Judgement

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sanctus_Vir
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sanctus_Vir

Guest
I would like to know peoples ideas about judging others. My own theory is that judging others would be as looking down upon them. Feeling sorry for people is also looking down upon them. It is said we mustn’t covet thy neighbor, wouldn’t that mean we shouldn’t look at them lower than yourself aswell? What do you think?
 
I would like to know peoples ideas about judging others. My own theory is that judging others would be as looking down upon them. Feeling sorry for people is also looking down upon them. It is said we mustn’t covet thy neighbor, wouldn’t that mean we shouldn’t look at them lower than yourself aswell? What do you think?
Hi
I agree with most of you post. We are nobody to judge others, we must try to save them and help them; if we look down upon them then we can neither hepl them nor save them. Let us leave the judgement to GodAllahYHWH to do it in the hereafter. We are all brothers in humanity.
Thanks

Muhammad had a marvelous record of a peace loving person for 40+13+2=55 years, he joined in welfare activities if there was any in Mecca, he helped the needy and in distress, he stood for the human cause, he never harmed any person. His record in these 55 years is clean by any standards.
 
I would like to know peoples ideas about judging others. My own theory is that judging others would be as looking down upon them. Feeling sorry for people is also looking down upon them. It is said we mustn’t covet thy neighbor, wouldn’t that mean we shouldn’t look at them lower than yourself aswell? What do you think?
I think feeling sorry for someone may lead to charity. Like giving aid to the hungry / homeless, stuff like that. But when we do that we are looking at building up the person; not so he is on the same level we are but building him up to ensure that his dignity as a human person is preserved. The whole “judging others” thing I think boils down to attitude. If I am judging someone with an attitude of, “I am so much better than Bob because Bob this and that,” then that’s a no-go. But if I am judging (or perhaps discerning is a better term here?) that Bob may need some help and I am drawn to charity then that is not only OK but required from me.
 
I would like to know peoples ideas about judging others. My own theory is that judging others would be as looking down upon them.
We judge on a daily basis. As humans, we receive information through our senses about the world around us. Based on that information, we analyze and act upon it. This is our personal form of judgment in daily life. Insofar as the human animal is concerned, this is normal and is wired into our instinctual desire to survive (a lower brain function and not upper).

On a greater scale, we have societal judgment. This is the basis for human law, regardless of society or culture.
Feeling sorry for people is also looking down upon them. It is said we mustn’t covet thy neighbor, wouldn’t that mean we shouldn’t look at them lower than yourself as well? What do you think?
As bjust rightfully points out, having empathy or sympathy for another’s plight is not a negative judgment (it is a judgment, for we have weighed evidence that leads us to conclude they are in need of help), but is rather judgment that leads us (hopefully) to the positive end of providing a charitable act.

Perhaps the question asked in the OP could better put as: what are the ethical and moral guides to judgment of things by man? How is the premise supported by Judeo-Christian Scripture?

To get that rolling, I point out that – in accordance to the Genesis account – we are created in God’s likeness. Ergo, we have the capacity to judge things of this Earth, as long as we do not judge Divine Purpose, nor God’s ultimate judgment for each of us individually and collectively (i.e., humankind).
 
god made us all the same as he said. That doesn’t mean that we stay the same though. I do believe that ones actions may steer them to a lower position on the earth but that it isn’t our job or right to be judging others. I believe it is for the Father to do. He is all that is divine and is the only one above us all, therefor he is the only one to have right to judge.
 
god made us all the same as he said. That doesn’t mean that we stay the same though. I do believe that ones actions may steer them to a lower position on the earth but that it isn’t our job or right to be judging others. I believe it is for the Father to do. He is all that is divine and is the only one above us all, therefor he is the only one to have right to judge.
The distinction is that God judges us for our eternal place in heaven. It is given to man to judge temporal things – hopefully using the morals and ethics given to us by Christ. “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s” creates that distinction from the secular daily life of man from man’s spiritual and eternal life … and it is God’s judgment that establishes what our final destination will be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top