Marital Sex

  • Thread starter Thread starter TruthSkr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
To be clear for readers, the catechism of the Catholic Church says in #2352 (dealing with masturbation).

“To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety, or other ***psychological or social factors ***that can lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability.”

Look, all I am saying is that a good Catholic can take this to a confessor or spiritual director and get pastoral guidance. He may suggest he seek a pharmaceutical or therapeutic remedy or there may be spiritual guidance.
That is not about this subject. The thread is what about married couples who are unable for one reason or another to engage in marital relations. It is absolutely the case the as not noted for readers that if any of them thought one could seek climax in such circumstances. Such would be gravely sinful.
 
Why is it every time I make a point that can’t be refuted, someone says that its not the subject of the thread.
Well in this case what your discussing is not what the thread is about - so no need to discuss it.
OK, so let’s go back to the OP and see what he did say…

“If I understand correctly, a Catholic man who is unable to have intercourse with his wife because of impotence, can no longer have sex with his wife because he will commit a mortal sin if he ejaculates outside her body. Protestants, on the other hand, have no such rule, I have read.”

The point that I challenge is that while the Church teaches that it would be sinful to not finish the marital act properly, the sin can be mitigated to something less. Again, read CCC#2358. If this God given law of chastity could never be violated for any reason, why does the Catechism suggest pastoral solutions?
You cited the wrong CCC number there. That is about homosexuality. But I know the one you meant for you quoted it other places.

The CCC does not suggest pastoral solutions for such.

The Law of chastity as you put it yes is a negative precept that admits of absolutely no exceptions. The article there you mention is about possible mitigation of culpability in say a person whose habit of self abuse or other psychological reason etc may lessen the sinfulness of the particular act due to the lack of freedom. They would discuss such with their confessor who will assist them in overcoming this difficulty and judge etc. It REMAINS contrary to chastity and but is not a “license” to continue that habit. It just may be that the person does not have freedom at the moment and may not in such acts be committing a mortal sin (be guilty of such). This MAY be the case in such. Such is still contrary to Chastity and is never permitted. Chastity may not be voilated for any reason.
Your dogmatic responses are not very convincing since you never cite any sources that show that your position is consistent with Church teaching. I get the sense that you (and others) are spewing opinions as fact.
What I have noted is the long teaching of the Catholic Church. See the Catechism on chastity, and various works of Moral Theology.
 
Here’s my last go at explaining it.

Emphases mine.

“Pastoral solutions” don’t change the quality of an act. There is an object, an intention, and a circumstance. I get the idea that you are saying that there is some fourth aspect to speciate a moral act called “pastoral solution.” There isn’t. I can seek advice, counseling, therapy, absolution, etc., but what the morality of what I do depends on my will, my intellect, my passions, the time, place, manner in which I do what I do, and so on. Now, it could happen that someone asks someone who ought to know better but doesn’t, and he is given bad advice. This would possibly lessen the responsibility on the part of the moral agent, but the counselor, especially if he is a cleric, would have committed a grave fault. Read Mk. 9:42…

Life challenges are not “applied.” They occur. Interesting that you say that the sin of abortion could never have its culpability mitigated, when this is one of the clearest examples when it could be. “If you don’t have an abortion, I will disown you as my daughter.” “If you don’t have an abortion, I will kill you.” “If you don’t have an abortion, I will put you on the street.” Those are some major, major stresses that would, in a normal person, greatly inhibit interior freedom to deliberate rationally and will freely, combined with the indoctrination of the culture of death which could arguably lessen culpability even more. Objectively grave matter, definitely. Objectively grave sin for this actual individual moral agent, much harder to say. Then again, as the Apostle says, “They are without excuse…”

