, inabiliy to believe doesnt seem like a choice, because without proper communication, Ive been left with no choice but to see there isnt anyone there.
It seems your view of “actions” is skewed to me.

What types of things are you looking for?
 
What about when I believed and regularley attended Confession and regularly prayed? He was letting me “go it alone” which has nothing to do with the “choices” Ive made. Ive never experienced any actions, which is what real love is supposed to be, not just fuzzy feelings.

Many believers’ definition of love is ultimately action, but when it comes to God, fuzzy feelings will suffice as proof for his existence. Double standard.

By the way, inabiliy to believe doesnt seem like a choice, because without proper communication, Ive been left with no choice but to see there isnt anyone there.
Which seems like you believed in the so-called “prosperity gospel” - that God will shower those He loves with material things in this life. See, here’s the thing. Many times I’ll pray (sometimes daily for weeks or even months) for something, and I don’t get what I ask for. And then, I ask God, “Why? Why did you tell me no?” This is especially true if I think what I want is what God wants. But… God’s time is not our time. And, as Blessed Teresa of Calcutta once said, “God does not expect me to be successful - as far as human success is concerned. God expects me to be faithful.”

Regardless, from your text, it seems like you want to believe, but have felt so rejected by God that you have lost faith in Him. Is this the case? Because if it is, I apologize for all of us Christians who have let down our fellow human being, who the Father created and Jesus died for. It’s our fault - not God’s, nor yours, but ours. And, though I don’t know you personally, and have probably never crossed paths with you - I’ve let countless people down myself who God has sent me to help, and I’ve just ignored (probably just by not even noticing their existence). And so have all of us. And for that, I’m sorry. Because God really does love you, but the only way to experience God’s love is (a) when you’re in need, have someone show God’s love to you, and (b) when you see someone else in need, be the love of God for them.

Love is more than a feeling, it’s more than an action, it’s more than a choice. But what is true about love is that when you perform loving actions for others, you grow in love for them. And when you stop perfoming loving actions for others, you lose your love for them. As such, love is like a living, breathing organism. If you feed the love with actions, it grows and spreads. If you stop feeding love with actions, it will shrivel and die.
 
Which seems like you believed in the so-called “prosperity gospel” - that God will shower those He loves with material things in this life.
It seems youve made an unfound assumption about me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top