John 6 Does Not Teach Real Presence

  • Thread starter Thread starter reformissionary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
From God’s point of view the groups that have valid Holy Order (maintained unbroken apostolic succession) are:

1)Catholic Church (and the only one in the Fullness of the faith)
  1. Eastern Orthodox Churches
  2. Various schismatic Churches, such as the Old Catholics who split from the Catholic Church after Vatican I, but who have maintained apostolic succession by virtue of a schismatic but valid bishop.
It is a sad scandal that these valid Churches are split, but each of them do have apostolic succession. The Catholic Church alone, however, has the Christian faith in the Fullness of the teachings of Christ and His apostles.

Those who have lost apostolic succession or never had it and thus do not have Valid Holy Orders and so do not technically have a valid “Church”, but are rather ecclesial fellowships, are:
  1. Anglican/Episcopal (lost apostolic succession soon after their schism and heresy)
  2. Reformation Protestants
  3. Post-Reformation denominations
  4. All non-denomination denominations and various sects of modern invention.
…“most Protestant denominations do not maintain apostolic succession”… Actually no Protestant denomination has apostolic succession and, except for the Anglicans, never had it. This is one reason why Anglican are often listed separately from Protestants, but they nevertheless do not have valid Holy Orders.

As for Communion, for all “churches” without valid Holy Orders communion is merely a symbol and the bread is merely bread and the wine merely wine (or grapejuice). They do not have a valid Eucharist because they do not have valid priests.
That is totally correct… 👍
Great post…

Matthew
 
I am pretty sure that if a Catholic priest became a Lutheran, for example, he would be able to produce the real deal. He would be in sin, but in the eyes of the Chruch, he would still be able to confect the Eucharist.
 
***yes, i do… and if you have a problem with that…

you have a problem accepting a God who can prevent His Church from teaching error…***
Cmatt25 states he’s catholic but he is not…

Matthew
 
=distracted;6733352]again… objectively speaking, only the Catholics have the Real thing… the Real Presence… as given to us through Transubstantiation… which can only be accomplished through an ordained Catholic priest…
Again, objectively speaking, we have discussed the issue of the Catholic view of valid orders before, and I do not wish to argue with you about it, as we generally have a good dialogue relationship. EricFilmer has listed the appropriate CCC sections, and I will leave it to Catholics to discuss the Catholic Church’s view.
As for Lutherans that are not in succession, we are going to have to agree to disagree until the time of unity. The Lutheran confessions provide a clear description of presbyter ordination and its validity, even in Catholic Church history.

The relationship of our communions is clearly asymmetrical: we accept your orders and sacraments as valid, the Catholic Church rejects (though not as finally as you seem to think - see my signature, and google Lutheran Catholic dialogue Eucharist. I pray for the day when unity comes to us. When it does, I suspect this will be one of the less complicated to resolve.

Jon
 
I haven’t spent time reading through the several hundred posts on this but there were several that caught my eye.
Reformis posted
Code:
History/1500 years/etc - People are fallible. The Scriptures are not because they are inspired by the Holy Spirit.
to which MickVoci posted
Code:
People are fallible. But not you, right? You are obviously annoyed that I'm asking you for some factual history, but asking I am. Show me in the historical record when this heresy of the Real Presence began. Show me the period when the Church battled it and finally succumbed to it. You are making the claim, however indirectly, that the entire Church was consumed by a heresy. So present your evidence or admit that you have none.
I didnt see a reply from Pastor Reform if he is infallible. So my question is again are you infallible since you claim people are infallible. But YOU HAVE IT RIGHT? How do you know that YOUR interpretation is correct. Does your interpretation stand the test of time? Do you mean to say that the early Christians who were taught by Jesus’ Apostles were all dumb Dodos and didnt understand it all through 2000 years they have passed the wrong interpretation to the world? BUT YOU HAVE IT RIGHT?
BTW scripture is NOT infallible. It is inerrant. And you would NOT know the scripture but for the Catholic Church who had this teaching even before the bible was compiled. And when the Bible was compiled it HAD to agree with what the Church was teaching otherwise it would be rejected.