Again, a “pastoral solution” is not a wand that is waved over an act that is objectively grave matter to make it all okay. The pope could tell me it’s okay for me to fornicate since I’m a young man surrounded by beautiful women, which is a challenging situation for me and therefore deserves that “pastoral solution,” but he would be wrong. A pastoral solution is the help given to someone to form his conscience in line with the Church’s teaching and to provide him with the spiritual (and sometimes material) resources necessary to flourish as a Christian in a given difficult situation, especially a case in which a rightly formed conscience urges a commission or omission that is challenging. A pastoral solution could also involve navigating a situation that involves the measurement of goods calling for a prudential judgment, such as, “Many people will be offended if I close this parish, but it will help the health of my diocese. What do I do, and how exactly do I go about doing it?” (Let’s pray for our bishops.) There is no prudential judgment to be had here: it is an intrinsically grave object which no circumstance or intent could justify, as it purposefully severs the procreative aspect of human sexuality from the marital act, thus reordering the moral agent away from the Author of life Who created us with that in-built purpose. Give Humanae Vitae a serious study if you need more explanation. This stuff is all old news. I’m peacin’ out. Merry Christmas!
Jesus gave the Church the ability not only to bind sins, but to loose, as well. You can read chapter and verse about what the Church teaches on a particular moral topic, but the truth is, we live in a complicated world where a sin committed by one person carries more guilt than the same sin committed by someone else.

I have cited examples; here is one more…A man steals a car to go on a joy ride so as to impress his friends. Another steals a loaf of bread to feed his family. Forget about the “intrinsically evil” the act contains and consider the sinner themselves. How would Christ judge each of those men?

I sense from our Holy Father an urging to become less hardcore judgmental and more understanding and welcoming of the sinner. That is the challenge. Sure it’s easy to condemn someone’s sin based on some legalistic interpretation. But, if we see the sinner as Jesus sees him with a compassionate heart, I suspect that the individual who could not complete the marriage act as perfectly as you think he should would not be condemned.

And, that is germane to the OP’s question and it is what I have been trying to say all along. I see a man doing the best he can to express his love for his wife.
You say “crucify him”!
 
Jesus gave the Church the ability not only to bind sins, but to loose, as well.
Yes - via Confession one can repent - I mean repent (resolve not to commit the mortal sin or any mortal sin again) - and yes then the sin can be forgiven.

The Church was not given the authority to bind and loose that which cannot be changed. The Church cannot say a man lusting after some woman is not objectively gravely sinful…
The Church cannot say murder is not objectively gravely sinful…
The Church cannot say direct abortion is not objectively gravely sinful…
The Church cannot say that one can seek a climax outside the context of the marital act (see my post above).

Period.

Jesus did not give that kind of authority to the Church.

As the Church herself teaches.
I have cited examples; here is one more…A man steals a car to go on a joy ride so as to impress his friends. Another steals a loaf of bread to feed his family. Forget about the “intrinsically evil” the act contains and consider the sinner themselves. How would Christ judge each of those men?
The first is stealing. Objectively that is yes sinful.

The second can simply be Not stealing. Be a* different* moral object. Where it is not that “theft here is ok” but that it is Not theft by definition.

2408 The seventh commandment forbids theft, that is, usurping another’s property against the reasonable will of the owner.** There is no theft** if consent can be presumed or if refusal is contrary to reason and the universal destination of goods. This is the case in obvious and urgent necessity when the only way to provide for immediate, essential needs (food, shelter, clothing . . .) is to put at one’s disposal and use the property of others.

scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a7.htm#2408

Seeking climax in disordered ways - is never ok. Never chaste. It is gravely wrong. Period. No intention or circumstance can make it good.

CCC:

II. GOOD ACTS AND EVIL ACTS

1755 A morally good act requires the goodness of the object, of the end, and of the circumstances together. An evil end corrupts the action, even if the object is good in itself (such as praying and fasting “in order to be seen by men”).

The object of the choice can by itself vitiate an act in its entirety. There are some concrete acts - such as fornication - that it is always wrong to choose, because choosing them entails a disorder of the will, that is, a moral evil.

