Kneel to the Pope

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oblaidon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Over at “The Catholic Legate”, Catholic apologist Mark Bonocore addresses the question as a part of a longer piece on the authority of Peter and the papacy. An excerpt to the point:
. . . .as if it even needs to be said, those customs developed much later, when signs of respect given to any authoritative figure in the Roman and/or Gothic world (e.g. kissing a ring of office; kneeling, etc.) were directed toward the Papacy as well. We should not expect to see the same cultural expressions of respect given to a Jewish Apostle in the 1st Century. However, with that said, we do see Peter treated with special respect. For example, as I already mentioned above, in Acts 5:15, the sick of Jerusalem are brought out and placed on the ground so that Peter’s shadow might pass over them as he walks by. That doesn’t sound like just a regular guy, does it? Also, the other Apostles are not treated this way. Likewise, in Gal 1:18, Paul says how he spent fifteen days “conferring” with Kephas (Peter); and the Greek word here (“historesai”) means “to ask of a higher authority” --the same word which the pagan Greeks used when they consulted the Oracle of Delphi and other “divine” authorities. If Paul was merely meeting with an equal, he would have used the word “heiden.” Likewise, in Acts 15:12, after Peter gives the definitive teaching at the Council, it says that everyone “fell silent” (meaning that they remained silent: the past-tense aorist “esigese” in Greek, not “sigesai,” as used later in v. 13), and there is no more room for debate after Peter had spoken. And we could cite other examples as well.
However, the real problem here is that Mr. Cloud is taking his traditional, Protestant notions about a domineering, medieval-style Papacy (the “boogie-man” of Protestant tradition) and trying to apply that image to how Peter and his earliest successors operated in the first few centuries of the Church. Based on this, Mr. Cloud naturally (though unwisely) concludes that there was no early Papacy because we do not see Peter or the earliest Pope’s behaving like the medieval “enemy” of the Protestant “revolution.” However, what Mr. Cloud fails to realize here is that, after the days of Constantine, when frequently heretical Roman/Byzantine, Emperors tried to usurp headship over the Church, thereby blending world politics with Christian doctrine, and forcing the Church to define itself and to operate in worldly terms, the Popes of Rome were forced to change their leadership style from the pious and humble instructions of Jesus (i.e., “He who would be the first among you must become the SERVANT of all”) to the more secular, authoritative style of Papacy that Mr. Cloud’s Protestant ancestors encountered. And it was most necessary for the Popes to do this; for if they had not gone toe-to-toe with heretical Byzantine emperors, directly invoking their full authority as successors of Peter, and so acting like “emperors” themselves, the Church would have been overcome by heresy on numerous occasions. I will be happy to relate the specific history on that if Mr. Cloud requires.
However, before the late 300’s / early 400’s --that is, before the Church got involved in earthly politics, but was still an illegal, underground society, the earliest Popes (Peter included) did not advertise their authority in worldly ways, but typically exercised their authority in the humble and pious ways that Jesus initially instructed (see 1 Peter 5:1-4), because they could afford to do that. It was only in extreme cases (as when they needed to excommunicate someone) that Peter and the other early Popes put their foot down, and let their authority be seen. And this is why it is very difficult for Protestants to see a “Pope” in early Christianity --not because they didn’t exist (they clearly did), but because they did not typically exercise their authority in the style that Protestants expect of a Pope. . .
catholic-legate.com/dialogues/cloud.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top