Loatheing alcohol

  • Thread starter Thread starter djamu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

djamu

Guest
I wish alcohol didn’t exist. I am a relative of an alcoholic, he comes home drunk every night he is at our house. this alcoholic happens to be my brother. 😦 he’s sposed to be a role model for me. I’m lucky I was taught about that stuff early. I loathe alcohol. I hate is so much, that no matter what happens in my life I am never ever going to try it. peepz that haven’t tried it, don’t. you gonna wish you hadn’t.
 
I’m sorry about your brother, but as a responsible drinker, I cannot echo your sentiments.
Alcohol is vital to our salvation. If you think about it, we only really need 5 things, wine, wheat, water, oil, and men. In fact, you could say we have been destined to have all five from all eternity, as the sacraments have always been in God’s plan for our salvation. Therefore, Alcohol has always been in God’s plan.
Alcohol is not intrinsically evil. Misuse of Alcohol is sinful, much like misuse of sex is sinful.
You need to have an intervention for your brother. Getting drunk every night is abusing his body, a temple of the Holy Spirit.
You, and your brother will be in my prayers.

Yours in Christ,
Thursday
 
My family has dealt with this curse for at least 3 generations that I know of. Al Anon for relatives of alcoholics, and Al A Teen for children of alcoholics are real life-savers and I highly recommend them.
 
I wish alcohol didn’t exist. I am a relative of an alcoholic, he comes home drunk every night he is at our house. this alcoholic happens to be my brother. 😦 he’s sposed to be a role model for me. I’m lucky I was taught about that stuff early. I loathe alcohol. I hate is so much, that no matter what happens in my life I am never ever going to try it. peepz that haven’t tried it, don’t. you gonna wish you hadn’t.
As the daughter of an alcoholic, I used to feel exactly the same way. But for those who are not themselves alcoholics, there is a healthy approach to alcohol that doesn’t involve swearing completely off the stuff. It took me years to reach that point, after I learned to get past the anger.
 
I sympathise with you. I’ve had some other types of addictions and problems spanning generations in my family. We’re all moderate drinkers though. In moderation it has all sorts of great health benefits - those who have three or four standard drinks a week are generally healthier than teetotallers.

And Christ couldn’t have chosen an inherently sinful thing to use in the Eucharist, could he …

But I do second the recommendation of Al-Anon or Al-A-Teen for you. Those guys do some fantastic work.
 
If he doesn’t want to use alcohol good for him. Hes not trying to fight the matter which becomes the body and blood. He’s just saying he won’t drink alcohol (and in communion you don’t drink alcohol you drink blood, so thats a moot point.) When is the last time y’all’ve been to a college campus? Do you have any idea just how bad binge drinking is? Some havn’t had a sucessfull weekend unless they wake up in a stranger’s aparment with their head over the toilet.

I find what he is doing commendable, and even a natural response in some environments.

Saint Monica is the patron saint for alcholics.
 
Abstaining from alcohol might be an occasion of merit, but not if it is tied to a heretical notion that drinking alcohol is evil in and of itself. By focusing on alcohol it becomes a reverse idolatry in a manner of speaking. That is, instead of taking an inanimate object and worshipping it as God, it is taking an inanimate object and turning it into a devil. It avoids the truth–that our fallen nature gives us the tendancy to take perfectly legitimate things and ruin them by being immoderate and disordered.

Scott
 
My family has dealt with this curse for at least 3 generations that I know of. Al Anon for relatives of alcoholics, and Al A Teen for children of alcoholics are real life-savers and I highly recommend them.
This is an excellent suggestion.

OP: You say your brother is supposed to be a role model for you. It would be nice if our siblings would be another kind of parent for us, but as long as your brother abuses alcohol by choice, that isn’t going to happen. If he is an alcoholic, it may even be beyond what is in his power to do right now. As long as he relies on his own power, that is not going to change.

Al-Anon will help you sort out what, in living a life of love, you can and can’t realistically expect of yourself and your alcoholic loved one. It will give you role models for living your healthy life in the midst of someone who isn’t. I really encourage you to find a group near you.

As for whether alcohol were never invented…well, what would have been is what was. Changing the Constitution to outlaw it did not make it go away. It is something we have to deal with.

My own father and mother drink daily, except during Advent and Lent. I have never seen either one drunk*, and as far as I know, neither one has been. They are both over 70. I have an uncle and aunt, though, who are alcoholics. They have had to give it up entirely…but they did give it up, and of their own free will. Using alcohol responsibly, like using food or sexuality or power responsibly, is a choice. There is something that tempts all of us. Remember, too, that alcoholism and alcohol abuse are about much more than the alcohol. It is the lot of most alcoholics to compulsively try what won’t work until they finally get to a point that they realize it is time to run up the white flag and face the real problem that drives them into the arms of alcohol. If it weren’t alcohol, if your brother could not get that, it might well be something else, perhaps even something worse.

You’ll find all of this out if you get some help from people who have been through and who are going through something like what you are suffering. Don’t face this alone.

(*I have seen my mother drunk once. She has dementia now, and was at a function where alcohol was offered to her. No one thought to help her keep track of how much she had had, because we were not used to her recent lack of short-term memory and self-awareness preventing her from doing it herself. Her over-consumption was not her fault, but ours.)
 
I wish alcohol didn’t exist. I am a relative of an alcoholic, he comes home drunk every night he is at our house. this alcoholic happens to be my brother. 😦 he’s sposed to be a role model for me. I’m lucky I was taught about that stuff early. I loathe alcohol. I hate is so much, that no matter what happens in my life I am never ever going to try it. peepz that haven’t tried it, don’t. you gonna wish you hadn’t.
Two things:

If the moment presents itself try and get him into AA

You should attend some Al-Anon meetings asap. You are letting your brothers problem become your problem
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top