Letting Go- Advice Sorely Needed

  • Thread starter Thread starter Norm640
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

Norm640

Guest
I posted this in vocations, but I post it here as well because 1)All topics in a community of Catholics discussed among members and in the spirit of fellowship are actually communications with God, which are prayers, 2)This section has the most people posting, 3)I am really lost and confused and need advice.

My ex girlfriend Olivia and I are still talking, even though we broke up in October of 2011. We were in a very long-distance relationship (Ohio- Mexico). I wanted to still be her friend because I knew it would hurt her to just break things off, and I was hoping she’d slowly realize I wasn’t the man for her and would find someone.

But that didn’t happen…over the past year and a half we’ve been OK as friends but every once in a while she’ll get upset at me if she sees me talking to someone on Facebook. And I just can’t stand that stuff.

She told me Sunday that she’s never been friends with her ex boyfriends and that she can’t be mine. I said OK. I understood. And I told her I really cared about her, and that the only thing I want is her happiness. I thought this was a sign that finally we would go our separate ways.

But then, once again, she writes me today and acts like nothing is wrong. When confronted, she told me she couldn’t stop writing me. I am in complete agony, because I don’t want to tell her once and for all to stop writing me, but on the other hand I know that she still loves me and keeps me in her world to torture herself- either in hoping for a relationship or by conjuring up all of these things I might or might not be doing.

I tried to explain to her that this is unhealthy, and that my staying with her would hurt her, because she deserves a man that loves her as much as she loves. I was with her for 2 years, I flew to Mexico five times. From the beginning I didn’t feel comfortable with her, but I was open to it because I had never been in a relationship before and thought maybe as we knew each other better I might develop some chemistry. I never did.

Even her mother wondered why we didn’t talk, lol.

This absolutely breaks my heart because she has dedicated her life to me. It is too much. Way too much for me. I have prayed and prayed and prayed for God to help her, I’ve prayed for her happiness. I spent two months doing this every day with various novenas…

I am not meant to be with anyone right now, maybe not ever, but Olivia is, I know this. But because she is 40 now she thinks she’ll never be married and most certainly won’t have children. And I feel like I’m to blame.

I just hate feeling like her happiness depends solely on me…I don’t know what to do. And I am telling you because there are no women in my life to tell, except my niece, who has no moral center and tells me just to ignore her, lol.

How can I not hurt her feelings? How can I make her see that this can’t work? How do I not devastate her? What can I do?

Thanks for your help…
 
Really. No advice. Nothing…Hokay…I guess I’m on my own here.
 
Really. No advice. Nothing…Hokay…I guess I’m on my own here.
Patience! You only just posted - give people time to find it. I haven’t read your post in detail, I’ll be back when I have.
 
Hi! You mention she is 40, you don’t say how old you are.

I am a Mexican who married an American. We “dated” long distance for less than a year. I was 27, he was 36. I knew we were going to know quickly whether we were going to make it or not. We have been married for 13 years and we have 3 children.

Nobody can make you “responsible” for his/her happiness. Our happiness comes from God and from knowing His love. If you truly don’t feel like this is the woman for you and you have seen that letting go “softly” won’t work, be firm. You don’t have to be rude or humiliate her in any way, but you have to be firm. If she can’t be friends, then just, at least for now, don’t be. According to what you mention, I think, in my humble opinion, that is what would be best for both of you.
 
That was my question as well. How old are you?

Look, there is really only one way to break it off, and that’s to break it off. Stop communicating with her. Unfriend her on FB, or put your account on dormant for a while. Or do both. Send her a text that you won’t be taking her calls any more. You have to cut it off, or it’s just going to drag on and on, which is not good for either of you. Whatever the reasons, you know it’s not going to work. She probably knows it too, but you are a crutch for her. Change your phone number if you have to. Do what it takes. Do it with kindness, but do it.

p.s. If you’ve only known her for 2 years, she was 38 when you met her, so you are hardly responsible for her not being married or having children. Please don’t take that on. It’s not yours.
 
I agree with the other posters I think you are better off to make a clean break–she is probably hoping you will change your mind and dragging it out will only make it worse for her in the long term.You are not doing her any favours and you need to gently close this chapter of your life.

Thoughts and prayers to you in this difficult time.
 
Hello Norm640, I maybe able to give you some good advice. After reading your post, I noticed that you keep mentioning that you are afraid of hurting her, but did you know that you are hurting her much much more by not letting go.

Stop listening to any guilt trips she is laying on you, did you know that many people use guilt to manipulate people to get control over them? This is not something that is done out of love, and is not a healthy state of being for either one of you. Do you really want to be used and manipulated that way?

You are also not showing much honor to yourself because you are expected and supposed to take care of yourself first, I don’t mean that in a selfish way but if you don’t you are the one who is going to be hurt the most.

Do what you want, but if you really want to stop hurting her and yourself, break it off ASAP and stop being so “nice” about it, you’re just making it harder than it has to be.

Dear God, please give this man and wisdom and courage to do what he already knows he must do. Amen
 
I just prayed 3 Hail Marys and a special prayer for you. May Our Lady help you to part peacefully with your ex-girlfriend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top