Mathematics: Man-made or Divinely Created?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JMJ_coder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
All truth is true to everyone.
Not so. The statement “My brother’s name is David” is not true to everyone. It is a relative truth, or a relative falsehood. This does not, of course, mean that I do and do not have a brother named David. 🙂
 
Not so. The statement “My brother’s name is David” is not true to everyone. It is a relative truth, or a relative falsehood. This does not, of course, mean that I do and do not have a brother named David. 🙂
False. It is relative truth in that your brother is a relative. 🙂

But the statement is true for all of us. “Your brother’s name is David” is how I would express that same truth. All speakers of English understand personal pronouns. In fact, I believe all human beings who have mastered any language understand personal pronouns. It is not the words that are true or false, it is the concept that is being expressed by the words.

Back to Math.

1.9999… + 1.9999… = 4
and
2 + 2 = 4

Two statements, differently expressed, both stating the same truth. It is not the statement but truth that remains.

or

The sum of the squares of the lengths of the legs of a right triangle equals the square of the length of the hypotenuese.

is true and can also be expressed as

The sum of the squares of the two shortest sides of a right triangle equals the square of the length of the longest side.

Not two truths, but one. Expressed differently. The truth remains, the expression changes.
 
False. It is relative truth in that your brother is a relative. 🙂

But the statement is true for all of us. “Your brother’s name is David” is how I would express that same truth. All speakers of English understand personal pronouns. In fact, I believe all human beings who have mastered any language understand personal pronouns. It is not the words that are true or false, it is the concept that is being expressed by the words.

Back to Math.

1.9999… + 1.9999… = 4
and
2 + 2 = 4

Two statements, differently expressed, both stating the same truth. It is not the statement but truth that remains.

or

The sum of the squares of the lengths of the legs of a right triangle equals the square of the length of the hypotenuese.

is true and can also be expressed as

The sum of the squares of the two shortest sides of a right triangle equals the square of the length of the longest side.

Not two truths, but one. Expressed differently. The truth remains, the expression changes.
To be clear, Evan: I agree with you that there is only one truth, expressed differently from different perspectives. But, in terms of propositional truth, there are epistemological difficulties here. For example, Descartes says, “I think, therefore I am.” This almost certainly was objective truth at the moment he wrote it. But this is not adequate evidence to prove – beyond the kind of doubt that Descartes was considering – that Descartes existed. It is not adequate to say: “Descartes thinks, therefore Descartes exists”. This misses the meaning of the statement.

Or consider: I say “I think, therefore I exist.” Do *you *know that I think?

The idea of relative (or subjective) truth is that this type of truth cannot accessed from every perspective, but only one perspective. Relative truth is no less true. But the distinction between absolute and relative truth is a useful distinction.
 
To be clear, Evan: I agree with you that there is only one truth, expressed differently from different perspectives.
ok then.
But, in terms of propositional truth, there are epistemological difficulties here. .
Save me from feature creep 😦 Now we have to accept the propositional logic. Moving from discussing truth to a discussion of hypotheses and conclusions.
For example, Descartes says, “I think, therefore I am.” This almost certainly **was objective truth **at the moment he wrote it.
or to reduce verbiage… was true
But this is not adequate evidence to prove – beyond the kind of doubt that Descartes was considering – that Descartes existed.
I hope it would, at least, prove to Descarte his own existence.
It is not adequate to say: “Descartes thinks, therefore Descartes exists”. This misses the meaning of the statement.

Or consider: I say “I think, therefore I exist.” Do *you *know that I think?
Here we have a proposition with a hypthosis and conclusion and a logical inference.

IF the hypothesis is true, and the inference is valid, then the conclusion is true.

You seem to be arguing… is the hypothesis true? Either it is or it isn’t. It does not matter if I know it is true or not, either it is or it isn’t.
The idea of relative (or subjective) truth is that this type of truth cannot accessed from every perspective, but only one perspective. Relative truth is no less true. But the distinction between absolute and relative truth is a useful distinction.
The access only provides insight into truth, the truth stands on it’s own. Many things I cannot know. …

The Trinity is a truth. I cannot prove it. Is it relative truth in your expressions of truth?
I can prove the existence of many orders of infinity, perhaps you cannot. Does this make the orders absolute for me and relative for you? Or absolute for me and a subjective truth for you?

It seems if a perspective can be found where something is true, then when the statement is made, the perspective should be assumed that makes it true. We are sloppy with our language. So when I say

1.9999… + 1.9999… = 4 I should properly lay down all the implied assumptions behind such a statement. Similar to the ‘My bro’s name is Joe’. Assumption: My refers to some guy who made the statement, bro is a biological offspring of the same parents, Joe is the appelation used to identify him within that family. We assume other people can figure out the appropriate situation. If not we provide additional info.

Like my daughter is J (ok foster daughter) … was true?
She was adopted, became S … was true?
She changed her name to C … is true?
But I can still say to my wife: our daughter J because J refers to the person, not the appelation used to identify her. She will always be our daughter. True then always true. Even though subsequent activities make it not true AT THIS TIME (in our perspective) we can mutually put ourselves in the perspective that recalls a truth underlying many alternate perspectives. If someone wished to argue with me, I would need to add context, but I know it is true even if this person did not know us/her at that time.
 
What do you think – is mathematics a product of human invention alone or is there a divinely created substance behind it?
This sounds like the paper my husband had to write for his *Philosophy of Mathematics *class last semester.
 