1756 It is therefore an error to judge the morality of human acts by considering only the intention that inspires them or the circumstances (environment, social pressure, duress or emergency, etc.) which supply their context. There are acts which, in and of themselves, independently of circumstances and intentions, are always gravely illicit by reason of their object; such as blasphemy and perjury, murder and adultery. One may not do evil so that good may result from it.

scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s1c1a4.htm#1752
I sense from our Holy Father an urging to become less hardcore judgmental and more understanding and welcoming of the sinner. That is the challenge. Sure it’s easy to condemn someone’s sin based on some legalistic interpretation.
One is not judging persons - but acts. If a deliberate act is evil - that is what it is.

Yes welcoming the sinner! Amen! Thanks be to God for the grace of repentance and Confession!
But, if we see the sinner as Jesus sees him with a compassionate heart, I suspect that the individual who could not complete the marriage act as perfectly as you think he should would not be condemned.
Again it is a different case where a married couple thought they could have relations and tried and were unable to do so…(and did not seek or consent to any disordered climax).

Than a couple who cannot have relations who then deliberately engage in disordered actions seeking to have a climax. Such is always and everywhere objectively gravely sinful. It is a misuse of the sexual faculties and is contrary to their marriage and chastity.

Jesus was quite serious about even lustful looking…and about avoiding other serious sins…(if your eye causes you to sin…pluck it out …he said in that hyperbolic way to make the point…).
 
Jesus gave the Church the ability not only to bind sins, but to loose, as well. You can read chapter and verse about what the Church teaches on a particular moral topic, but the truth is, we live in a complicated world where a sin committed by one person carries more guilt than the same sin committed by someone else.

I have cited examples; here is one more…A man steals a car to go on a joy ride so as to impress his friends. Another steals a loaf of bread to feed his family. Forget about the “intrinsically evil” the act contains and consider the sinner themselves. How would Christ judge each of those men?

I sense from our Holy Father an urging to become less hardcore judgmental and more understanding and welcoming of the sinner. That is the challenge. Sure it’s easy to condemn someone’s sin based on some legalistic interpretation. But, if we see the sinner as Jesus sees him with a compassionate heart, I suspect that the individual who could not complete the marriage act as perfectly as you think he should would not be condemned.

And, that is germane to the OP’s question and it is what I have been trying to say all along. I see a man doing the best he can to express his love for his wife.
You say “crucify him”!
Your theology and rationale is at odds with the posters here and also at odds with the universal church God gimself established. They are however in line with Protestant theology and the rationale of realativism. Does any of that give you pause? Does it awaken a humbleness and submissiveness within you? Or does your pride insist that you are right and all of us and the church and the entirety of salvation history is wrong?
Why do you assume today’s challenges sexually, is greater than at any time in history?
 
I think I have made my point abundantly clear. But, let me try one last time. The OP referenced this sin as being mortal, thus having an everlasting impact on our salvation if not confessed as opposed to a Protestant understanding where there is no standard since there is no Biblical reference. If a pastoral solution can be applied to mitigate the sin then it is no longer mortal. Bear in mind, missing Mass on Sunday is also grave matter but can be mitigated for specific circumstances.

There are acts, however, that the Church teaches are intrinsically evil. In a word, they are always wrong and any life challenges could not be applied to mitigate or lessen the seriousness of the sin. Abortion is one such example.

The case the OP raises concerning a physiological impediment may be one that deserves consideration for a pastoral solution by a qualified spiritual counselor such as a priest. Such a person, however, is empowered by the Church to make a prudential judgment as evidenced in the CCC.
That is in fact the reality. The internal forum, that is a person under spiritual direction, is a legitimate light for conscience and reason and discernment. It’s the correct place for an encounter with the just but merciful God in impossible situations.

I think a lot of people on the thread would die of shock to know how the internal forum works as part of the relationship between priests and people. But the goal is to grow closer to God and that is reflected in a persons grasp of love of neighbour.

