Loyalty to one's diocese and one's bishop

  • Thread starter Thread starter jab42483
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jab42483

Guest
Does one owe loyalty to the bishop of the diocese in which one resides? I know several Catholic friends who drive out of our diocese to attend Mass. These individuals also bash the bishop of the diocese in which we all reside as being absent, etc.
Having reflected on obedience, I would think it would be, in a sense disobedient to travel across diocese lines and support parishes when you have three local parishes. These parishes aren’t the most beautiful liturgically, but nothing heretical. Your thoughts?
 
We can attend mass at any Catholic church, though we remain members of the parish and diocese in whose territory we actually reside. Occasionally one may encounter inconveniences if one regularly attends a parish that is not one’s own, when it comes to marriage or baptisms or things like that.

Anyway, I think we definitely need to make an effort to be respectful to our pastors, both our priests and our bishops. Over all greater respect and deference is probably what we need more of. But that doesn’t mean we should go to the opposite extreme and regard any suggestion that a bishop is not impeccable, either morally or prudently, as a sort of blasphemy. In the United States in particular we have undeniably come face to face with episcopal mismanagement and sin. To blind or gag ourselves regarding those problems would be rightly seen by outsiders as creepy and fanatical.

Of course, it’s also true that sometimes what is right is not always popular. In my own diocese we’ve seen massive parish and school closings. While I sometimes disagree with the choices and criteria we have seen regarding these decisions, it is obvious that with such an extreme priest shortage as we have in this diocese some of this did need to happen. Also there is a feeling, out here in the more distant, western part of the diocese, that our bishop ignores us (the feeling can be especially bitter in remote parishes, such as my own, that have not had a parish priest for a long time). This is, in my opinion, mainly an inevitable effect of distance and comparatively sparse population, combined with a feeling as old as the colonial era that no one in Albany knows or cares about anything west of Schenectady.
 
I recall a “rule” of the Church that we are required to attend the Catholic parish closest to us most regularly, except for special occasions and such. We can attend another Catholic parish regularly if we get specific permission from the Bishop.

This implies that driving out of the diocese for the purpose of avoiding a diocese’s parishes is illicit. If the Bishop were immoral or something, even then not all of his parishes would be complicent (sp?) in his immorality or abberation.
 
I recall a “rule” of the Church that we are required to attend the Catholic parish closest to us most regularly, except for special occasions and such. We can attend another Catholic parish regularly if we get specific permission from the Bishop.

This implies that driving out of the diocese for the purpose of avoiding a diocese’s parishes is illicit. If the Bishop were immoral or something, even then not all of his parishes would be complicent (sp?) in his immorality or abberation.
That is not the case in all archdioceses. My archdiocese has the following “rule” about which parish one can belong to:
" …a person can belong to a parish in three ways: by one’s street address, by regularly attending a parish outside of the pre-determined boundaries and registering there, and finally, where they attend Mass if a person is without a permanent residence."
 
I recall a “rule” of the Church that we are required to attend the Catholic parish closest to us most regularly, except for special occasions and such. We can attend another Catholic parish regularly if we get specific permission from the Bishop.

This implies that driving out of the diocese for the purpose of avoiding a diocese’s parishes is illicit. If the Bishop were immoral or something, even then not all of his parishes would be complicent (sp?) in his immorality or abberation.
I have never heard of such a thing! My family moved to Miami in 1940. Because of the location of our house on N. Miami Ave., we were in Corpus Christi Parish (before their Church and School were built). At that time, Sunday Mass was held in a Movie Theater. However to get to that Church from our house the trip took two bus lines and a 7 block walk. Now, to most of you, a 7 block walk is not much, but in the tropics…
Anyway, I attended Parochial school at Gesu, in Downtown Miami, and my family attended Mass at Gesu Church because it took only a 15 minute bus ride from our corner to get there.
Our home became the “home away from home” for the priests of Gesu. It was no big thing for me to come home from school to se Father So-and-So wearing a Hawaiian shirt, relaxing in a beach chair in our back yard, reading the newspaper. Many times a Parish priest from Gesu would help me with my math or Latin homework. We would usually have a priest at our dinner table most nights.
The point of all of this is that I never heard that one needed a Bishop’s permission to regularly attend a parish other than one in the Diocese in which one lives, etc., If that were so, how could Catholic travelers, or sailors legitimately attend Mass in other places for that matter?
 
Does one owe loyalty to the bishop of the diocese in which one resides? I know several Catholic friends who drive out of our diocese to attend Mass. These individuals also bash the bishop of the diocese in which we all reside as being absent, etc.
Having reflected on obedience, I would think it would be, in a sense disobedient to travel across diocese lines and support parishes when you have three local parishes. These parishes aren’t the most beautiful liturgically, but nothing heretical. Your thoughts?
Many threads have been dedicated to which parish are you supposed to belong. I’ve been through it myself, and it caused some very painful experiences for me and my family.

The more important part of this is, to me, is the obedience to the Bishop. I live in a metro area that has two dioceses: one on each side of the state line. One diocese has had some major issues that did involve the Bishop, and I still have some problems with it. However, I’ve attended Mass in both diocese, with no problem. It’s hard for me not to ‘bash’ one particular parish and leadership, due to my own personal and painful interactions with them. However, I realize that their own fruits will come to bear in due time; when I’m asked by other laypeople why we are not members of XXXX, I have an answer that does not bash the parish or people, although my views are quite honest and valid. Does it serve anything for me to air my grievances to friends or strangers?

Long story short: Don’t ‘bash’ other priests or such; even if it’s true, it isn’t helpful. Be very careful in this. Also, don’t judge others by their actions of going to another parish; it doesn’t hurt you, and their reasons behind it may not be clear, although still quite legit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top