Reform posted
Code:
I have and do read those things. But why not as well, and of far greater importance and value, look at the Scriptures? I find it odd that most Catholics I talk to love to talk about the Fathers, who disagreed on much, while often having no idea how to interact with God-breathed Scripture.
Are you insinuating that for 2000 years the Church has NOT looked at the Scripture or has been blind on the thing that IT PUT TOGETHER and claimed it was the inspired Word of God. The Early Church Fathers who were taught by the apostles had NO IDEA how to interact with God-breathed Scripture, but 2000 years passed and YOU do?
StevieD posted
You believe after all you are your own interpreter of the truth, but it might be wise to pause and re-consider.
This says it all. YOU ARE RIGHT and 2000 years of Christianity is wrong. That my friend can be considered arrogance.

Reform posted
Code:
Protestants are consistent in their interpretation throughout the book.
WOW :eek:Now that is a mouthful. Then why are there hundreds if not thousands of denominations all claiming they know the truth (like you do) but all have different interpretations?
 
I’m going to post the following but I DO NOT TAKE CREDIT FOR IT. It was posted sometime back by a gent by the name of Michael explaining John 6. I don’t know if he is still around but with his permission I will post it.

John 6:51-58 is to be interpreted literally and is one of the strongest passages that testify to the Real Presence in the Eucharist. In the Gospel of John, there is a certain pattern that helps to shed light on John 6. Whenever Jesus makes an ambiguous statement, it is usually followed by a misunderstanding/question, and this, in turn, is followed by a clarification either by Jesus or the Evangelist. So, this is the basic outline of this pattern:
  1. **Ambiguous Statement by Jesus **
  2. Misunderstanding/ Question
  3. Clarification
Now here are some examples from the Gospel of John:

John 2:19-21

Jesus answered them, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.” The Jews then said "It took forty-six years to build this temple, and you will raise it up in three days? But He was speaking of the temple of His body."

John 3:3-5

Jesus answered and said to him, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.” Nicodemus said to him, "How can a man be born when he is old? He cannot enter a second time into his mother’s womb and be born, can he?Jesus answered, "Truly Truly I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit he cannot enter the kingdom of God."

John 4:32-34

"But He said to them, “I have food to eat that you do not know about.” So the disciples were saying to one another, 'no one brought Him anything to eat, did he? Jesus said to them, " My Food is to do the will of Him who sent me and to accomplish His work."

John 8:31-34

So Jesus was saying to those Jews who believed in Him, “If you continue in My word, then you are truly disciples of Mine; and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free.” They answered Him, "We are Abraham’s descendants and have never been enslaved to anyone; how is it that You say, “You will become free.” Jesus answered them, "Truly, Truly I say to you, everyone who commits sin is the slave of sin.

Now let’s look at John 6:51-53 and see if it fits the Ambiguous Statement/Question/Clarification pattern:

"I am the living bread that came down out of heaven; if anyone eats this bread, he will live forever; and the bread also which I will give for the life of the world is My flesh." Then the Jews began to argue with one another, saying, "How can this man give us His flesh to eat? So Jesus said to them, Truly, Truly, I say to you unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood you have no life in yourselves.

So, following the established pattern, verse 53 is a clarification of verses 51-52. If he were merely speaking figuratively, then we would have expected the literal meaning of the “figurative” language he used, as it happens in the verses I gave above and in many other places in the Bible. Instead, what we see in verse 53 is a reaffirmation of what the Jews understood Jesus to mean. So the clarification is that Jesus was speaking literally, not figuratively. If he were speaking figuratively, He would have indicated that in verse 53.

The point of the above post is that when Jesus is speaking figuratively, either Jesus Himself or the Gospel writer explains what He means. He often uses progressive revelation as a teaching method, going from ambiguity to greater clarity. There are numerous examples of this in the 4 Gospels. Here are some more:

(cont’d)
 
contd
John 4:10-14

**10Jesus answered and said to her, “If you knew the gift of God, and who it is who says to you, ‘Give Me a drink,’ you would have asked Him, and He would have given you living water.”
11She said to Him, “Sir, You have nothing to draw with and the well is deep; where then do You get that living water?
12"You are not greater than our father Jacob, are You, who gave us the well, and drank of it himself and his sons and his cattle?”
13Jesus answered and said to her, “Everyone who drinks of this water will thirst again;
14but whoever drinks of the water that I will give him shall never thirst; but the water that I will give him will become in him a well of water springing up to eternal life.” **

John 8:56-58

56"Your father Abraham rejoiced to see My day, and he saw it and was glad."
57So the Jews said to Him, “You are not yet fifty years old, and have You seen Abraham?” 58Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was born, I am."