The Trinity is a truth. I cannot prove it. Is it relative truth in your expressions of truth?
I can prove the existence of many orders of infinity, perhaps you cannot. Does this make the orders absolute for me and relative for you? Or absolute for me and a subjective truth for you?
No, you’re right. Really, what I was saying is that there are relative *statements of *truth, authentic experiences of two separate “truths” that only amount to one objective truth. For example, a colorblind person (Bob) might *see *blue where I see purple. This does not mean the object is two colors, nor does it mean that Bob and I are looking at different things. There are two valid statements of the perceived color of the object, but both of these statements are ultimately objective truth – but truth *about *perception.

To simplify, we can call “truth about perception” relative truth. But this does not make it any less absolute. And, as you are indicating, the simplification can be – in certain contexts – deceptive.
 
Truth is a value, and like any value it is a relationship between at least two (in this case abstract) entities. So truth is, in the strictest sense, relative.
some truths are relative to perspective, but not all.
I exist. You can say that this is relative to a time and space, but it is still an eternal truth that i experience my existence in the here and now; and when I’m gone it will be an eternal truth that i did exist at some point in time and space. That there are things which exist, is not a relative concept. Objectively speaking there is not a place in which you can find absolute nothingness, since there is no such thing as absolute nothingness; nothing is not real, because it doesn’t exist objectively. This is not a relative or a subjective truth. Its an objective truth. You cannot find “absolute nothing” in objective reality.
Mathematical truth is determined relative to a language and a truth value system–nowadays usually a formal system. 1+1=2 is only true, for example, under an appropriate system, such as the Peano axioms and N. However, we can construct arbitrary systems under which 1+1=2 is false (e.g. a group ( { -1,1,2 }, + ) where e=2, -1=1^{-1} and x+x=x^{-1} for any x in { -1,1,2 } ). In other systems 1+1 is true but not exclusively true (e.g. the integers modulo 2, where 1+1=0).
When you change the constructive rules of mathematics, different answers result. This does not mean that 2 + 2, given the correct set of rules does not equal 4. When i see two cars, i see two cars. There is quantity in nature, and thus there is a basis for objective mathematical truth. Otherwise scientific measurement is fallacious in terms of revealing the truth about nature, or coming to understand how to design something according to spec.
 
Am I the only one fascinated with the concept of pi? It’s interesting that a circle’s diameter fits around its circumference exactly 3.16… times. However, the number of decimal places that pi goes to never ends (it’s irrational).

Anyone ever wonder why God didn’t set pi to exactly 3?
lol wtf? I can’t tell if this post is a joke or not…

:banghead:

…God did say that pi equals 3.

I Kings 7:23-26

He made the Sea of cast metal, circular in shape, measuring ten cubits from rim to rim and five cubits high. It took a line of thirty cubits to measure around it. Below the rim, gourds encircled it – ten to a cubit. The gourds were cast in two rows in one piece with the Sea. The Sea stood on twelve bulls, three facing north, three facing west, three facing south and three facing east. The Sea rested on top of them, and their hindquarters were toward the center. It was a handbreadth in thickness, and its rim was like the rim of a cup, like a lily blossom. It held two thousand baths.

If God created mathematics, he wasn’t the God of the Bible, because he got it wrong.

But anyways, this whole discussion is rediculous. Steps to realizing this are things like knowing that there is nothing special about base 10, and physics equations like linear velocity = Initial velocity + (acceleration x time) can logicaly never be any other way. Mathematics is not dependant on a creator.
 
Steps to realizing this are things like knowing that there is nothing special about base 10, and physics equations like linear velocity = Initial velocity + (acceleration x time) can logically never be any other way. Mathematics is not dependant on a creator.
Mathematics is dependent on there being such a thing as existence, and thus it is dependent on a creator, accept not in the same sense as a being that is moved or caused in to existence. Any mathematical truth that is necessarily true of beings, rather then tautological, is an abstraction of being; and tautological truths are higher levels of abstraction which also relies on the reality of being but does not reflect the truth of any being, other then that there is such a thing as** reality**. Mathematics is not a being by itself. Absolute Being precedes mathematical truth, for there is no truth in absolute nothingness. Mathematics is an abstraction of the ontological order .
 
Thanks for the replies.

Some math, though, I cannot imagine being anything other than human inventiveness – such as imaginary numbers. 🤷
 
lol wtf? I can’t tell if this post is a joke or not…

:banghead:

…God did say that pi equals 3.

I Kings 7:23-26

He made the Sea of cast metal, circular in shape, measuring ten cubits from rim to rim and five cubits high. It took a line of thirty cubits to measure around it. Below the rim, gourds encircled it – ten to a cubit. The gourds were cast in two rows in one piece with the Sea. The Sea stood on twelve bulls, three facing north, three facing west, three facing south and three facing east. The Sea rested on top of them, and their hindquarters were toward the center. It was a handbreadth in thickness, and its rim was like the rim of a cup, like a lily blossom. It held two thousand baths.

If God created mathematics, he wasn’t the God of the Bible, because he got it wrong.

But anyways, this whole discussion is rediculous. Steps to realizing this are things like knowing that there is nothing special about base 10, and physics equations like linear velocity = Initial velocity + (acceleration x time) can logicaly never be any other way. Mathematics is not dependant on a creator.
You may find these links interesting:

PI in the Bible
The Number PI in the Bible
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top