That should definitely be an important part of this thread and not a separate discussion altogether.
 
That is in fact the reality. The internal forum, that is a person under spiritual direction, is a legitimate light for conscience and reason and discernment. It’s the correct place for an encounter with the just but merciful God in impossible situations.
Leading the person in confession to the truth - with love.

Helping them form their conscience according to the teachings of Jesus and his Church.

Assisting them to live them …to repent and believe the Gospel!

Yes the light to Truth is splendid and enlightens us in our darkness…
 
Leading the person in confession to the truth - with love.

Helping them form their conscience according to the teachings of Jesus and his Church.

Assisting them to live them …to repent and believe the Gospel!

Yes the light to Truth is splendid and enlightens us in our darkness…
I get your point. I agree with church teaching regarding sexual morality. Going to confession is a good thing. I’m not trying to subvert anything. All I am saying is that circumstances arise that lessen the degree of culpability. Thus, grave matter can be mitigated to something less. Killing, stealing, missing Mass are all very serious matters but each of these can be at most venial given the circumstances of a situation. This is not a one size fits all case.

If the OP’s assumption that the Catholic understanding is that the person who committed this sin was automatically damned…well that is not necessarily so.
 
I get your point. I agree with church teaching regarding sexual morality. Going to confession is a good thing. I’m not trying to subvert anything. All I am saying is that circumstances arise that lessen the degree of culpability. Thus, grave matter can be mitigated to something less. Killing, stealing, missing Mass are all very serious matters but each of these can be at most venial given the circumstances of a situation. This is not a one size fits all case.

If the OP’s assumption that the Catholic understanding is that the person who committed this sin was automatically damned…well that is not necessarily so.
Again, this is different than your first post. #12 of the thread. In that post you say it should be ok. And that there is “no problem” with it. This is quite different than your current posts. And it should be! We all can learn through conversation. Sometimes legalism is part of the mercy…
Culpability should be dicerned in the confessional. So the answer, the merciful answer is to encourage people to find mercy in the church and that is done in the confessional because sin is sin. You cannot take sin and say that it is ok or not evil or even holy. Which is what you were doing in previous posts.
 
Leading the person in confession to the truth - with love.

Helping them form their conscience according to the teachings of Jesus and his Church.

Assisting them to live them …to repent and believe the Gospel!

Yes the light to Truth is splendid and enlightens us in our darkness…
There are times in the internal forum where people are directed to follow their conscience and not commanded one way or the other. I know that to be true and in keeping with Church teaching. A good spiritual director has a grasp of two things. The Church law and the unique relationship of the person and God. The internal forum is a very important part of Catholic life but also very private and sacred. Myself, I will always tend to complete obedience and severe self judgement because of my formation, but I don’t feel better than others who I can easily see are more loving and generous than me, but are afflicted by a certain ignorance and suffering that I’m not. I truly believe that God sees that distinction too.

DIGNITATIS HUMANAE
 
There are times in the internal forum where people are directed to follow their conscience and not commanded one way or the other. I know that to be true and in keeping with Church teaching. A good spiritual director has a grasp of two things. The Church law and the unique relationship of the person and God. The internal forum is a very important part of Catholic life but also very private and sacred. Myself, I will always tend to complete obedience and severe self judgement because of my formation, but I don’t feel better than others who I can easily see are more loving and generous than me, but are afflicted by a certain ignorance and suffering that I’m not. I truly believe that God sees that distinction too.

DIGNITATIS HUMANAE
Sure a conscience that is formed well by the Churches Teachings - that has that light already but is faced say with two different good things to choose from etc.

Yes confession and the direction of a Penitent by his confessor in following Christ faithfully in his Church is a great gift. A Confessor yes can be very helpful in assisting both penitents who are already quite faithful to Christ and his Church as well as those who are in difficult situations and need light and a great amount of formation - to also follow him.

