J
James_2_24
Guest
What does the Bible mean when it says that we should “Judge not”. This can mean one of two things:
In fact, I have come across this problem before. I once stated that a homosexual person was wrong for practicing homosexuality and homosexuality is disordered. Another Catholic told me, “you cannot judge people like that.” I responded, “Yes I can, what I can’t do is tell you they are going to hell for their actions… only God knows that. I do know what they are doing is objectively wrong… but I don’t know the state of their heart and mind… are they truly ignorant? do they not know any better? are they a little whacky upstairs? i don’t know any of that so I don’t know how culpable they are.”
The person really didn’t buy my argument, but he also went on to say I couldn’t say Protestant theology was wrong cause then I’d be judging them. I couldn’t believe it!
I also see a problem with definitin #2 listed above because when the Bible says, “By your fruits you shall know them” the Bible implies that we must judge based on people’s “fruits”.
- It means not to say whether or not a person is heaven or hell bound.
- It means not to say a person is objectively “wrong” in their practices.
In fact, I have come across this problem before. I once stated that a homosexual person was wrong for practicing homosexuality and homosexuality is disordered. Another Catholic told me, “you cannot judge people like that.” I responded, “Yes I can, what I can’t do is tell you they are going to hell for their actions… only God knows that. I do know what they are doing is objectively wrong… but I don’t know the state of their heart and mind… are they truly ignorant? do they not know any better? are they a little whacky upstairs? i don’t know any of that so I don’t know how culpable they are.”
The person really didn’t buy my argument, but he also went on to say I couldn’t say Protestant theology was wrong cause then I’d be judging them. I couldn’t believe it!
I also see a problem with definitin #2 listed above because when the Bible says, “By your fruits you shall know them” the Bible implies that we must judge based on people’s “fruits”.