Madame de Guyon

Status
Not open for further replies.
So last night I went to the local Flame of Love prayer cenacle which is held at a fairly progressive parish and run by an elderly deacon who has impressed me as being a pious, devout and prayerful man (this is not true of all deacons I’ve ever met). During the cenacle, the deacon spoke on what seemed to be contemplative prayer (without using the term) and talked about St. Francis de Sales and then some historical Catholics who weren’t saints but whose spirituality was influenced by St. Francis de Sales. One of the people the deacon talked about for several minutes was Madame Guyon, who he said was “imprisoned by the Church for seven years” including a couple in solitary, and she used prayer/ her relationship with God to get her through this hardship.

I hadn’t heard of this person before and was wondering how someone would go from being imprisoned by the Church to being praised at a holy hour for her prayer life and held up as a model for Catholics, so I looked her up and it appears from what I read she got in the middle of one of those power struggles involving some bishops, the Pope and Louis XIV and not only was she imprisoned but was regularly threatened with being burnt at the stake for heresy. Her writings also ended up on the Church’s forbidden book list. I am rather dim I know, but it’s hard for me to understand how simply praying in a contemplative way gets you all this grief (it’s not like she invented it since she studied St. Teresa of Avila and St. Francis de Sales). She also remained loyal to the Catholic Church her whole life despite all this mess and died in the Church.

Anybody familiar with this lady? I couldn’t find anything where the Church had ever said maybe they were wrong to persecute her. I note that Google Search brought up a past CAF thread on her but it apparently didn’t survive the move as the link comes up as “doesn’t exist or is private”, so I don’t know what was said before on here.
 
Last edited:
I did find an old thread on her here
40.png
Jeanne Guyon?? Spirituality
I own a couple of books by her including one on prayer and her autobiography. I am a bit puzzled that she is not referenced a tad more often by Roman Catholics. She is explicitly Catholic yet seems more favored by Protestant readers than Catholic. Is there a reason? From her autobiography I deduce she somehow generated a great deal of hostility in her lifetime. . I don’t spot any obvious heresies however. She seems to have been a pious ‘society woman’ who was too centered on her faith to trouble…
And another here where she is mentioned in a discussion of Brother Lawrence who was another person discussed by the deacon.
40.png
Practice of the Presence of God translation Spirituality
Hey, Y’all, I have carried Practice of the Presence of God all over the world with me, but have noticed several translations. Any recommendations for a modern one? Which is best? Blessings, Anneg
Whole thing seems silly, even though the Pope at that time seems to have been better than average for that era (not sure that is saying much though)
 
From what I have read about her, her writings were thought to promote Quietism, or complete passivity to God’s action in one’s life, which the Church has long condemned. Nowadays, I think some people see her as an example of the patriarchal church suppressing a woman, but it does seem like some of her ideas were on the fringe, such as her apparent indifference to the hope of eternal salvation. Admittedly, I have not read much of what she wrote, but it sounds like one would need to discern whatever is useful from what might be erroneous.
 
I found this rather unflattering essay on her and other Quietists, paints a rather different picture than the deacon did last night amd less flattering than some of the other writings about her. I suspect maybe the truth is in the middle somewhere, but in any event, it wasn’t worth throwing people in prison, which from all accounts was quite horrific then. At least no one seems to have gotten burned at the stake.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top