John 10:1-10

1"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who does not enter by the door into the fold of the sheep, but climbs up some other way, he is a thief and a robber.
2"But he who enters by the door is a shepherd of the sheep.
3"To him the doorkeeper opens, and the sheep hear his voice, and he calls his own sheep by name and leads them out.
4"When he puts forth all his own, he goes ahead of them, and the sheep follow him because they know his voice.
5"A stranger they simply will not follow, but will flee from him, because they do not know the voice of strangers."
6This figure of speech Jesus spoke to them, but they did not understand what those things were which He had been saying to them.
7So Jesus said to them again, "Truly, truly, I say to you, I am the door of the sheep.
8"All who came before Me are thieves and robbers, but the sheep did not hear them.
9"I am the door; if anyone enters through Me, he will be saved, and will go in and out and find pasture.
10"The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I came that they may have life, and have it abundantly.


John 7:38-39

38"He who believes in Me, as the Scripture said, ‘From his innermost being will flow rivers of living water.’"
39But this He spoke of the Spirit, whom those who believed in Him were to receive


John 12:32-33

**32 And I, if I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all peoples to Myself.” 33 This He said, signifying by what death He would die. **

John 21:18-19

**18 Most assuredly, I say to you, when you were younger, you girded yourself and walked where you wished; but when you are old, you will stretch out your hands, and another will gird you and carry you where you do not wish.” 19 This He spoke, signifying by what death he would glorify God. **

Matthew 16:6-12

6 Then Jesus said to them, “Take heed and beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and the Sadducees.” 7 And they reasoned among themselves, saying, “It is because we have taken no bread.”
8 But Jesus, being aware of it, said to them, “O you of little faith, why do you reason among yourselves because you have brought no bread?[a] 9 Do you not yet understand, or remember the five loaves of the five thousand and how many baskets you took up? 10 Nor the seven loaves of the four thousand and how many large baskets you took up? 11 How is it you do not understand that I did not speak to you concerning bread?—but to beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees.” 12 Then they understood that He did not tell them to beware of the leaven of bread, but of the doctrine of the Pharisees and Sadducees.


This does not happen in John 6.

]John 6:63

63 It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and they are life

This verse does not mean that Jesus was speaking figuratively. The word “Spirit” is used to refer to those things that pertain to God and the word “flesh” refers to those things that pertain to sin. We constantly see the Spirit vs. flesh construct throughout the Bible:

Galatians 5:16

16 I say then: Walk in the Spirit, and you shall not fulfill the lust of the flesh. 17 For the flesh lusts against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh; and these are contrary to one another, so that you do not do the things that you wish.

Romans 8:5-6

5 For those who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who live according to the Spirit, the things of the Spirit. 6 For to be carnally minded is death, but to be spiritually minded is life and peace

So what Jesus meant in John 6:63 was not that he was speaking figuratively. Rather, that His words originate from God (i.e. Spirit) and they are life giving (i.e. life). He said this in response to the rejection of His teaching. Those who were “carnally minded” rejected His teaching, while those who were “spiritually minded” accepted it. If one is in the flesh, one cannot accept His words because the flesh wars against the Spirit, effectively cutting off the person from the source of life. Consequently, the flesh profits nothing because its end is death. Those who are in the Spirit receive life (Romans 8:6). To be “carnally minded” does not mean to be literally minded. It means to have a mind that is in rebellion against God. Those who were in such a state did not accept Jesus’s words.

God Bless,
Michael
 
***yes, i do… and if you have a problem with that…

you have a problem accepting a God who can prevent His Church from teaching error…***
Ok you can keep believing you do. And no I have faith God will correct and keep His Church from err in the end. God bless and peace be with you.
 
TobyLue, my thanks to you and, by extension, Michael, for this information. It is a worthy addition to the extensive exegetical defenses for a literal interpretation of John 6 that has accumulated throughout this thread. As you may or may not know, OP has been banned, and therefore will be unable to respond to your posts, although he may at least read them.

Such material that you have provided from Michael is just the sort of thing that OP required Catholics to submit to him, and yet he largely ignored when it happened. If you read my Posts #408 & 409, you will this documented. Suffice to say, even if OP were not banned, I doubt if he would have addressed your posts seeing as he didn’t address the others when he had the chance. To be fair, he did make several responses to a lot of material, but based on the evidence I presented in Posts 408 & 409, I think he intentionally avoided commenting on the strongest arguments in favor of a literal interpretation of John 6.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top