Matthew's generations

  • Thread starter Thread starter RobinHood
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

RobinHood

Guest
Matt. 1:17 says: “so all the generations from Abraham to David [are] fourteen generations; and from David until the carrying away into Babylon [are] fourteen generations; and from the carrying away into Babylon unto Christ [are] fourteen generations.”

The question now is very simple: Why do the verses from Matt. 1:2 up to 1:16 give only 13 generations for the last period, and NOT 14 - 14 - 14 as stated in Matt. 1:17

Thank you in advance for your help
God Bless
Robin
 
Was Jechoniah counted both before and after the exile?

Or was Mary counted as a generation along with Jospeh and Jesus?

-Tim-
 
Was Jechoniah counted both before and after the exile?

Or was Mary counted as a generation along with Jospeh and Jesus?

-Tim-
I doubt Mary was counted as a generation along with Joseph and Jesus since this wasn’t done in the other examples from the same list when the mother was mentionned.

RobinHood
 
Here is a quote from the Aquinas Study Bible
1:17 fourteen generations: If we begin by counting Abraham, and end with Christ, we have but 41 generations; hence, apparently, a name must be repeated or supplied to make up the three fourteens, or 42. By putting David at the end of the first series and beginning of the second, we shall have: Abraham, 1 David, 14; David, 1 Josias 14; Jechonias, 1 Christ, 14. The repetition of David’s name is suggested by the Evangelist himself; From Abraham to David. From David to the transmigration; making David the head of the second fourteen, and therefore to be counted as much as Abraham is of the first. There were in reality more than three fourteens, but for some mysterious reason of his own, St. Matthew, who omitted some generations (see v. 8), wishes to divide the entire into three fourteens, according to the catalogue of names expressed by himself. (Bishop John McEvilly) For the generations, exactly numbered, are only thirteen in the first group of fourteen, as you will see if you count the recurrence of the word “begat;” which word is repeated thirteen times; because in it alone Abraham is reckoned the first, and David the last generation. But in the second group of fourteen, David, the first in it, is not reckoned; nor yet in the third, Jeconias the first name; because those persons have been already named and enumerated as the last in the second and third groups of fourteen. Therefore, in the third group of fourteen, one generation must be added—namely, Jehoiakim begat Jehoiachin—in order that it may consist of fourteen generations; that is to say, of fourteen persons begetting and begotten, as I have already said. All the generations then are precisely forty-one; but the persons begetting and begotten are forty-two, because the generation of the first—namely, Abraham—is not reckoned here, but is presupposed as being known from the Book of Genesis. (Cornelius a Lapide)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top