We all can have blind spots or need counsel in how to follow Christ faithfully - a confessor can be very helpful in the internal forum. Assisting his penitents to leave the darkness and know the light of the good news or to know more fully that light and how to live the truth…how to follow Christ in all the various difficulties that one finds along the path.

In this case there is no question - ones conscience would be in error if one thought one could seek a climax when one cannot have marital relations - so that would be rather an error to correct.
 
The original post asked about the distinction between a Catholic understanding of the marital embrace versus a Protestant understanding. The point I am trying to raise is that, based on the example posed, the Catholic understanding is not as rigid as you make it out to be. That is important if we are to provide a suitable answer to question.

As I see it, the purpose behind the law is to respect and preserve the procreative aspect of the act. But, when it is impossible to accomplish that, a pastoral solution may be in order. Catholics have an obligation to attend Mass on all Sundays. But, when satisfying that obligation is not possible or another obligation precludes it, a pastoral solution suggests that it is not mortally sinful. A mother, who needs to care for small children may be exempted from the obligation to attend Mass on a particular Sunday. No one is suggesting that the law of needing to observe the Lord’s Day is ignored or excused away. Simply that these laws must exist within the framework of serving God’s people. When we carry it to a legalistic extreme, we place unfair and unrealistic burdens on people.

I will say, that I am not qualified to make the distinction in any particular case. I simply mean to point out that pastoral solutions do exist that would minimize the spiritual impact of not following the letter of the law.
Once they are sure that impotence will always prevent penetration and finishing inside they are called to avoid situations where they will be tempted to sin and commit mutual maturbation. If that means that they are limited to cuddles and chaste kisses, so be it.
 
I get your point. I agree with church teaching regarding sexual morality. Going to confession is a good thing. I’m not trying to subvert anything. All I am saying is that circumstances arise that lessen the degree of culpability. Thus, grave matter can be mitigated to something less. Killing, stealing, missing Mass are all very serious matters but each of these can be at most venial given the circumstances of a situation. This is not a one size fits all case.

If the OP’s assumption that the Catholic understanding is that the person who committed this sin was automatically damned…well that is not necessarily so.
As I explained regarding your example of theft - what you were giving as an example can simply be “not theft”. It is never that theft is ok in some circumstances. But that such and such (see the CCC) is NOT theft.

As to missing Mass - that is a “positive precept” of the Church which admits of exeptions. The Obligation *ceases *in those exceptions for as long as the exception lasts (say being sick). Thus no sin.

Killing can happen where there is no sin.

Murder on the other hand can never be done - such is gravely wrong all the time. Now can it happen that something will cause the culpability to be lessened where it is even not a mortal sin? Yes. In examining the particular murder one judges that one did not commit a mortal sin due to xyz (if one commits murder - I will still bring the matter to confession!!) But one cannot then say to oneself - oh my culpability is lessened so I can murder…such is likely actually to increase ones culpability!

Can there be that which lessens the culpability of a person who has done Y grave matter? Yes. But sure. Can it even mean that there was venial sin not mortal? Sure.

But one cannot then say “oh well it is not a mortal sin for me (though it is grave matter) so I will go do it”…that is not something that should be done.

And as I noted the seeking of climax when one is unable to have marital relations will always be gravely contrary to their marriage and to chastity. Now can it happen that a particular persons culpability for their fall on Tues was reduced to a venial sin for some reason? Yes is could happen. But that does not change the grave nature of the act.

The point of the thread I think way Catholics cannot do what some Protestants think they can do -which is a different matter than we have been lately discussing. To that I answered:
And if some Protestant Christian communities allow for abortion - does that mean that abortion is ok?

No it means that they are seriously misinformed (or even that they have been deceived by the surrounding society or have deceived themselves).

All are to live chastity. If some Christians are misinformed about what that means that is that is their misinformation.

Such does not change the reality of what chastity (marital chastity) is and what is gravely sinful in itself as an act contrary to that chastity and marriage itself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top